9 ms·
When Did Life First Emerge in the Universe?
- theparanoid 6y agoA more interesting paper is Life Before Earth, https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3381 https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3381, analyzing biological complexity and projecting into the past for an origin of 9.7 billion years ago.
- OnlyOneCannolo 6y ago> These attempts to explain the presumed origin of life on Earth are strikingly similar to stretching and shrinking of time scales in Biblical Genesis to fit preconceptions (Schroeder, 1990). That's one hell of a refutation.
- gus_massa 6y agoThe definition of minimal life as a thing with a single nucleotide is weird. If I have to pick an arbitrary number, I'd choose at least 100. (Anyway, with their model they get that when the Earth appeared, "life" had ~10000 nucleotides.) > In particular, photosynthesis or chemosynthesis is needed to be independent from organic resources. It's weird because the current estimation is that photosynthesis appeared like 1000 millions years after the fist cell. So if this article were correct and the initial cells population came from space, they probably would no have photosynthesis.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoWhatever existed prior to life probably had life-like qualities, but couldn't fully meet the criteria, e.g., viruses. So even 0 nucleotides could make sense, if this prototypical organism had other features, and at some point, nucleotides arrived later.
- gus_massa 6y agoWhen the chains are very small, you can start to hope you are lucky and get the correct one. The ocean has 1.3 * 10^18 m^3 (3.5 * 10^20 gallons). If we assume 1 random DNA chain per cubic meter, that is like 4^30, so it's enough to have all the chains with 30 bases. (With 1 molecule per cm^3, you get like 10 more bases in locations for random chains.) It's actually more complicated, because shallow part of the sea or fumes near ocean rigs may have more concentration, and 1 molecule per cubic meter is a very low concentration. Anyway, extrapolating to 1 base is too extreme. Also, they had a nice fit for DNA based life, and they discuss the RNA World hypothesis, but it's not clear that the fit for DNA can be extrapolated to the RNA or whatever was used before. (There is a recent paper that propose a mix of RNA and DNA instead of a pure RNA word. We still don't know.)
- CryptoPunk 6y agoThe implication of this study is that life on Earth could be amongst the longest in development, which would be a solution to the Fermi paradox.
- stcredzero 6y agoSee also Issac Arthur's Civilizations at the Beginning of Time https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OytOJdGsrA0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OytOJdGsrA0
- jimmyed 6y ago> "When Did Life First Emerge in the Universe?" > "We don't know ..." Why does SA have to use such a clickbait-y title?
- xenophonf 6y agoWell, in their defense, we have an upper bound...
- mcphage 6y ago> Why does SA have to use such a clickbait-y title? Because it's a good question, and the subject of the article.
- wombatmobile 6y agoSomewhat relatedly, the article reads like a plea for funding. It's not just an "interesting story", it's an attempt to justify why the story should be further researched: > Our actions will be a source of pride for our descendants if they sustain a civilization intelligent enough to endure for trillions of years. Here’s hoping that we will act wisely enough to be remembered favorably in their “big history” books.
- drewcoo 6y agoIn the hope that young earth creationists might read it and learn something?
- noja 6y agoSo people click it. Really. That's the answer. For impressions.
- 01100011 6y agoWhat if intelligent, self-aware systems existed in the earlier phases of the universe? Would they have understood the changes taking place in the universe, their eventual demise, and taken steps to allow life of a new form to emerge after the universal condensation? Obviously there is no way of knowing, but it was an amusing thought to consider for a moment.
- buttercraft 6y agoWould this not apply today?
- newacct583 6y agoThere are such systems. And we're in fact making a very feeble attempt to do exactly that. Right here. In this thread on HN.
- agumonkey 6y agoearlier you mean pre big bang ?
- krastanov 6y agoMore like the extremely hot early universe, e.g., before the universe became transparent to the cosmic background radiation (<1M years after the Big Bang).
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> before the universe became transparent to the cosmic background radiation (<1M years after the Big Bang) There were millions of years when the universe was transparent and room temperature [1]. [1] https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journal-of-astrobiology/article/abs/habitable-epoch-of-the-early-universe/114595C6E860A5002A9B783875602106 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/international-journa...
- raducu 6y ago
- foolfoolz 6y agowhat if we are just some primitive form of rock compared to the real life in the universe and they don’t give a fuck about us at all?
- BurningFrog 6y agoThen we have to defeat them!
- wruza 6y agoFirst they ignore you, then they 0x000000b7a831...c0 at you, then they 0x00000000f021...72 you, then you 0x000000000000...6b.
- raducu 6y agoThere's got to be limits to biological and technological evolution. After all, it took ~billions of years for life to evolve on Earth and we're not immensely different than a monkey or dog. Also, we have very few genes compared to all other animals, we're like a 7zip of genetic information, each gene coding multiple proteins, a spaghetti dna code that's very good at what it does, but surely it limits evolution. If there is anything at all to evolve at, intelligence/emotional wise. What would a human or alien species with an iq of 1000 be able to achieve vs what we can achieve in the exact same Universe?
- adrian_b 6y agoIt is very difficult for us to imagine which would be the abilities of a "more intelligent" alien species. On the other hand, it is very easy to imagine an alien species that would have the same intelligence as humans, except that its thinking speed would be several orders of magnitude higher, because it would not be limited by the slow velocities of ions in liquids, like in the animal nervous systems. The interactions between us and such aliens could be like the interactions between a sea star and us, even if they would not have a higher IQ.
- wruza 6y agoit took ~billions of years for life to evolve on Earth ~80% of time waiting for Oxygen Catastrophe, which was random (but was result of evolution, nonetheless). It wasn’t like start, billions of years, end. Organisms that we call non-bacteria non-algae are less than a billion years old, roughly.
- throwaway98797 6y agoThe Last Question https://www.physics.princeton.edu//ph115/LQ.pdf https://www.physics.princeton.edu//ph115/LQ.pdf
- catlifeonmars 6y ago> A complementary strategy is to search for technological signals from early distant civilizations that harnessed enough energy to make them detectable across the vast cosmic scale. > Communication signals are not expected to be detectable across the universe, because the signal travel time would require billions of years in each direction and no participant would be patient enough to engage in such a slow exchange of information. So effectively what we could search for is energy pollution from construction and transportation operations. Although it seems obvious in retrospect, it never occurred to me that intentional communication signals would not have the appropriate characteristics to be detectable across vast distances of space and time.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoWouldn't the signal travel time of energy pollution be the speed of light? Certainly faster than the speed of sound, but still geological timescales.
- ben_w 6y agoSure, but if all you want is an existence proof, it’s still possibly better because it removes the requirement that whoever made the noise needs to still be there (FSVO “still” given how simultaneity behaves in relatively). OTOH, also worse because it’s unlikely to be directional, so the output would have to be powerful even compared to the galaxy it’s part of for an intergalactic detection.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI feel a lot of our ideas are no longer valid is the other species has biological immortality. Then travel time to another star doesnt require antimatter, it just needs a long nap
- 7thaccount 6y agoNot as likely, but still fun to speculate about is biological life being a transitory phenomena as Paul Davies (of SETI) postulates. Once you've become a machine civilization (either we build them or upload ourselves and become them), travel at lightspeed becomes possible and so do all kinds of nifty ideas.
- imvetri 6y agoLife is an illusion and We do not have any choice in our actions. Just like how the planets and stars do their work, we do ours and makes us no different from non-living things.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoLife does not imply free will.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSome people believe (i.e. have faith) that free will exist, even though it is by definition a supernatural entity. Some people, like what you say, do not have faith in free will. I find it funny when nonbelievers profess to know the truth with such certainty. Why did their carbon atoms have to type this on HN?
- solipsism 6y ago"supernatural" is undefined and it's untestable. You start with meaninglessness, and then you're suprised when rational thinkers say they don't believe in the nonsense?
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIn not sure if you chose to comment on this ;)
- solipsism 6y agoChoices are real. Free will is not.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoSounds like an axiom for a small subset of humans. Like all axioms, unfortunately it can not be proven: https://www.sscc.edu/home/jdavidso/Math/Goedel.html https://www.sscc.edu/home/jdavidso/Math/Goedel.html
- therufa 6y ago> When Did Life First Emerge in the Universe? May 13th 1936; the date when "they" rolled out the "life" patch ocf
- Aardwolf 6y agoIf there was some life going on in the very fast moving first nanoseconds of the big bang, to them the time where we live in now is probably what they'd call the heath death
- divs1210 6y agoWhen the universe first emerged
- GistNoesis 6y agoDecember 23, 1947 : Before that the various chemical information processing machines that were used to bootstrap life where running at roughly 1Hz frequency. A frequency so slow that the billions of years elapsed since the creation of the universe, used negligible computation power compared to the resources needed for a single second one century later when the simulation had to be halted having exhausted all computational credits.
- iso1210 6y agoYou're assuming that nowhere in the entire universe of trillions of planets did a transistor get created before then?
- sigzero 6y agoCorrect
- LogicUpgrade 6y agoThis is funny, because the universe has so much compute available, every particle spawns a new universe millions of times a second, and it's still nowhere close to running out of compute.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoAs, the infinite multiverse rears its unfalsifiable head ;)
- GistNoesis 6y agoDoes it ? It kinds of depend on how you simulate the universe. There are shortcuts. Particles are not fundamental. Information is. It begs the question : how much information is there in a drop of water ? Does the algorithm has to simulate every one of the water molecules, or can it adaptively only needs to preserve the macroscopic quantities while preserving the consistency of the microscopic level (aka information conservation). Most physical phenomenons exhibit some degree of self synchronization, and self similarity, witness of some kind of information redundancy. It happens at all scales of the universe, from particles which self-organize into crystals, spinning rocks coalescing into planets, stars forming black-holes to store information on their surface instead of the volume. All these physics rules allow huge speed-up in computation, because once a quantity doesn't change, a billion years for a billion stars can go in an instant. Information is conserved, but information wants to diffuse. That is the cosmic entropic battle which life is fighting. Life are the computations which can't be shortcutted.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoBy clicking the link we will never know when life first emerged in the universe, but Scientific American will get concrete money from ad revenue.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIf life is part of a phase transition of matter, then it is absolutely flourishing everywhere within the universe, which is larger than our minds can grasp. My favorite thought experiment is imagining a future earth civilization that does check everywhere in the universe and then it finds no signs of life now or in the past.
- Ekaros 6y agoI have been kinda interested on how old a civilisation with human like technology could be. That is at what point is there planets with sufficient amounts of heavier elements like Iron and stuff needed for semi-conductors. As with search for radio signals somehow those need to be generated. Further leads to question when such planets cooled enough to have reasonable atmospheres that are not too hot. After all these are some constraints. On other hand good question is how much faster evolution of more "complex" life could have been.
- AnonC 6y agoLife as we know it on earth came about very, very late in the age of the universe. That’s not just fascinating (as facts about the universe generally are), but also highly surprising. That we’re here now seems to be a big fluke. Considering how much humans have evolved in understanding things around us and having the capacity as a species to create larger and coordinated changes, the daily news we see is generally such a huge disappointment. “Squandering” doesn’t even cover what we’re doing to the only planet we can inhabit for now. > But life’s signatures will not last forever. The prospects for life in the distant future are gloomy. The dark and frigid conditions that will result from the accelerated expansion of the universe by dark energy will likely extinguish all forms of life 10 trillion years from now. Until then, we could cherish the temporary gifts that nature had blessed us with. Our actions will be a source of pride for our descendants if they sustain a civilization intelligent enough to endure for trillions of years. Let’s hope we’re able to give the gift of wonder and awe to many more generations to come.
- Koshkin 6y ago> very, very late But rather soon after Earth has cooled down (i.e. about 1 billion years since the planet has formed), which is more relevant. > seems to be a big fluke So, no, it doesn't.
- jacquesm 6y agoEarth orbits a second generation star. So the first generation had to form and live to the end of its sequence before the stellar explosion created the heavier elements that our solar system is made out of. Without that life is very hard to imagine. So a lot of this 'delay' is perfectly natural, life may not have had a chance to emerge much sooner in this particular solar system than it did.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoBlue hypergiants only last about 10 million years. What really is necessary to know, I believe there is still debate, is whether main sequence supernovae can generate all the necessary elements. I believe gold and heavier are might not be possible with normal supernovae and may require neutron star mergers to generate. I believe earth tectonics, not a small aspect of Earth's long term stability/cycle, need radioactives to maintain a liquid core (not to mention the magnetic shield provided by the core). Still, an earth like world in a mostly stable/quiet area of a galaxy may be possible only a few billion years after the big bang with some luck with blue hypergiants and a lucky neutron star merger, if that is in fact necessary for heavy elements and radioactives.
- ARandomerDude 6y agoDay 3.
- Koshkin 6y agoThe universe is (too) big, so we may never know.