4 ms·
The part about "give up stock options for nothing" sounds awfully close to a threat to retaliate against workers for unionizing. In that context, it comes acros
by jcranmer 6y ago
The part about "give up stock options for nothing" sounds awfully close to a threat to retaliate against workers for unionizing. In that context, it comes across rather close to the stereotypical mob indirect threat: "Nice house you have there; shame if something were to happen to it."
My personal feelings are that if a company needs to resort to threats and retaliation to prevent unionization, then the workers do deserve to unionize, because the company clearly is willing to trample on any worker who dares threaten its authority, and only collective action on the workers' part is likely to counter that.
- josephcsible 6y agoThat was never intended as a threat and was clarified years ago: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/999415738967277568 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/999415738967277568 TL;DR of the thread: he was warning that UAW would get rid of the stock options, following their track record with other automakers.
- jeltz 6y agoIf it was never intended as a threat I see no issue for him to follow the court order and delete the tweet and apologize for the misunderstanding. Furthermore this is not just about the tweet but also about a series of other anti-union actions from Tesla.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 6y ago> If it was never intended as a threat The "just a prank, bro" defense?
- jjulius 6y agoOkay, but what's stopping him from fighting for that? Between his initial offending tweet, and the clarification tweet that you just shared, he makes it sound like it's important to him that his employees have stock options. He could have said that he/Tesla have been trying to get those included but UAW refuses. Instead, he just says, "Well they usually don't, so I mean it's your call if you want to lose them or not, /shrug." If he cared, he'd put in the effort. Instead, he's just citing precedent in the form of a vague threat instead of being the "cool CEO" people make him out to be and trying to do some good.
- detaro 6y agoI mean, being rude against the "uncool people" (whoever he thinks that is today) is a big part of his "cool CEO" brand, consequences be damned.
- colechristensen 6y agoIt is probably more of a reflection that unionis generally oppose stock options and they get negotiated out of contracts.
- Rule35 6y agoPresumably he can change compensation easily, as long as it's equivalent. A company a friend was at made the change and they got more money (than they'd have made with RSUs that were sold at acquisition). The 'more' part made it legal without renegotiating. Removing stock options just means that many fewer communionists have a say over other matters in the company because they won't buy stock.