5 ms·
Musk tweeted “Nothing stopping Tesla team at our car plant from voting union. Could do so tmrw if they wanted. But why pay union dues & give up stock options fo
by colechristensen 6y ago
Musk tweeted “Nothing stopping Tesla team at our car plant from voting union. Could do so tmrw if they wanted. But why pay union dues & give up stock options for nothing? Our safety record is 2X better than when plant was UAW & everybody already gets healthcare.”
And there are big regulations about not doing anti union things.
I, for one, can’t see anything particularly wrong with this tweet and don’t really care what the law says, I’m opposed to unions and labor boards having the power to silence somebody saying this.
- anon_tor_12345 6y ago> I, for one, can’t see anything particularly wrong with this tweet and don’t really care what the law says you really don't see the difference between just anyone saying this and the employer saying this? what you personally feel about unions is irrelevant; there is a very clear imposition of power over the employee here and manifestly why the laws are as strict as they are. just so no one willfully misconstrues what i'm saying: what's at issue here is that the employee's continued employment is contingent on their employer's opinion of them hence this is tantamount to an overt threat. saying you don't see anything wrong with what he said is like saying you see anything wrong with a teacher implying quid pro quo for sexual favors from students.
- temp8964 6y agoIs quid pro quo for sexual favors from students legal? Is change payment schedule after unionization legal?
- seoaeu 6y agoNeither is legal, I'm not sure what your point is?
- temp8964 6y agoNo. The second is legal.
- seoaeu 6y agoCutting workers' pay as retaliation for unionizing is illegal.
- temp8964 6y agoIt is not retaliation at all. Unionization changes how the company works, payment can be changed accordingly.
- ceejayoz 6y agohttps://www.shrm.org/ResourcesAndTools/tools-and-samples/hr-qa/Pages/preventunionorganization.aspx https://www.shrm.org/ResourcesAndTools/tools-and-samples/hr-... > The acronym TIPS can help remind employers not to: > * Threaten—never threaten to retaliate against employees by terminating them or reducing pay or benefits. > * Interrogate—do not interrogate employees about their activities or activities of co-workers. > * Promise—do not promise anything to employees, such as promotio ns or benefits, in exchange for not supporting the union. > * Surveillance/Spying—never spy on union activities.
- anon_tor_12345 6y agoThere's a list a mile long of court cases at all federal levels that disagree with you. So I'm just curious according to what definition of legal do you think it's legal?
- brokenkebab 6y ago>there is a very clear imposition of power over the employee here Hm, where is this imposition of power? I see what could be clearly called bargaining. Btw, my apologies if this sounds too harsh, but comparing it to "sexual favors" not only absolutely meaningless, but probably qualifies as a dirty emotional trick aimed at ungrounded shaming of those who disagree with you.
- anon_tor_12345 6y ago>Hm, where is this imposition of power? I see what could be clearly called bargaining. Isn't this ironic? The whole point of a union is collective bargaining power; individual employees do not have any bargaining power so how exactly is musk engaging in bargaining? With whom is he bargaining? >but comparing it to "sexual favors" not only absolutely meaningless, They're both examples of coercion by someone with power over a subordinate, they both involve trading your body (in the form of labor or sex) for money (or some sort of compensation), and they're both generally recognized as exploitative. These are three obvious features that make them analogous propositions.
- Rule35 6y ago> They're both examples of coercion by someone with power over a subordinate, No, the teacher is (indirectly) your employee and it doesn't matter. If they threaten to withhold a grade you've earned it's clearly criminal, regardless of the threat used. > they both involve trading your body (in the form of labor or sex) for money (or some sort of compensation) If prostitution and a job are the same then it means prostitution isn't bad. But maybe your equivalency is wrong. > they're both generally recognized as exploitative I bet you'd say that letting your starve by not hiring you would be exploitative too.
- anon_tor_12345 6y agoliterally every single rebuttal you've written here is a red herring.
- 6y ago
- colechristensen 6y agoThe union is trying to exercise power as well, I have no problem with Elon saying that, and that it is a far cry from... actual anti union tactics. Preventing propaganda campaigns, threats, lies, etc shouldn’t be lumped in with making a straightforward argument against unions — when that point is reached i think union power has gotten too strong and i no longer support it.
- temp8964 6y agoAlso first amendment. Why can't CEO say anti-union things? Are they allowed to say pro-union things?
- ceejayoz 6y agoEmployees have rights, too. When they conflict with each other, the courts get involved. They've repeatedly done so on this issue. https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/495/associated-press-v-national-labor-relations-board https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/495/associated-... > In addressing the First Amendment issue, Roberts observed that although the AP claimed to have discharged the employee for biased reporting, the record revealed the actual reason to be his union activity, which had no bearing on First Amendment issues: “The business of the Associated Press is not immune from regulation because it is an agency of the press. The publisher of a newspaper has no special immunity from the application of general laws. He has no special privilege to invade the rights and liberties of others.”
- temp8964 6y agoHow did he invade employees' rights?
- ceejayoz 6y agoEmployees have specific rights under the National Labor Relations Act, which has long held up to Constitutional review by the Supreme Court, to organize unions without this sort of retaliation or other "unfair labor practices". https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/158 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/158 Musk would similarly find himself in trouble if he said, say, "OHSA rules are bullshit and you don't have to follow them", despite it being First Amendment speech.
- temp8964 6y agoWhere is the retaliation? He is stating the change of payment schedule after the unionization. This is not allowed?
- baryphonic 6y agoDoes labor law supersede Musk's first amendment rights? I don't get it.
- tablespoon 6y ago> Does labor law supersede Musk's first amendment rights? I don't get it. I don't think first amendment rights mean you have the right to literally say or write whatever you want, such as a threat, without consequence. And Musk did make a threat, it was just a milder one than to send in the Pinkertons.
- seoaeu 6y agoUm, yes? Same way that libel laws supersede first amendment rights. None of the rights in the constitution are absolute, especially when they conflict with each other
- baryphonic 6y agoLibel law explicitly applies only to factual claims that are false and damaging to another person's reputation. Opinions, including the ones Elon Musk expressed, would very clearly be protected speech in the context of libel law. Why these restrictions on libel law? Well, because of the First Amendment. Again, why should the courts restrict libel law to such a degree but allow labor law to dictate what opinions someone can or cannot express? (We can all accept, I hope, that Musk's tweet was his opinion.) Also, which constitutional rights are in conflict here? Labor law is just enacted law, not constitutional in nature. If labor law conflicts with the Constitution, the Constitution wins.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoUm, does the law on blackmail supersede first amendment? How about death threats or recruitment for ISIS? Obviously extreme examples, but making a point that first amendment has many things it does not protect.
- baryphonic 6y agoExpressing an opinion online about unionization issues is equivalent to blackmail, death threats and recruitment for ISIS? What? I wasn't asking about whether terroristic threats were legitimate exceptions to First Amendment protections; I asked whether labor law was.
- jcranmer 6y agoThe part about "give up stock options for nothing" sounds awfully close to a threat to retaliate against workers for unionizing. In that context, it comes across rather close to the stereotypical mob indirect threat: "Nice house you have there; shame if something were to happen to it." My personal feelings are that if a company needs to resort to threats and retaliation to prevent unionization, then the workers do deserve to unionize, because the company clearly is willing to trample on any worker who dares threaten its authority, and only collective action on the workers' part is likely to counter that.
- josephcsible 6y agoThat was never intended as a threat and was clarified years ago: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/999415738967277568 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/999415738967277568 TL;DR of the thread: he was warning that UAW would get rid of the stock options, following their track record with other automakers.
- jeltz 6y agoIf it was never intended as a threat I see no issue for him to follow the court order and delete the tweet and apologize for the misunderstanding. Furthermore this is not just about the tweet but also about a series of other anti-union actions from Tesla.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 6y ago> If it was never intended as a threat The "just a prank, bro" defense?
- jjulius 6y agoOkay, but what's stopping him from fighting for that? Between his initial offending tweet, and the clarification tweet that you just shared, he makes it sound like it's important to him that his employees have stock options. He could have said that he/Tesla have been trying to get those included but UAW refuses. Instead, he just says, "Well they usually don't, so I mean it's your call if you want to lose them or not, /shrug." If he cared, he'd put in the effort. Instead, he's just citing precedent in the form of a vague threat instead of being the "cool CEO" people make him out to be and trying to do some good.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoI'm opposed to laws supporting unions in general. If workers want to voluntarily get together and agree to bargain collectively, that's great. That's really just individuals engaging in voluntary contracts. The issue is the way unions work (or at least my understanding, correct me if wrong) is that in many places once a union has taken hold, they actually get the right to prevent a non-unionized worker for working. That's absolutely crazy to me (and evil, and inefficient). --- Note: The above doesn't mean that Elon doesn't treat his workers like shit - he does. I wish people would see through the cult of personality with him, because so many workers have sustained injuries on the job or just burnt themselves out for someone who really doesn't care about them. The thing with trying to save humanity from existential threats, is ethically speaking you can justify sacrificing as many actual humans for the cause as necessary. But yeah, unions aren't the mechanism to fix that.
- seoaeu 6y ago> The issue is the way unions work (or at least my understanding, correct me if wrong) is that in many places once a union has taken hold, they actually get the right to prevent a non-unionized worker for working. Lots of states don't work that way (with "right to work" joining a union is always purely optional). The problem is that it empirically results in far worse outcomes for workers. With right to work unions are weaker because individuals can freeload off of the improvements in pay / working conditions achieved by a union without contributing back.
- ryathal 6y agoIt also provides a necessary check on unions, they have to provide a better service than base level employment. Many unions are taking dues while providing little to no benefits for large portions of their members.