5 ms·
>It rejected Uber's claim that the company itself was not liable, because, it argued, its drivers had the status of contractors rather than employees. Another
by Barrin92 6y ago
>It rejected Uber's claim that the company itself was not liable, because, it argued, its drivers had the status of contractors rather than employees.
Another absolutely fantastic aspect of the gig economy, absolutely no sense of institutional responsibility from anyone. Just a giant game of musical chairs where everyone can point at everyone else.
If a hotel discriminates because of disability or race or whatever else they risk the reputation of their entire business and trivial legal claims. If someone gets a racist Uber driver it's going to be 'they're just contractors dude, we don't know them!'. Shareholder capitalism at its finest. All of the profits, none of the accountability. I guess that is widely considered to be social progress nowadays.
Yet another reason that Uber has given countries to make them treat their drivers as employees.
- missedthecue 6y agoThis isn't specific to the gig economy? No one tends to jump at the chance to take responsibility for anything whether they are a company, charity, government, or small child.
- yunesj 6y agoSome contractors refuse to drive someone with a dog in their own car, even when refusing is illegal and against Uber policy. The person can sue the driver and Uber can take action against reported drivers. Is this only Uber’s fault because they have the deepest pockets? > racist drivers Uber has enabled servicing minority neighborhoods, following an era of medallion taxis that avoided those areas.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- notafraudster 6y agoAs the arbitrator suggests, it's Uber's fault because when the complaints got to Uber, they developed a program to help drivers evade responsibility by teaching them how to more effectively deny service to the disabled; refused to remove drivers that violated their rules from their platform; and failed to abide by a previous settlement they had entered into for doing the exact same thing; and they did this to her specifically over a dozen times despite her repeatedly asking them for help and trying to work through the system.
- anang 6y agoMore like: uber has two contracts, one between the themselves and the driver and one between themselves and the rider. If a driver is refusing rides based on race, then that is Uber’s problem. If they then want to pursue legal action against the driver, that should be entirely between Uber and the driver.
- emteycz 6y agoCould you please elaborate on alternatives to what you call "shareholder capitalism"? Are you proposing that people shouldn't own companies?
- Barrin92 6y agothe alternative is stakeholder capitalism. Giving workers, customers, and locals ownership in the business. I love people owning companies, but in my opinion it should be the workers and customers. In Germany for example, large companies are obligated to have a third of their voting seats be workers. If we want to fix Uber, why not start there. Give drivers a third of the seats at the table, and make it so that the management and ownership is as diverse as the people Uber serves. Would be interesting to hear if they have disabled people in management.
- emteycz 6y agoThank you, interesting idea