10 ms·
> In particular, how easy will distribution be, considering that HIV is extremely easily preventable but it still spreads, because of lack of distribution of kn
by heavyset_go 6y ago
> In particular, how easy will distribution be, considering that HIV is extremely easily preventable but it still spreads, because of lack of distribution of knowledge, I assume.
This is a huge problem in the US. Truvada must be taken everyday to prevent HIV, and in 2015, it cost $1400 for a 30 day supply. In 2021, it costs between $1900 and $2500+ for a 30 day supply in the US.
Elsewhere in the world, Truvada might cost $40. In Australia, Truvada costs $8 for a 30 day supply[1].
The only other drug approved for PrEP in the US is Descovy, which is manufactured by Gilead, too, and costs $2300+ minimum for a 30 day supply.
[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/aoc-hiv-drug-cost-us-australia-ceo-gilead-video-a8919316.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...
- rafale 6y agoWhy doesn't the US pass a law that prevent such large deprecencies? Is it because the legal landscape is different and pharmaceuticals companies worry about the cost of litigation in the US?
- GiorgioG 6y agoBecause the passage of laws is bought and paid for by corporations.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoBecause Big Pharma lobbies to prevent such laws from being imposed. There’s even a law that prevents Medicare from negotiating down the price of drugs, with obvious consequences.
- rtkwe 6y agoBecause the GOP is ideologically opposed to price controls (except when it's in the form of subsidies to their state's pet industry of course). Something, something, free market distortions I think is the usual reason.
- midasuni 6y agoDems control President, Senate and House
- rtkwe 6y agoYou know about the filibuster right? Republicans can filibuster (force infinite 'debate' though modern rules don't require people to actually talk during a filibuster any more [0]) anything they don't want to pass and it's up to extremely centrist (barely) Democrats like Joe Manchin if the filibuster remains. Without removing that it takes 10 Republican votes to stop debate on any bill. There are some work arounds but they're limited to things that one person decides are sufficiently budget related enough to go through the reconciliation process that prevents filibusters. And that is a thrice a year option at most. [0] I get why since senators have all sorts of commitments to their time even counting just Senate business but it means a there's basically no cost to doing one where there was.
- FentanylFloyd 6y ago> You know about the filibuster right? standard Dem excuse for being impotent and/or complicit
- stupendousyappi 6y agoFilibuster.
- madeofpalk 6y agoI think you’re misguided if you think this is a partisan issue. It’s an American issue where neither party has really adequately done anything about affordable healthcare and gouging like this.
- rtkwe 6y agoEverything that has been done or been tried has had to pass or be written under the specter of the filibuster though. It fundamentally limits the type of options that get through. The only major change in the last decade was Obamacare which is remarkably similar to the system passed under a the Republican Governorship of Mitt Romney. Democrats have some options they'd like to do that might help but cannot because of the filibuster. Reconciliation which is the only way around the filibuster guaranteed is pretty limited in scope due to the rules around it. Whether those could pass a vote if there was no filibuster is unknown because they all get completely blocked by Republican filibuster.
- contravariant 6y agoEnglish isn't my first language so I might be asking something obvious here, but what's a deprecency?
- edflsafoiewq 6y agoTypo of "discrepancy".
- EarthLaunch 6y agoSeems to indicate the status of the commenter.
- analogdreams 6y agoWe had a president that addressed this but people didn't like that he sent 'nasty' tweets. then his successor overturned the order and we all celebrated.
- actinium226 6y agoOK, I'm legitimately curious to know more. I do remember him talking about "making insulin as cheap as water" or something like that, but can you point me to the actual executive order or bill he was trying to pass that dealt with this issue of lowering the cost for prescriptions? A source about Biden overturning whatever it was would be great as well. I don't preclude Trump from having actually done something meaningful, but a lot of what he does is vain and self-promoting, so I could easily see this being a case where he tried to put something into effect that looks good on the surface but doesn't actually accomplish anything, or doesn't accomplish it in a sustainable way and thus would need to be revoked to prevent prices going up in the long term.
- fny 6y ago> ...can you point me to the actual executive order or bill he was trying to pass that dealt with this issue of lowering the cost for prescriptions? [0]: https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=trump+prescription+executive+order https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=trump+prescription+executive+... [1]: https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=biden+trump+prescription+executive+order https://letmegooglethat.com/?q=biden+trump+prescription+exec...
- monkeywork 6y agoThe condescending nature of using LMGT make me just ignore you.
- kmos17 6y agoI remember him making a lot of noise about making insulin super cheap or giving us the best and cheapest health plan to replace obamacare, he had a full 4 years in office to accomplish this, including two years with complete control of congress. So what exactly did he accomplish?
- missedthecue 6y agoWorth noting that no one pays $1400 a month. Their insurance covers it, just like insurance covers you in Australia or Germany or Canada or anywhere else.
- danm 6y agoBut then, doesn't that mean everyone with coverage pays for it?Insurance pays for it, and everyone with coverage pays for these high costs through high premiums -- public healthcare in Canada doesn't pay for drugs, and even without insurance the cost of those drugs tends to be substantially cheaper, at least in the few scenarios I've been exposed to.
- caspper69 6y agoMore likely it means you pay (or more appropriately, your insurance company pays) the negotiated rate, which is often far, far less than the published retail cost of a medication. Those big monthly $$s get investors excited tho. This is to say nothing of the public / private debate.
- missedthecue 6y agoInsurance doesn't pay $1400 either. I mean 225,000 Americans are on it, and multiply that by 1400 x 12, and you're already way past Truvada's global annual revenue. The numbers don't work out. Americans do subsidize European and African prices though, there's no doubt about that.
- ur-whale 6y agoMoney still has to come from somewhere.
- ojbyrne 6y agoIf you are insured and look at medical bills in the US you generally see an obscene top line cost, a very large discount that the insurance company negotiates, and your personal copay. That discount doesn’t really seem to come from somewhere.
- ddingus 6y agoCorruption. Seriously. It is both chronic and legal here.
- dudeinjapan 6y agoThe US had a president who tried. Yeah, that guy. https://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2020/11/20/fact-sheet-trump-administration-finalizes-proposal-to-lower-drug-costs.html https://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2020/11/20/fact-sheet-trump-a...
- at_a_remove 6y agoIt costs quite a lot to take any given new drug to market (one study suggested a median of 0.985 billion, and a mean of 1.3 billion), and most of them do not make it. They must recoup expenses somehow, or go broke, and then ... no new drugs. To that end, they get a limited period of exclusivity over their invention. Now, is this done efficiently? I don't know. Perhaps the FDA approval process could be less costly. Or we could limit litigation in some manner. And so on. But they're sure not gonna churn out new drugs for the cost of some generics.
- jackson1442 6y agoWhile I can appreciate that drugs _do_ cost money to manufacture, it does not mean that people should be expected to pay hundreds or thousands for a drug that is vital to their health.
- at_a_remove 6y agoThe money comes from somewhere. You can make it direct or you can make it indirect, but it is still coming from one bank account or another. Essentially, the US is footing the bill for the world. If you look at overseas pharmacies, PReP has been available (as are many drugs) at very cheap prices for quite a while now. Some countries just ignore the drug patents and go on their merry way. Our current method of accounting inside the US has people pay into insurance, which then pays out for these particular drugs.
- dillondoyle 6y agoOr pharma could not make profit/pay dividends? That seems like a much bigger 'cost' than FDA paperwork (though trials are expensive)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- at_a_remove 6y agoInstead of making a smart-ass comment, I was prompted by your reply to look. Some non-profit pharmas do exist, but it appears that they are largely focused on generics or orphan drugs. I have seen some press-release stuff on how some of them could work in drug discovery, but it was always a team-up with someone else, and I couldn't find what new drugs had actually made it to market from non-profit pharmas. I suppose the only way to really prove this one way or another would be to select the last thousand drugs to market globally, note the country of origin and the company, and whether or not they were for-profit or not. Perhaps build out on that -- how much did it cost to bring that to market? How many failed per pharma?
- mike00632 6y agoIt's relevant to mention that the patent for every component of Truvada will expire this September.
- techrat 6y agoNo guarantee the price will go down in the US as a result. An epilepsy medication I took, once the patents completely expired (both on the regular and extended release versions), the generics ended up costing me more to pick up while the branded version rose in price as well.
- pg_bot 6y agoIt typically takes about 6 months to 3 years for generic drug prices to decline due to how we approve generics in the USA. Most people don't know that we have an insane policy whereby the first generic drug applicant receives an extended period of market exclusivity. https://www.fda.gov/drugs/abbreviated-new-drug-application-anda/paragraph-iv-drug-product-applications-generic-drug-patent-challenge-notifications https://www.fda.gov/drugs/abbreviated-new-drug-application-a...
- ultimoo 6y agoI'm curious with what the motivation behind that rule is -- assuming there is one and the rule isn't a result of plain lobbying.
- refurb 6y ago"Most people don't know that we have an insane policy whereby the first generic drug applicant receives an extended period of market exclusivity." The US has some of the lowest cost generics in developed nations - prices tend to be lower than the EU. The US has some of the highest generic drug penetration of developed nations. [1] That's because of things like the 180 generic drug exclusivity and mandatory generic substitution laws. The 180 exclusivity is a big part of that. If you open the flood gates to any generic manufacturer, the margins disappear so quickly that some manufacturers won't even bother to try. By dangling a massive carrot whereby the generic manufacturers can quickly recoup costs and make a large profit, it drives generic companies to compete to the enter the market. When Lipitor went off patent, eleven generic companies entered the market and prices dropped 95%. The US generic market is one of the best functioning in the world. [1]https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5594322/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5594322/
- Quinner 6y agoInteresting that the UK-based Independent did this reporting without mentioning that the NHS still hasn't issued approval for Truvada to be provided outside of trial programs.
- est31 6y agoI googled your claim and found this: https://www.gaytimes.co.uk/life/prep-is-finally-available-on-the-nhs-how-can-i-get-it/ https://www.gaytimes.co.uk/life/prep-is-finally-available-on... http://www.pmlive.com/pharma_news/nhs_england_will_make_prep_for_hiv_available_in_april_1329238 http://www.pmlive.com/pharma_news/nhs_england_will_make_prep... So it seems that your claim is (thankfully) outdated.
- JoshGlazebrook 6y agoI looked up pricing of Truvada vs. Descovy through my insurance, and weirdly Truvada would be a $40 copay, yet Descovy is $0 as insurance covers the entire obscene amount ($~2200 for a 30 day supply).
- rossjudson 6y agoMedical insurance companies know they get a slice of the pie, so the size of the pie is really, really important to future growth. Also, can't help but wonder if your insurance company has an ownership interest in Descovy...somewhere. $2200 is cheap if you're paying it to yourself. And the pie grows. Yeah, that's my mildly paranoid writing for the week, methinks.
- stemlord 6y agoI don't know anyone who's actually paying for PrEP here in the US because pretty much every provider's going to cover it, no? It's more expensive treat HIV than it is to prevent it, so if you're an at-risk individual your insurance doesn't want you getting it
- gizmo385 6y agoNot everybody has or can afford insurance.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoExactly. It's like assuming everyone has a Mercedes, a smartphone, or a butler. M4A is also not a solution for universal healthcare because Medicare isn't very good: it requires multiple types of paid co-insurance, rations healthcare, and doesn't pay doctors enough to motivate them to help patients. Medicare is a bare-bones, half-measure that doesn't offer a healthcare system. The common refrain of "It's better than nothing" is an invalid rationalization to settle for substandard healthcare.
- simple_phrases 6y agoSeveral insurance companies like UnitedHealthCare had to be sued into covering PrEP. Not many insurance companies are going to happily cover a medication that can cost ~$30,000+ a year to fill. Even now, United is making it clear that they don't intend to cover new PrEP medication like Descovy even though the medication doesn't cause as much renal damage and failure as Truvada does: https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/payer-issues/unitedhealthcare-changes-coverage-for-gilead-s-new-hiv-prevention-drug.html https://www.beckershospitalreview.com/payer-issues/unitedhea... If you have a high deductible insurance plan, it is not going to be fun to pay for your first few months of PrEP entirely out of pocket. Many people are priced out of PrEP because of that, as are the uninsured and underinsured.
- dillondoyle 6y agoThe copay should be refunded by Gilead. but it shouldn't have to be that way and many can't just be out $1k for 60 days.
- savant_penguin 6y agoOne thing that I've never understood is: if the cost of medicine (insulin is another example) is so high in the US, couldn't you just import?
- anon_tor_12345 6y agoamerica is a free market when you don't look at the collusion between industry and government (i.e. import bans and tariffs). https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/fda-basics/it-legal-me-personally-import-drugs https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/fda-basics/it-legal-me-persona... >In most circumstances, it is illegal for individuals to import drugs into the United States for personal use.
- savant_penguin 6y agoFDA, however, has a policy explaining that it typically does not object to personal imports of drugs that FDA has not approved under certain circumstances, including the following situation: The drug is for use for a serious condition for which effective treatment is not available in the United States; >> You are gonna die and they have something not in the USA that could save your ass There is no commercialization or promotion of the drug to U.S. residents; >> You are fine as long as you do not compete with US drug companies The drug is considered not to represent an unreasonable risk; >> This could literally mean anything. Who defines what unreasonable risk means? And you are comparing the risk of the unapproved drug with what exactly? You are certainly not comparing with the risk of death by not having access($$) to some drug you need The individual importing the drug verifies in writing that it is for his or her own use, and provides contact information for the doctor providing treatment or shows the product is for the continuation of treatment begun in a foreign country; >> Again you are forbidden to compete with US drug companies and Generally, not more than a 3-month supply of the drug is imported. >> And even if the drug could save your life and it's not available in the US you still have to play this stupid traveling game every three months. I'm sure most people with chronic illnesses love to burn their money being forced to travel due to some arbitrary regulation Holy shit fuck the fda
- obtino 6y ago> Elsewhere in the world, Truvada might cost $40. In Australia, Truvada costs $8 for a 30 day supply[1]. AUD 6.60 in Australia is the cost for those eligible for the concession PBS rate (those that are on welfare, pension etc.). It's AUD 41.30 for everyone else. This is all thanks to our government negotiating a good rate with the manufacturer and then subsidizing the costs. This is not what all governments do, unfortunately.
- inter_netuser 6y agoThere is absolutely NO WAY that a brand name drug costs $8 dollars. This is just confusion. 8 dollars is what the user pays in co-pay at a pharmacy. Taxes paid for others shoulder the rest, via a subsidy mechanism. Reference from the first google search: https://www.chemistwarehouse.com.au/buy/78769/truvada-300-200mg-tablets-30 https://www.chemistwarehouse.com.au/buy/78769/truvada-300-20... Private prescription means you forgo the govt subsidy. Truvada is apparently no longer on the subsidized (PBS) list: https://www.starobserver.com.au/news/national-news/no-more-subsidised-truvada-for-australians-but-there-are-alternatives/194091 https://www.starobserver.com.au/news/national-news/no-more-s...