2 ms·
When people switch from barter to market (currency), does that count as "making more money" and poverty reduction in these stats? Some getting a job as a clean
by lupire 6y ago
When people switch from barter to market (currency), does that count as "making more money" and poverty reduction in these stats?
Some getting a job as a cleaner but paying someone else to cook their food, and paying for the commute, isn't a real improvement in quality of life and reduction in poverty. Specialization and economy of scale is great, but at the low end of labor skill, "dollarizing" work at the expense of home economics and barter, is a sham.
- dan-robertson 6y agoIf you were a historian trying to estimate things like historical poverty rate then this (and the “gdp” of subsistence farming or home crafts like spinning and weaving cloth for one’s own clothes) would, I hope, be one of the first things you would consider. Fortunately historians do consider this and work hard to produce results that don’t naively apply today’s economic systems and metrics to the past.
- Ma8ee 6y agoSee the note above the distribution curves in the post: “None market income (e.g. through home production and subsistence farming) is taken into account.”