3 ms·
What's a feature in one context can be a bug in another. I get where OP is coming from: when I zoom in and the text reflows, it's easy to lose my place. PDFs do
by lolinder 6y ago
What's a feature in one context can be a bug in another. I get where OP is coming from: when I zoom in and the text reflows, it's easy to lose my place. PDFs don't have that problem.
Also, digital, free-flow media lose basically all sense of space. PDFs are much better for finding a piece of content again later, because I can remember the location on the page and roughly how many pages into the document.
- Gehinnn 6y agoUsually, if you have reflow, you can disable it. However, if you don't have reflow, you cannot usually enable it!
- kwhitefoot 6y agoOpera does better, or at least it used to.
- dredmorbius 6y agoMany PDF readers / eBook readers now at least try to reflow PDFs. This often works, though it often doesn't. Though too be fair, reflowing HTML / displaying it without all the added-on cruft also often fails these days. Tools such as Reader Mode make heroic efforts, but also very frequently fail (or are apparently blocked or have sites blacklisted by tools).
- kwhitefoot 6y agoI wonder why browser bookmarks don't save the position.
- necovek 6y agoThe answer is likely obvious in that it depends on what content is the visible content at the time of the bookmark, which will further depend on the content itself (it can change since this is a bookmark on an alive web page), page styles, zoom level/scaling, window size etc. Basically, for a bookmark to fully store a position, it would have to store all of the above (and probably more), and it would only be really usable on the same device as long as the underlying content does not change.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoThe underlying content of most pages that I bookmark does not often change. And storage is so cheap now that I would even be happy to have my browser save the rendered page whenever I save a bookmark so that when I ask to see the bookmarked page I get exactly what I was looking at. If I want to see what the page at that address looks like now I refresh the page. And I am almost always on the same device.
- rualca 6y agoBrowser bookmarks save position when there is a position to be saved, which is represented in the form of IDs being pointed to by links with a fragment. Any other scenario doesn't even ensure that the content will continue to exist, let alone have the same structure.
- rualca 6y ago> when I zoom in and the text reflows Zooming in/out should not trigger a reflow. Only things like changing the geometry of a page or font settings require a reflow. It seems you're blaming a document format for a UX problem created by an implementation.
- wwn_se 6y agoA5 pdfs are really nice on mobile and especially tablets. If there were both A4 and A5 pdf renders available more often that would be grate!