4 ms·
https://www.tor.com/2014/03/25/how-history-can-be-used-in-fiction-the-borgias-vs-borgia-faith-and-fear/comment-page-1/ https://www.tor.com/2014/03/25/how-histor
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
https://www.tor.com/2014/03/25/how-history-can-be-used-in-fiction-the-borgias-vs-borgia-faith-and-fear/comment-page-1/ https://www.tor.com/2014/03/25/how-history-can-be-used-in-fi...
> Even costuming accuracy can be a communications problem, since modern viewers have certain associations that are hard to unlearn. Want to costume a princess to feel sweet and feminine? The modern eye demands pink or light blue, though the historian knows pale colors coded poverty. Want to costume a woman to communicate the fact that she’s a sexy seductress? The audience needs the bodice and sleeves to expose the bits of her [that] modern audiences associate with sexy, regardless of which bits would plausibly have been exposed at the time.
> I recently had to costume some Vikings, and was lent a pair of extremely nice period Viking pants which had bold white and orange stripes about two inches wide. I know enough to realize how perfect they were, and that both the expense of the dye and the purity of the white would mark them as the pants of an important man, but that if someone walked on stage in them the whole audience would think: "Why is that Viking wearing clown pants?"
- sillyquiet 6y agoYes, this makes sense, but you can convey what you want to an audience without compromising historicity so thoroughly I believe. Taking the Vikings tv show example - Ragnar Lothbroke would have been in richly and boldly colorful, probably embroidered, clothing of wool and linen and maybe even silk or cotton from trade. He would have been covered in gold and silver jewelry, and his armor and weapons would have been gilt or inlaid with silver, gold, and copper-alloy and intricately engraved. Instead we get an extra from Sons of Anarchy complete with tats and edgy haircut. Edit, also 3/4s of those impressions the modern audience does have is from decades of movies and tv shows. I think a project that respects its audience could do its part to start projecting more accurate impressions of past aesthetics and fashion sensibilities.
- taneliv 6y agoBy the by, any series (or movies) that you'd recommend for their historical accuracy, especially with respect to the everyday things like clothing and other customs?
- sillyquiet 6y agoMaster and Commander is really good for more recent history of the Napoleonic Wars era as far as clothing, language and customs. Outlaw King (netflix movie about Robert Bruce) is bad, but a leap better than other medieval outings - they at least try, the armor is sloppy, ill-fitting, and anachronistic but the weapons, clothing and heraldry are really good. Others more expert than me have mentioned Henry V (1944) with Laurence Olivier as being the best movie attempt at 15th century armor. A company that makes clothes and merchandise for 'viking' enthusiasts kick started a short film that is absolutely excellent in terms of language, clothes, and attitude of the very late Viking period, although they too fall prey to the Vikings-as-bad-ass-biker trope on occcasion. (Not to mention the romantic sanitization of all the unsavory activities any early medieval raiders or pirates would get up to). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yqbowUiH-s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_yqbowUiH-s In general though, true historical accuracy is very hard to find outside niche youtube videos, even if you aren't terribly nitpicky about what is 'accurate'.
- gerikson 6y agoExcept the French crew in Master and Commander had clothes from almost a century before the events in the movie. This was done to denote their "foreignness".
- sillyquiet 6y agoYeah, this is a good point (more like half a century really). I always sort of rationalized in my head because of O'Brians emphasis in the books of sailors' innate conservatism but you are correct. Not to mention there's no way a French crew would be in an American heavy frigate in 1805.
- gerikson 6y agoI'm a huge POB fan but I felt I could overlook a lot of the liberties taken with the movie. At least it got made! And I think the shipboard scenes on the Surprise were really well done.
- sillyquiet 6y agoAnd this is not a knock against the actor himself - I think he did a fantastic job of conveying the mix of pensiveness, thoughtfulness, brutality and ferocity an early Medieval warlord like Ragnar would have had.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoHmm, pants with bold stripes you say ? https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Ftse3.mm.bing.net%2Fth%3Fid%3DOIP.WlqZP438CRuoZxZ4-piDTQHaC9%26pid%3DApi&f=1 https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F... But then these pants also fit the character. And those Vikings are of course highly anachronistic. And wearing something closer to the criticized "Drab barbarian clothes."
- dwohnitmok 6y agoIn the vein of historical accuracy, that article repeats the assertion that nobles basically randomly pooped all over the floor in Versailles. Does anybody know if that's actually true? I feel like I've heard so many conflicting versions of this tale (yes there were essentially small mountains of shit and nobody batted an eye, no these were basically lies and gossip and fabricated by enemies at the time and framed in such a way that it is clear by their salacious tone this was not normal and very disapproved of, etc.) that I have no idea what to believe.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI tried to look into that claim a little more and found a website claiming there was a single French princess who behaved this way on the theory that she was too important to have to waste her time visiting bathrooms, and that her unusual behavior outraged the palace servants (who had to clean it up - the princess wasn't exactly wrong about being important). This seems more plausible than the presentation here.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIIRC it was pretty normal there to throw the content of the chamberpots out of the window in the morning. Which led to a great stink in the summer.
- DanBC 6y agoOr it works the other way. Modern audiences don't understand the significance of a wool cap in Shakespeare. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/cZHd4yrC7DV2sdyndn372K/transcript-shakespeares-restless-world-programme-8 https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/articles/cZHd4yrC7DV2sdyndn...
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> If, for instance, a theatre director today put a middle-aged man on stage wearing low-slung jeans, everybody in the audience would know it was both inappropriate and funny. Well, that claim didn't age well. It's hard to get non-low-rise pants in any variety now.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoYou can still find some pants that have the waistband at the actual waist, but they are unfortunately few and very far between. I like these a lot: https://www.varusteleka.com/en/product/sarma-worker-pants/55188 https://www.varusteleka.com/en/product/sarma-worker-pants/55... And in wool: https://www.varusteleka.com/en/product/sarma-worker-trousers-wool/62307 https://www.varusteleka.com/en/product/sarma-worker-trousers... Wear them with button suspenders, so comfortable. Why did suspenders ever go out of fashion? Otherwise, find a good menswear store or even a tailor to custom make you proper-waisted pants. It's worth it.
- lmm 6y agoLiterally the next line in the article is "In 50 years time they probably won't understand it at all".
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIt's been less than 10 years. People were already complaining about the impossibility of buying pants that fit years before that program came out.
- watwut 6y ago> Want to costume a princess to feel sweet and feminine? You are already starting with "I want the princess to be cartoon character rather then human character". Also, presumably, there would not been a single viking with bright pants, but rather all characters having colors. So one wiking would stand out less.
- lmm 6y agoIt's theatre, of course we're starting with "these people need to be clear, larger-than-life character archetypes, not fully nuanced humans".
- watwut 6y agoNo, the ones with nuanced humans are much better. Or at least the ones with tiny bit more nuance then story for 3 years old.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Also, presumably, there would not been a single viking with bright pants, but rather all characters having colors. So one wiking would stand out less. That doesn't follow at all. The whole concept of "the expense of the dye and the purity of the white mark these as the pants of an important man" is that the pants stand out from what everybody else is wearing. That's how you can tell that the one guy who can afford to wear them is rich and important.
- Sniffnoy 6y agoA note, the pictures seem to have vanished in the Tor version of the article. It would probably be better to link to the original version on Ex Urbe: https://www.exurbe.com/the-borgias-vs-borgia-faith-and-fear/ https://www.exurbe.com/the-borgias-vs-borgia-faith-and-fear/