3 ms·
- Having something to say at all. Yes. Most bloggers. A full screen of infodump about themselves and what they were doing, then, perhaps, just perhaps, some co
by Animats 6y ago
- Having something to say at all.
Yes. Most bloggers. A full screen of infodump about themselves and what they were doing, then, perhaps, just perhaps, some content. Too often, just enough content to maximize clicks.
- Bad craftsmanship.
That's a teachable skill. Merely writing many words is not enough. Someone must criticize them. Back when journalism had copy editors, many writers learned their trade as newspaper reporters.
- Just whatever you do, write.
And if no one is reading it, please stop.
- CharlesW 6y ago> And if no one is reading it, please stop. This is not advice I would personally give, because: (1) Not-writing mostly guarantees that one is not going to get better at it. (2) Current audience size isn't a reliable indicator of whether one "should" (if we're judging) be doing a thing, whether that thing is writing, podcasting, creating open source projects, etc. Everyone has to get through "the gap" between one's taste and one's skills somehow. https://vimeo.com/85040589 https://vimeo.com/85040589
- pmichaud 6y agoNo, sorry. I'm not trying to pitch a unified theory of writing pedagogy that precludes clickbait blogging. I'm trying to say that I think the actually most effective advice, on average, for an "intelligent and earnest person [who] is an avid writer and reader and student of the world" is to write and don't stop. All the caveats you might be tempted to add are already covered in the people I'm talking to, they happen naturally. On average.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoI agree with the other replies that it doesn't make sense to ask bloggers to stop writing if they don't have many readers, not even if their writing is truly poor. Many bloggers aren't aiming to be the next Joel Spolsky or Raymond Chen, they're content with relatively few readers, and that's a good thing. If nothing else, writing is good exercise for future writing. If the 'blogosphere' is functioning well, it shouldn't much matter if inexperienced bloggers are churning out poor quality posts, as the best ones should still rise to prominence just the same. The average quality of all blog posts doesn't much matter. The existence of high quality blog posts is what matters. On a somewhat different note, I'd ask bloggers not to misrepresent their skill level. It might be good exercise for a student to write about a topic they're learning about, but it's frustrating to read a post written in an authoritative tone which turns out to be full of rookie misunderstandings.