3 ms·
The fact something that exists is selling better than something that doesn't exist doesn't really prove much :) Pretty much every car vendor already has L2 aut
by michaelt 6y ago
The fact something that exists is selling better than something that doesn't exist doesn't really prove much :)
Pretty much every car vendor already has L2 autonomy [1] - Google's not going to extract tens of billions of dollars by selling the industry something they already have.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lane_centering#Sample_of_level_2_automated_cars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lane_centering#Sample_of_level...
- ajross 6y ago> The fact something that exists is selling better than something that doesn't exist doesn't really prove much :) On the contrary, it proves that the other thing doesn't exist. Which is sort of important to analysis. I know that's glib. My point was the pontification about what "self driving autonomy" is or should be or might be or is supposed to be or (my personal peeve) "is supposed to be called" is essentially meaningless when we could be discussing what is actually happening in a vibrant and interesting market. I get it. People think about this stuff in the abstract. But it's not an abstract problem anymore, and I think arguments like yours are very much missing the forest for the trees. Roll back the clock to, say, 1985 and let's imagine we're talking about network technology. Elon is selling a working TCP/IP stack while you're yelling about the fact that akshooally it doesn't conform to the proper OSI layers and so can't ever be a successful network. How did history work out for the OSI pedants? Same principle.
- davidcbc 6y agoElon is selling a "Full Self Driving car" that is not full self driving at all by Tesla's own admission. It isn't doing the thing it is advertised to do. https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a35785277/tesla-fsd-california-self-driving/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a35785277/tesla-fsd-califo... https://www.roadandtrack.com/news/a35878363/teslas-full-self-driving-beta-is-just-laughably-bad-and-potentially-dangerous/ https://www.roadandtrack.com/news/a35878363/teslas-full-self... Calling an L2 car "full self driving" is incredibly irresponsible. I personally hope Musk faces consequences when yet another Tesla kills someone because of false advertising.
- ajross 6y ago> Calling an L2 car "full self driving" is incredibly irresponsible I repeat: this is an argument about semantics, further obscured by the use of jargon, and it does nothing to inform a discussion about what autonomy features are being offered on existing cars, nor about what the market wants, nor even about whether or not those features are safe or effective. It's just words. If you want to have a discussion about whether or not Tesla's self driving feature is safe or not, you need to come with evidence about safety. You can't just yell about "L2", no one cares anymore.
- davidcbc 6y agoCould you be more pedantic? I'm not even the one who brought up L2 in the first place. I used the same jargon as the person I was responding to. HN is a technical forum, if you're going to have a discussion about autonomous vehicles on a technical forum then technical terms should be fair game. If I'm having this discussion elsewhere then I'll explain it differently. But fine, if you want to be pedantic: Calling a car that cannot drive itself without human intervention a "fully self driving car" is incredibly irresponsible.