3 ms·
> A syllable is a sound that makes up part of a word. In the year two nought nought nought (2000), Guy Steele gave a talk called "Growing a Language". He used a
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> A syllable is a sound that makes up part of a word. In the year two nought nought nought (2000), Guy Steele gave a talk called "Growing a Language". He used a schtick in his talk, where he did not speak a word of more than one syllable if he did not first say what it meant.
> In this post, I will use the same schtick.
This is a great and apparently unintentional illustration of why the belief in short words being simple is misguided. In its own introductory paragraph, it messes up in multiple ways by multiple standards.
Most obvious: nobody can understand "two nought nought nought". We'd have a much easier time with "two zero zero zero", even though the word "zero" is notionally 100% more complicated than the word "nought".
That was so obvious that the author helpfully glossed his own simplified language, knowing that we couldn't understand it. "two nought nought nought" means "2000". Good thing someone was there to dumb that ...up... for us.
Except... "2000" is "two thousand", and "thousand" is a word of more than one syllable. The author forgot to tell us what it means!
It turns out absolutely everything is very simple by this ludicrous standard. "Curl" is a non-evil one-syllable word, and it can be defined, also very simply, as ∇ × F (F: ℝ×ℝ×ℝ ⟶ ℝ×ℝ×ℝ). Look how easy that is to understand!
What does curl mean? Well, that must be a totally different question from "how simple is the concept?" I didn't understand what curl meant even when I was taking a class in it.
- tikhonj 6y agoGuy Steele used the restriction to one-syllable words to make a point. It's supposed to sound a bit off and it pushes him to define a bunch of words as he goes along. If he had started with "simple" words instead, the talk would have flowed too well for the gimmick to work! He actually mentions that in his talk: > In truth, the words of one syllable form quite a rich vocabulary, with which you can say many things. You may note that this vocabulary is much larger than that of the language called Basic English, defined by Charles Kay Ogden in the year one nine three nought[10]. I chose not to use Basic English for this talk, for the cause that Basic English has many words of two or more syllables, some of them quite long, handed down to us from the dim past of Rome. While Basic English has fewer words, it does not give the feel, to one who speaks full English, of being a small language. Using one-syllable words is a fun way to make the structure of the talk reflect its thesis, with a rule that's simple enough to explain in one sentence. It's not meant to be a serious example of a simple language! If you did it seriously you'd get something like Simple Wikipedia, which reads pretty well[1]: > A programming language is a type of written language that tells computers what to do. Examples are: python, ruby, jupiter, html, css, java, javascript, C, C++, and C#. Programming languages are used to write all computer programs and computer software. A programming language is like a set of instructions that the computer follows to do something. That reads well and it's a good example of defining specialized words as you need them, but it doesn't feel all that different from "normal" English and it's much harder to explain what "simple" constitutes in that context. It works better in reality, but worse for a talk. [1]: https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programming_language https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programming_language