3 ms·
> Among the authors' recommendations were that any regulation has extremely precise definitions to avoid any possible workarounds I find this surprising - shou
by viraptor 6y ago
> Among the authors' recommendations were that any regulation has extremely precise definitions to avoid any possible workarounds
I find this surprising - shouldn't it go the other way? The more strictly defined your law is, the more space it creates for "tweak just this bit to technically comply". More vague definitions are closer to "you know what we meant" position.
- Ensorceled 6y agoIn context, they mean the law should target any gambling mechanic as opposed to banning “loot boxes”. Otherwise the gambling mechanic will come back with another mechanism, say a lucky companion that increases your chances of finding a pot of gold at the end of each rainbow.
- BuyMyBitcoins 6y agoThis is already present in Pokémon Go with egg incubators, shiny Pokémon, and raids. You’re not directly buying rare Pokémon, but the tools to increase your chances of getting them.
- AlexanderDhoore 6y agoAs I understand it the law in Anglo Saxon countries is closer to the "precise definitions" system, while European Napoleonic Code law is closer to "you know what we mean". In the US you must follow the letter of the law. In France you must follow the spirit of the law. (I'm no expert. So please tell me if this isn't correct.)
- corty 6y agoIt depends on the area of the law and the field of application. E.g. criminal law and stuff that is meant to cut into civil liberties is very precise and letter-of-the-law style. Any criminal act needs to be defined in the law, you-know-what-we-mean isn't acceptable there. On the other hand consumer-protection, environmental regulations and stuff like that is interpreted more in a you-know-what-we-mean-style. Of course there are areas where both styles overlap.
- esturk 6y agoExactly, it should be a clear cut age limit, (say 18/21), to participate like gambling.