4 ms·
If that's your critic then Proof-of-Work is the issue, not crypto currencies in general. There are multiple Proof-of-Stake implementations already in production
by dgellow 6y ago
If that's your critic then Proof-of-Work is the issue, not crypto currencies in general. There are multiple Proof-of-Stake implementations already in production (still very young though), each with its set of properties (see Cardano, Algorand, Tezos, Polkadot, Harmony, etc).
- Jonovono 6y agoWhat do you think of Proof of Space-Time? https://spacemesh.io https://spacemesh.io
- ghgr 6y agoIt took me a while to find out the description of this proof of space-time (and check whether it's satire or not), so to save you time here's the gist of it: From the whitepaper: Loosely speaking, the PoST consists of two phases: an initialization phase (executed once), in which miners “commit” to the data that fills the space S , and an execution phase (executed repeatedly), in which miners prove that they are still storing the data. The time component of the spacetime resource is the elapsed time between successive proofs—if the interval between initialization (or the previous execution phase) and the latest execution phase is T, this proves the miner expended S · T spacetime. https://drive.google.com/file/d/18I9GPebWqgpvusI1kMnAB9nayBbL-1qN/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/18I9GPebWqgpvusI1kMnAB9nayBb...
- DougN7 6y agohttps://chia.net https://chia.net also does this. I guess the guy that designed bittorrent also designed this one.
- edf13 6y agoFrom the green paper... > We provide an initial security analysis of the Chia backbone, showing that as long as at least ≈ 61.5% of the space is controlled by honest parties Chia satisfies basic blockchain security properties. That seems to be a alarming high threshold for control of the network? So as little as 38.6% can attack the network?
- Nursie 6y agoI think it will provide horrible incentives to demand ever greater storage space, driving up the costs of storage in the same way that PoW coins have driven up the cost of graphics cards. It's also likely to have pretty bad environmental externalities as manufacturing said storage will have both energy and material waste side-effects.
- wavesplash 6y agoThe founder of Chia.net has doubts PoS is sound. Check out Chia’s low power Proof of Space + Time.
- Nursie 6y agoProof of space is just as poor an idea as PoW, because if it takes off it will drive up demand and prices for hard drives, creating the same incentives around them as there is currently around GPUs. The whole idea of creating artificial digital scarcity by basing it on physical scarcity of resources is just horrible.
- wavesplash 6y agoHardly. It's not about scarcity for PoS+T. The pollution, heat, and energy waste of Proof of Work far outweigh and minimal change in the cost of storage that PoS+T might bring.
- Nursie 6y agoOf course it’s about scarcity. If it’s profitable to dedicate storage to this scheme, it will stoke demand for that storage, the only limit of which is breakeven on the costs, scarcity and availability of that storage is then the factor limiting the space. And the whole scheme, as with all cryptocurrency, is designed to create digital scarcity in a decentralised way. It’s a terrible plan and very shortsighted. Making hard drives isn’t free of environmental externalities.
- wavesplash 6y agoAgain, I fail to understand that math or extremist rationale. You're comparing existing significant energy waste to an artificial scenario where all drive space is hoarded - and if that case ever came true, the total energy waste would still remain less than PoW by orders of magnitude.
- anoncake 6y ago
- fiftyacorn 6y agoThe one thing I'm not clear on with crypto energy requirements is how does it compare to normal bank/credit card reconciliation
- blondie9x 6y agoBitcoin uses order of magnitude more energy https://www.statista.com/statistics/881541/bitcoin-energy-consumption-transaction-comparison-visa/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/881541/bitcoin-energy-co...
- bronson 6y agoThe link shows almost six orders of magnitude more energy per transaction.
- rchaud 6y agoCrypto energy use should be compared to that of capital markets trades if anything. No one is using crypto as a medium of exchange.