5 ms·
The contrast and distinction between the different UI elements is immediately obvious. No mistaking a button for static text, and vice-versa. Also, no hidden sc
by userbinator 6y ago
The contrast and distinction between the different UI elements is immediately obvious. No mistaking a button for static text, and vice-versa. Also, no hidden scrollbars or other auto-hiding UI elements that are difficult to discover and irritating to use even once you know about them.
- tartoran 6y agoEven if it looks 'ugly' by today's standard those were good days UI/UX wise and things kept on improving. UIs were consistent and easy to use by mouse or keyboard and in my opinion things started going downhill ever since. I think good UI/UX will of course be rediscovered and the old ideas will be recycled into something new at some point.
- pilsetnieks 6y agoTo offer a counterpoint - back then everything in an interface had to be painfully obvious and usable in a myriad of ways because a significant portion of users were computer-illiterate first timers. As it is now, and forever will be, I think the balance between usability and ease of development will be those 20% of effort to make your app palatable to 80% of the users (barring some exceptions by people with underdeveloped moneymaking sense whose self-description might involve the word "artisanal".)
- tartoran 6y agoYes, you have a point. When IPads/Iphones first came out they were so usable that old people who never touched a computer or toddlers could use them without much direction, they were quite intuitive. They've messed up since then though, they've gone into a dubious direction. And the rest of the industry followed good and bad apple UI/UX decisions, some of them even poorly and we have a confusing mess, confusing and headache inducing at times even for the computer literate.
- titzer 6y agoI find touch interfaces have infantilized computing, turning everything into scrolling and big, fat, ad-looking buttons, and there is no way to really become skilled at them.
- swader999 6y agoI remember teaching old guys how to use a mouse in my first real programming job after school.
- laurent92 6y agoWindows classical UX was awesome: - Menus - Easy keyboard shortcuts with underlined keys in menus (Alt-F Alt-O!), and reconfigurable in general, - F1 Help working everywhere, - Unified keyboard shortcuts: F2 to rename, F5 to refresh (except in Lotus which closes entirely), - Reconfigurable an draggable toolbars! - Icons (those don’t exist in the web) And so on. Treeviews! Lists with sortable and reorderable headers! They were awesome. It was the ultimate UI. Then they flattened everything and, worse than everything, came the time where treeviews disappeared and were replaced with infinite list sorted by “last document opened” like in Google Drive... That is what I regret most: Old documents being buried behind an infinite scroll, you can never be sure that you see and sort everything.
- core-questions 6y agoRemember selecting more than one of something, and then being able to drag-and-drop it somewhere, or right click it and perform actions on the whole list? Remember tables with sortable column headers, in every app? Oh man. The web sucks so hard, and the kids working on it now are so used to it they don't even know how hard they've been fucked over. To think that in 2021 people still have to think about how to wire up a data table to some backend, thousands of people writing their own version of that every year....
- titzer 6y agoMenus are so. fucking. awesome. Imagine. The computer giving you a list of the actions you can do, written in a language you already understand, organized hierarchically by the kind of thing you are operating on. And as a bonus, most of them have keyboard shortcuts that are/were immediately spelled out directly on the menu!
- cytzol 6y agoYou're damn right. The other day, I was using the Twitter web interface, and I realised I'd accidentally clicked the "Like" button on a tweet as I was going back to the previous page. Oh no, I haven't liked a bad tweet, have I? Of course, I go forward, and the page has completely changed, showing me a bunch of stuff that wasn't there the last time I saw it. Great, now I need to navigate the UI. I scan the interface for some sort of "likes list". It's not in the sidebar. It's not in the "more" in the sidebar. It's not even in "lists". So I open Tweetbot, search the menu bar for "like", find it in "Tabs → Likes", and perform the action I want in seconds. Web applications can never compare.
- ChickeNES 6y agoIt helped that Microsoft put out a design manual laying out their standards: "The Windows Interface Guidelines for Software Design: An Application Design Guide"
- Narishma 6y agoI think it looks better than modern UIs.
- UIZealot 6y ago> Even if it looks 'ugly' by today's standard No it does NOT. It's beautify because it's simple, yet consistent and clear. Today's "standard"? That's the ugly one.
- grishka 6y agoIMO things started going downhill the moment laptop manufacturers started putting touchscreens into laptops. No one uses them with any kind of seriousness, but apparently every single UI designer now designs with them in mind for some bizarre reason.
- tartoran 6y agoYes, mixing the 2 paradigms was a disaster. Windows 10 got a lot of pushback when it removed the start button. They put it back and things improved a bit since then but I still disklike windows 10 a lot.
- saratogacx 6y ago8 removed it and replaced the system interface with a gesture based one even to go so far to remove it from server versions so people wouldn't put that version of explorer on their machine to get it back. Win 10 brought their current start menu.
- tartoran 6y agoYou're right, I forgot about Windows 8. Still, the story doesn't change much, there was a huge pushback...
- chiph 6y agoThe windows have edges! That tell you where to grab with your mouse to resize it! These days, dark mode on a black desktop background means you can't find where a window's surface ends.
- baud147258 6y agothough today you can resize the window with Win key + arrows or by dragging the window.
- flowerlad 6y agoThis is one of the biggest annoyances in Windows 10. If you use Command Prompt and have several of them open with overlapping windows, then it is impossible to see where one window ends and the next one starts. If you have text in all of them you'll frequently read text from the next window and then realize that text is not in the current window. Windows 10 UX is under the control of the guy who came with the Flat UI and they don't care about annoyances such as this. They are very dogmatic, and no matter how many people complain they aren't going to give up any of their Flat UI principles.
- Flow 6y agoThere's a rumor that Windows 10 will be getting a major graphical redesign. Most welcome by me if true! https://edition.cnn.com/2021/01/05/tech/windows-10-redesign-trnd/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/01/05/tech/windows-10-redesign-...
- 6y ago
- salamandersauce 6y agoThe number of times I have opened a folder on macOS scrolled up and down wondering where the hell my file is before realizing it's hidden off to the SIDE is too damn high.
- Jtsummers 6y agoIf you're talking about the "columns" view in Finder it's pretty obvious unless you're not paying attention where the contents of the folder you opened are displayed. Unless they happen to have exactly the same contents as another existing open folder at the same level the next column over's view visibly changes. I guess this would be awkward if you've never used it, but I can't imagine it being confusing more than once or twice unless you never look at the screen while opening folders.
- salamandersauce 6y agoIcons view. Not columns. It will regularly open some of my folders in a window where the width of what it displays is less than the width of where it puts files so some require a side scroll. Why on earth it does this I have no clue.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoThere's an option somewhere in System Preferences to always show scrollbars. I wish that was the default.
- zbuf 6y agoInteresting to see that screenshot of the old IE as it was the first time we started seeing toolbar buttons that didn't have a static border to show they were a button. You had to hover the mouse to know that it was clickable.
- grishka 6y ago> Also, no hidden scrollbars I agree with the rest but not this. You no longer need visible scrollbars now that you do 99% of your scrolling with the wheel or the trackpad or sometimes the keyboard. You did need visible and prominent scrollbars back when mice lacked wheels so you actually clicked and dragged them.
- arp242 6y agoIt still has value as 1) an indicator you can scroll in the first place, and 2) an indicator of where in the document you are.
- MawKKe 6y ago1) case in point: Windows 10 Settings
- feanaro 6y agoIn fact, I would argue that 2 is the primary use case for scrollbars.
- BlueTemplar 6y ago2) is still around though : the scrollbar tends to show up as soon as you start scrolling (... which I guess covers 1) too ?)
- fireattack 6y agoI still click and drag scroll bar frequently. It's faster, easier to fine control the position (especially useful when you want to toggle between two or more positions). To me, all three ways to scroll (scrollwheel, auto-scroll, dragging scroll bar manually) have their uses.