5 ms·
This seems like a weasally headline to me. "Shows ties to Bloomberg News" makes it sound like Peltz was conspiring together with the Bloomberg journalist. Whe
by crazygringo 6y ago
This seems like a weasally headline to me.
"Shows ties to Bloomberg News" makes it sound like Peltz was conspiring together with the Bloomberg journalist.
When what's alleged is simply that Peltz was feeding the Bloomberg journalist legitimately publishable scoops.
Peltz is rightly accused of insider trading. But Bloomberg appears to have done nothing wrong whatsoever.
- antrix 6y agoFrom the article, it seems the information was flowing _from_ the reporter: > The feds allege that Peltz used disposable “burner” phones and encrypted apps to communicate with a journalist, and that the reporter provided “material nonpublic information about forthcoming articles” which Peltz used to trade in the market “just prior to publication of an article about each company written by the reporter.”
- mannykannot 6y agoNews like this loses its value unless it is published immediately, so I would think the leaker is effectively in control of when it is published.
- jsemrau 6y agoTrying to wrap my head around what you are trying to say. Let's use some example. If you would know that Tesla's delivery numbers were a disaster (they weren't). Knowing that before everybody else would give you a chance to sell at a significantly better price than others.
- plouffy 6y agoYes, but if you know exactly when everyone else find out you can time your trade more easily.
- theturtletalks 6y agoCould an insider trader get information, not act on it, write an article about his scoop, and then make trades after the article's published? If the publication he writes on is obscure and not followed, is the information still considered public?
- Thorrez 6y agoSure, but that doesn't mean it "loses its value unless it is published immediately". Basically, the info has a certain amount of value, that doesn't really go down. If you pair that information with the knowledge of when it will be published, it goes up in value.
- mannykannot 6y ago> Basically, the info has a certain amount of value, that doesn't really go down. I was thinking of the value of the news to Bloomberg, which was mentioned in the article: At Bloomberg, scoops about deals are highly valued, because beating competitors like Reuters or Dow Jones helps to justify the high price of a terminal, which carries rich veins of data along with news, at a reported cost of around $24,000 a year. The terminals constitute the company’s core business. If the information is deemed important, then, as soon as Bloomberg is confident in the information's accuracy, it will publish. Once Peltz had a record of giving reliable tips, that would likely happen quickly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scoop_%28news%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scoop_%28news%29
- Thorrez 6y agoThanks, that makes sense.
- jsemrau 6y agoI think it depends how this information will be distributed. If it will be syndicated, then you will know the limit already.
- mannykannot 6y agoI am not taking a position here on the proposition that Peltz needed to know when the information would be published in order to profit. I am pointing out that, even without being explicitly told by the journalist, he could be reasonably sure that publication would occur quickly, if at all. He could also be reasonably confident that it would be published, given that it is valuable information, and that Bloomberg had demonstrated its confidence in his leaks by publising earlier ones. The feds may well, of course, have independent non-circumstantial evidence of the journalist informing Peltz about when the information would be published.
- coliveira 6y agoIt looks like both were involved in trading inside information, one for market operations and the other for articles. If the journalist had a deal (which I can only suspect to be the case), he was facilitating the crime of insider trading.
- throwaway789256 6y agoThe journalist didn't need a deal. His prestige increased because he was publishing scoops.
- crazygringo 6y agoThe journalist has not been charged with anything. And this actually brings up a fascinating point: is it a crime for a journalist to tell a third party when the journalist will publish a story, if both believe the story will affect the markets? The journalist isn't telling the third party what the information is -- after all, in this case it seems like it was the third party who supplied it. And the journalist isn't profiting financially either. They're just getting their story, not a share of profits. I'm not aware that courts have determined that this is facilitating insider trading. And like I said, the journalist hasn't been charged with anything. But I'm not an expert. Are you sure this would be a crime?
- plouffy 6y agoJournalists often have embargoes on their articles. A company may want to announce a new product, will tell a few newspapers but ask them to wait before publishing.
- PeterisP 6y agoSure, but violating those embargoes is not a crime. It might (but isn't likely to) violate some contract between the company and the newspaper - which is also not a crime, but may open up the possibility for a civil claim; it might cause the newspaper to stop receiving future releases; it might result in the journalist getting fired, but nothing about violating such embargoes would be criminally prosecutable by the state.
- throwaway789256 6y agoThis has been discussed below. The reporter was giving Peltz non-public information about the stories he was going to publish, which allowed Peltz to better time his trades. The information flow was two-way.
- kaminar 6y agoThere's no way they caught this person in a few months time, with all the precautions he took. Someone ratted this guy out. Would love to know why the feds don't pursue the big market manipulators, instead trying to make headlines with small fish. Probably can't make anything stick, because they are less than competent and less than fully manned. The rat needs to be exposed.
- ethbr0 6y agoBecause there's a resolving door between federal lawyers, politicians, and very lucrative private law jobs. Power is political.
- spoonjim 6y agoOften times people who take a lot of precautions still make one mistake. cf. Ulbricht, Ross.
- watwut 6y agoIt is important to punish whistleblowers, because it makes cheating safer. If people are afraid to report it is easier to cheat and not get caught.