4 ms·
> I think this is just the usual goal post moving, if a machine does it then we decide it wasn't really dangerous for a machine to do it. I strongly disagree.
by endisneigh 6y ago
> I think this is just the usual goal post moving, if a machine does it then we decide it wasn't really dangerous for a machine to do it.
I strongly disagree. Most machines are not capable of killing you because it makes a mistake.
Do you have an example of something humans did that could kill them that was automated completely that still can kill them, but generally does not anymore? An elevator is one example, but in the case of an elevator its a very bounded problem to solve, and even still hundreds die for unnecessary elevator deaths yearly.
Not to mention an elevator is not an entropic environment. A full self driving car would have to be able to deal with ice suddenly falling on the ground, people crashing around them, etc.
- nsp 6y agoFully automated train systems? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_train_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_automated_train_system... Not nearly as complex a problem as self driving cars, but I'd still rather not get hit by a train
- endisneigh 6y agoMy understanding of trains is that most of the safety advances have come from better signaling, not the automation of the trains themselves.
- anyfoo 6y agoYes, not nearly. Not anywhere close to the complexity needed for self driving cars. Trains run on closed, limited, well-signaled infrastructure, which (comparably) makes it fairly easy to "avoid other trains" (as long as the signaling, coordinated externally, works--if it doesn't the train is likely programmed to just stop until it does again).
- craftinator 6y agoYou mean, like the entire rest of his comment? Garmin Autoland...
- endisneigh 6y agoThe Garmin Autoland is not equivalent to full self driving? That's like self parking which has existed for a while now. In any case planes are inherently orders of magnitude safer than cars to begin with due to the lack of obstacles/chaos.
- anyfoo 6y agoIt frustrates me to no end when people compare autolanding (even the Garmin kind), or worse, general autopilots, with self-driving cars. Anyone who does that has either never traveled in an airplane (even just as a passenger), or just never observed and thought about the vastly different levels of interaction planes have with their environment.
- craftinator 6y agoDid you forget what you originally wrote? You said: > Do you have an example of something humans did that could kill them that was automated completely that still can kill them, but generally does not anymore? And I pointed out that the parent comment had already provided an example. Now you are arguing with me that the example given, about Garmin Autoland, isn't comparable to self-driving... Which isn't at all the example you asked for in the first place. Maybe focus and read a little more, write a little less. You'll be more easily understood.
- endisneigh 6y ago> Do you have an example of something humans did that could kill them that was automated completely that still can kill them, but generally does not anymore? My understanding from looking at research is that airplanes by experienced pilots rarely killed people... and they... still don't even when (partially) automated? There doesn't appear to be definitive evidence that autopilot is safer [2] as many of the innovations in safety have been conflated with procedural improvements. In fact there are studies [1] that suggest autopilot is actually making flights unsafe as pilots are becoming complacent and airplanes do not flight themselves completely from point to point including taxiing. In other words, no, plane automation is not an example as it does not satisfy the criteria of "generally does not" compared to the baseline of no automation. [1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/001872088502700107 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/001872088502700... [2]https://www.eurocontrol.int/sites/default/files/publication/Hindsight/Hindsight-20.pdf https://www.eurocontrol.int/sites/default/files/publication/... Try not to be so condescending, sheesh.
- jacobolus 6y ago> hundreds die for unnecessary elevator deaths yearly Elevator deaths are extremely rare in industrialized countries (a couple dozen per year in the USA), and most are of people working on the elevator (e.g. accidentally falling down the elevator shaft), not passengers riding in an elevator. I think construction elevators are also quite a bit less safe than ordinary passenger elevators. Typical elevators are one of the safest forms of transportation, substantially safer than stairs or ladders.