5 ms·
Why is fusion ignored?
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y ago
Why is fusion ignored?
- sand500 6y agoBecause it is always 50 years out.
- drran 6y agoWhy is the LENR ignored then?
- cthalupa 6y agoBecause at least regular fusion has significant and universally accepted empirical evidence of it even being fundamentally possible. LENR has had to have a name change because the primary connotation with cold fusion is a bunch of psuedoscience and bullshit. Yes, some real scientists have published some results that make continued study worthwhile, but if regular fusion is 50 years off, our indication is that LENR, if it's even possible, is 100.
- drran 6y agoWhy 100? I see no barrier to adopt the LENR worldwide in a short period of time, when the effect will be well understood and easy to reproduce.
- cthalupa 6y agoIf people outside of the LENR community could ever reproduce any of their experiments it would be a good start. I don't think the hundred or so scientists at a bunch of disparate universities are part of some conspiracy to push quack science, but something is up when there is no theoretical framework that even begins to explain your results, no one outside of your community can reproduce it, and your results are still just "well that's weird" vs. "we have something we can build off to actually produce energy"
- drran 6y agoWhen someone outside the LENR community will reproduce Cold Fusion experiment, he will be part of the LENR community immedialtely, so nope. However, you can look at results produced by Akito Takahashi[0]. Are they convincing enough for you? [0]: https://www.lenr-canr.org/acrobat/BiberianJPjcondensedzb.pdf#page=128 https://www.lenr-canr.org/acrobat/BiberianJPjcondensedzb.pdf...
- the8472 6y agoIf all you want is fusion instead of energy production then just put a fusor[0] in your garage. Lab results that show some evidence for trace amounts of fusion reactions do not imply net energy production. E.g. one of the recently announced results needed a powerful xray beamline to get some tiny results, which consumed more energy than the fusion reactions ever released. This is comparable to the ancient greeks inventing a "steam engine"[1] that does no meaningful work. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusor [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile
- drran 6y agoUnlike fission and like thermal pump, this energy can be used to heat buildings, so even if nuclear reaction can produce just 100-200% of additional energy, which is enough for about 30-60% of electricity spent, the device still can perform at 200-300% efficiency when used as a home heater.
- the8472 6y agoIn that case it would compete with a heat pump. And unlike that one it can't double as AC. And that's not exactly baseline power production. Shifting goalposts?
- kergonath 6y agoOh, you again? It’s ignored because it’s bunk.
- drran 6y agoIt's ignored, because most labs in the world cannot reproduce it yet, because LENR is not well understood yet. However, LENR is not dismissed completely, see [0]. My own idea is that plasma micro-bubbles are hot enough to cause nuclear fusion somehow. [0]: https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/scientists-in-the-us-and-japan-get-serious-about-lowenergy-nuclear-reactions https://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/scientists-in-the-u...
- zamalek 6y agoBecause nobody has demonstrated working LENR. You can't build that which has not been discovered. Oil wars are effectively fought over energy. LENR would be a significant strategic, political, and economical advantage, and intentionally suppressing it is equivalent to shooting yourself in the foot. America, as one example, could stop participating in an expensive war occurring thousands of kilometers away over an ocean, that is being fought for the sole purpose of stockpiling energy reserves. We know how to make fission reactors, we have many of them operating right now. We could build more this very second.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoProbably because it's still decades away from being a cost-effective, break-even source of power.
- cthalupa 6y agoIn this article, or in general? For this article, because it's just not going to arrive in time to solve the main issue. I'm extremely optimistic about ITER, but the current timetable on ITER/DEMO doesn't have an operating poc plant until the 2050s. If you mean in general, it's not even remotely ignored. There are massive projects underway (see the previously mentioned ITER) as well as smaller, more experimental projects. It's a very exciting field to follow. It just doesn't move fast enough to solve problems that we needed to solve a decade ago. We're in damage control mode when it comes to climate change, deaths from emissions, etc. We can't afford to wait for a perfect solution when we're bleeding out in the field.
- rossnordby 6y agoIf anyone's not already aware of it, the SPARC/ARC reactor work spun out of MIT looks pretty promising on shorter timescales than ITER: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KkpqA8yG9T4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rY6U4wB-oYM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rY6U4wB-oYM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8uYNhevRtk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8uYNhevRtk
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoStuff like this is what got me excited about fusion. Energy is the most fundamental constraint of the universe and people like MIT's Zach Hartwig say fusion merely has a funding problem.
- effie 6y ago> fusion merely has a funding problem. When you look at history of ITER failures and the real problems involved in making the whole fusion power production operation economically sustainable, this claim disintegrates. It is a very complex project that is hard to manage, and building and operating fusion power plant is currently much more costly than doing that for a fission power plant. The only benefit of fusion vs. fission is that fusion can give us much more energy. But fission can give enough energy now for decades, and much more cheaply.
- king_magic 6y agoBecause it doesn’t exist yet?
- jtolmar 6y agoThe biggest problem with fission power is up front capital cost. It takes so long to pay off the mortgage that, by the time a nuclear plant pulls ahead over a fossil fuel plant, whoever decided to build that plant is probably getting ready to retire. We have every reason to believe that a fusion power plant will be even more expensive and slower to construct than a fission one. So, even if you skipped over the additional expensive and slow step of proving that a reactor design works, they still wouldn't be chosen by any energy company that expects to turn a profit.
- effie 6y agoFusion is not a real power plant technology and won't be at least for few decades, probably much longer.
- ncmncm 6y agoThe ITER project has no plans ever to boil so much as one gallon of water for public power. It is 100% a "research project", yet not even planned to try out until 2050. Then, maybe start a production plant after they finish experimenting, maybe in time for 2100 if everything works out perfectly. Which it won't. If $10B is hard (i.e. impossible) to justify for proven fission, how about $100B for fusion? $200B? Nobody involved expects ever? to field a competitive Tokamak power station. Not in their lifetime, not in their grandchildrens' lifetime. That is not the purpose of the project. It has a different purpose. Its main purpose is to provide employment for hot-neutron physicists, to maintain a population to be available to draw on for sporadic weapons work. Another purpose it shares with a lot of others, to provide a reliable long-term conduit of public funds to select private hands. The hot-neutron physicists are not getting those $billions, but somebody is. Every penny spent on ITER is stolen from other possibly viable projects. Imagine how many GW-years could be generated by 2050 by solar and wind paid for out of what is earmarked for ITER.
- andrewlgood 6y agoNo where near commercially viable. I am only aware of two groups (TriAlpha and the Nuclear Ignition Facility) that reached the breakeven point - more energy out than in - and that for a very brief moment. Always seems to be 30 years away.