7 ms·
Why SSDs are worth the money
- keithnoizu 15y agoRunning 3 raided SSD drives on my home workstation . . . seriously considering upgrading to one or more raided hyperOs DDR2 Ram Disk Drives. The write latency is nasty on compile time.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoCurious about this, is it RAID-0 for speed or some other variant?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- keithnoizu 15y agoRaid 0, Although I've heard something or other about a larger performance gain being realized by other raid configurations.
- moe 15y agoAre you sure writes are your bottleneck there?
- keithnoizu 15y agoYes. Large code base, large number of intemediary files and bin places. Compiling itself is an issue of course also but i'm already on a fairly high end i7 chip with tri channel ddr. More cpus or faster cpus would be nice but I'll take a faster hard drive over processor speed any day.
- justincormack 15y agoWhy dont you compile on a ram disk then? Its not like you need to persist the intermediate files...
- dexen 15y agoGive NILFS2 [1] a try. It's log structured so the writes do not cause overwrites of filesystem metadata, directories nor files. I have a very old, very slow SSD extracted from Asus EeePC, in an auxilliary computer; NILFS2 makes it crazy fast write-wise when compared to XFS and ext4. [1] http://www.nilfs.org/en/ http://www.nilfs.org/en/
- dlsspy 15y agoAmazing how many people are commenting about how SSDs don't help much. I am stunned by how long it takes to do anything on any of my computers that don't have SSDs now. IOPS matter to me.
- lparry 15y agoIt sounds like a bunch of people who havent experienced the difference first hand, trying to convince themselves that they dont care.
- city41 15y agoI do care and I have no doubt that SSDs are faster and better. I too am holding off until their reliability improves. But I just tested starting my iMac with a 7200 RPM drive in it and it took 31 seconds from the startup chime until I was able to fully use it. So I can also understand people's hesitation. And besides, if I booted over to Windows 7, it'd take about 4 minutes until this machine was usable, so it's all a matter of perspective. EDIT: to be fair I just measured Windows 7 and it took 1:30 before the machine was usable.
- ericd 15y agoThe boot time is just a convenient "wow" factor, the real benefit comes from the thousands of little everyday tasks becoming CPU-bound instead of IO-bound. A 7200 RPM drive is absolutely not comparable.
- cubicle67 15y agoI recently replaced the 5400rpm drive in my macbook with a larger capacity 7200rpm drive, and the difference in performance was quite noticeable. Of course no where near the jump from 7200 to SSD, but still a decent jump. Downside is that the new drive is loud enough to hear, whereas the original drive was dead silent
- 15y ago
- henryw 15y agoIf your servers were doing as much write as reads, then SSDs might not be as fast. I had (raid10) 4 intel 80gb ssd vs (raid10) 4 15k rpm scsi drives, and the scsi drives were faster with heavy innodb writes. You might wanna do some stress benchmarking before going into production if you have heavy writes. Now I'm sure the FusionIO line of drives will probably be faster than SCSI's, though I haven't tested them.
- rkalla 15y agoSomething to consider before going the SSD route: failure rates are high right now. The Intel X-25 series seem to be doing OK, but the Vertex2 and Vertex3 (brand new SandForce 2k-based drives) have really terrible failure rates. I've heard mixed things about the Crucial drives. I am sure you guys have read Jeff Atwood's post[1] about how every SSD they've put into machines in the last year has failed. I shared that around with a group of friends scattered around Chicago and the bay area - the friend in Chicago has a company with 30 employees. They have put SSDs in 12 of the developer machines, by the end of the year 10 had failed (Vertex2 drives). I think SSDs have a lot to offer, the performance is there for the right use-cases (which is almost every disk I/O scenario save for a few), but for a lot of folks the idea of having drives fail regularly is a suicide-inducing though (current company included). I'm sitting on my hands for an SSD not because I don't think they are awesome, too expensive or not big enough... I'm waiting because the failure rate seems to be painfully high in these things. I want some more time in the oven before I start sticking them in my work machines. There also seem to be other non-failure related issues as seen with the Vertex3 launch that everyone jumped on; Lookup "Windows BSOD Vertex3"[2] for a long list of issues. At least enough to make you take pause in buying one. I have a 11 year old Fujitsu drive that is still running, an 8 year old Seagate 15k SCSI drive that is still chugging and the two SATA's in my desktop now are both 3 years old (no RAID)... I expect 5 years out of a drive at this point, turning the speed up to 11 at the expense of digging back into my workstations or servers to replace busted drives and rebuild RAID arrays... uggggg... at least for me that sounds super painful. The only SSDs I would consider at this point if for some reason I had to get one are the Intel series, namely the 500 series. The X-25's (as mentioned) are still going strong with low failure rates and there is nothing to suggest the newer releases are any different. I'd rather see some 5-year results from those things before pulling the trigger though, which is why I haven't yet. I also haven't needed the insane speed. [1] http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2011/05/the-hot-crazy-solid-state-drive-scale.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2011/05/the-hot-crazy-solid... [2] http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&q=windows+bsod+vertex3&qscrl=1 http://www.google.com/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8...
- christoph 15y agoI'll take reliability over almost anything. I work out on the road 200+ days of 365. A drive failing on me while out in the wilds would be a ~~~~ing catastrophe. I can picture it now, Sunday night, after a long flight, code modified on the flight, not in a remote GIT update in a couple of days... failure in such a scenario would mean i'm out of job. No thanks, I'll take the slow HDD
- BoppreH 15y agoHigh failure rate, high price, low capability, but great speeds. So the ideal setup is SSD for your OS and programs and a spinning disk for your documents?
- RyanKearney 15y agoYep that's how I do it. I just have /home mounted on another drive in my linux environment and under Windows I changed the location of my My Documents, My Music, Downloads, etc folders to a traditional drive. You could move your entire user profile over, but some apps do a lot of IO in your AppData folder so you may want to keep that on SSD.
- gte910h 15y agoSSD for your OS, apps and documents where speed matters backed up to your spinner.
- MatthewB 15y agoMy Macbook Air screams. I bought a macbook pro about 1 year ago and my brand new MBA (top model) is noticeably faster. Not only boot and shutdown times but overall snappiness of the machine. The main reason for this is the SSD inside. I love it and will be installing one in my PC desktop soon enough. I can live with the high failure rate although I haven't run into any problems myself yet.
- dekz 15y agoI recently bought from OWC to be shipped internationally. It took 32 days and arrived a DOA drive and had consistent kernel panics (even when doing an initial clone). YMMV but if you're wanting to do an SSD upgrade, get ready to take into account failures.
- cowmixtoo 15y agoSince I posted this link last year: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1584998 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1584998 .... I've put a few DBs on SSD (Postgresql and Filemaker Pro). The real-world performance on extreme concurrent usage was been insane, ie something like a order of magnitude faster. For instance, a query on FileMaker Pro that would take up to 10 minutes on a heavily used instance (100 people accessing at one time) now takes seconds.
- cubicle67 15y agohere's something I'm curious to know - how often do you reboot your computer? I've got two I use daily, one has an uptime of 47 days, the other (a little macbook that spends all day on the road with me) about 32 days. They're just never off. Do people still turn their machines off?
- noarchy 15y agoMy Macbook comes out of sleep mode almost instantaneously, so I come out of it with uptimes that are similar to yours. My PC desktop, meanwhile, gets rebooted when Windows Update demands it, so it varies. There are workplaces where people might be rebooting daily, I don't know. I just know that at home or at work, I don't.
- mike_h 15y agoDropbox is an awesome way to offset the failure risk. I keep all my development projects on Dropbox, so the moment I write to disk, it's syncing with at least one other running workstation plus the Dropbox remote storage. (The brains of my homedir are symlinked to Dropbox as well: all dot files including shell history)
- Derbasti 15y agoI do the same thing. Won't save you when there is no internet, though. Then again, I lost count of how many times Dropbox saved my butt, so that should be a no-brainer regardless of your storage technology.
- Tichy 15y agoA very expensive way, though? My notebooks HD is 250gb, almost filled.
- mike_h 15y agoSorry to see this and respond late, but yeah, mine is pretty big too. Most of that doesn't change hour-to-hour in my use case luckily, so incremental backup to disk is good enough for the bulk. If you work mostly with code or other text, you can probably find a few folders of frequent business that fit on a small Dropbox plan and just sync those.
- keyle 15y agoI have only good things to say about the Corsair SSD's. I'm all SSD now, and they're very fast with very good reviews for a very decent price.
- viae 15y agoI have seen the light and been converted to the Church of SSD. The expense /is/ worth it. I routinely run Windows 7 and Windows Server 2008 (running Windows Deployment Server to reimage computers at different physical locations) on my Macbook Pro via VMWare Fusion at all times (in addition to all the other random apps I have open on the Mac). I haven't noticed /any/ performance penalties day-in-day out. Compare this to my previous Macbook Pro from three years ago, which begged for mercy booting Windows XP. Sure, I have more RAM and an i7 now, but it was always disk thrashing that killed me.... that's not a problem any more.
- unsigner 15y agoEverybody keeps talking of boot drives - and the guy in the video boots his laptop. Do you really boot often enough to make a difference? I think I see my machine boot about 10 times when I reinstall Windows (used to be yearly 10 years ago, much less frequent now), then basically never, modulo city-wide power failures and stealthy Windows Update ninjas in the night. Is it something peculiar to laptops, e.g. when you forget to charge them and they shutdown completely instead of sleeping?