3 ms·
Although this is probably obvious to most people I like to be clear: Working from home is great for employees. It seems likely that a solid majority of employe
by roenxi 6y ago
Although this is probably obvious to most people I like to be clear:
Working from home is great for employees. It seems likely that a solid majority of employees prefer WFH. But this is in the same vein as most employees would prefer to be paid without working anywhere full stop.
Employees are paid, in a large part, to do what their employers think is profitable. If there is a disagreement, the employee's opinion isn't really the guiding star. The question on WFH/Work from Work isn't what the employees prefer, it is almost strictly going to be about what employers think is more valuable.
- mempko 6y agoYou highlighted two important points. >most employees would prefer to be paid without working anywhere full stop. This is true but we should ask why? > If there is a disagreement, the employees opinion isn't really the guiding star. This second point is deeply related to the first. If employees actually owned part of the business like the owners, or to put it another way, there is no employee/employer separation, then it's clear they would want to work since they A) own part of the business and B) have say over the business. There is the concept of Democracy at Work by Richard Wolf as a solution to the two problems you mentioned. As an aside, as someone who owns part of a business, I can say that I also prefer work-from-home.
- leetrout 6y agoHow much of the business do you need to own? A tenth of a percent isn’t much motivation. Sounds like we’d need even splits?
- k3liutZu 6y ago> A tenth of a percent isn’t much motivation. Depends on the size of the company.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago>> most employees would prefer to be paid without working anywhere full stop. > This is true but we should ask why? Huh? The entire concept of working is that you do something you don't want to do in order to get something you do want to have. It makes no sense to ask "why would you prefer to get the good things without having to do the bad things?"
- luckylion 6y ago> If employees actually owned part of the business like the owners, or to put it another way, there is no employee/employer separation, then it's clear they would want to work since they A) own part of the business and B) have say over the business. Just label the employee "contractor" and the employer "client", and you end up with the exact same picture: the contractor would like to be paid by the client without doing any work. The client would like to pay nothing while having all the work done. They meet in the middle somewhere. For subsistence farmers, that might look differently, but mostly it's just an internalized split between wanting the fruits and not wanting the labor.
- iso1210 6y agoMost employers are also employees. What a given middle manager thinks may not be the same as what their manager thinks, or their employees think. Corporations may be legal 'person', but they don't have individual thoughts
- ghaff 6y agoNo. Corporations are not legal persons. They have certain legal rights, and don't have others, that align with the legal rights that people have. Some of those (freedom of speech->freedom to make donations) are more controversial than others (sign a contract).
- iso1210 6y agoNone of those things are done by a corporation, they're done by employees of the corporation - be it the janitor or the CEO.
- ghaff 6y agoWhen a corporation signs a contract, it's a contract with the corporation not with the CFO or whoever, i.e. it doesn't follow the CFO if they take a new job. Similarly, a press release is a statement by the company, not whichever PR person wrote it or the lawyer who approved it.
- iso1210 6y agoIt's irellevent. The corporation doesn't decide to sign a contract, or to tell people to work from office or work from home, employees of the corporation decide to to that act.
- j4yav 6y agoMaybe, but it’s also not an indentured servant program. Companies with better cultures are already actively recruiting people from the ones that want to force everyone back into the office full time as soon as possible, so they can chain them to their desk and watch them work. To me it seems like this will result in these places becoming worse and worse until they collapse under their own weight.