9 ms·
The ideology hiding in SimCity’s black box
- lalalandland 6y agoPing DonHopkins who have done much development on Sim City. I remember reading his musings about testing different 'political' or ideological algorithms for city development. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Hopkins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Hopkins
- infogulch 6y ago20 Minute Neighborhoods just flowed through the front page. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26580238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26580238 I wonder what kind of simulation model would produce a game where the 20 Minute Neighborhood design is optimal.
- cycomanic 6y agoIt's been a long time since I played sim City, but I recall one could build cities with only trains. It was weird because the citizens would complain they want more roads, but at the same time would be perfectly happy. IIRC they would be happier than if you build roads, I always thought it was an odd parallel to the real world.
- antasvara 6y agoHonestly that somewhat reflects the real world, at least in America. It seems to me that most people believe that more roads equals more options and freedom of movement. However, this doesn't take into account the detrimental effects of increased smog, cities optimized for cars instead of pedestrians, and so on. The perceived benefits of more roads, in my opinion, seem to pale in comparison to the detrimental impacts that this would have on cities. Sim City seems to capture this perfectly through the third-person view of a city. There's a difference between being happy and wanting changes that you believe will make you happy, and a computer simulation has captured this distinction by showing both a citizen's actual happiness separate from their desires. Obviously this isn't an exact parallel to the real world as desires can have an impact on one's happiness as well. However, it asks the important question of whether or not we should be designing cities to match desires, or to match what city planners believe would make people the happiest.
- kolinko 6y agoOne of the very few things I liked about the communist system was that something similar to 20 Minute Neighborhoods was very much in place then. There was a rule, that each neighborhood had to have access to all the services (healthcare, kindergardens, schools, "stores" etc) within a walking distance - and you can really see it in the neighborhoods built in that period.
- lwansbrough 6y agoI was disappointed when I learned Cities Skylines doesn’t have mixed use buildings: first 1-2 floors commercial/markets, with the rest residential which are very common where I live. Turns out interspersing residential and commercial zoning based on demand is very effective in their model though, which I was pleased by as that reflects reality. I did find though that the game forces the player to limit the availability of education to provide a sufficient supply of low education workers, which I didn’t find very fun.
- kmeisthax 6y agoOddly enough the developer of Cities Skylines is Finnish and the publisher is Swedish - you'd think mixed use would be the first option!
- fendy3002 6y agoJust wait for the dlc! Jokes aside, maybe it's hard to balance. I mean how do you treat the zone as?
- bobthepanda 6y agoC:S is old enough that it probably warrants a sequel at this point ;) In all seriousness, I think the main issue is that it would require more computation. C:S already runs into computation issues because unlike SimCity, which more or less just calculated a bunch of statistics and then simulated things on screen to reflect that, the former actually treats an individual resident as an agent and does all the calculations for each resident it simulates. IIRC there is a hard limit of 65,536 (a 16-bit unsigned int) agents being simulated so that they don't kill the average consumer computer trying to calculate Djikstra's for more than that amount of agents.
- lasagnaphil 6y agoFor all developers creating city-builder games, it seems there's an inherent dilemma between designing your game at a macroeconomic level and a microeconomic level. Games with macroeconomic simulations (SimCity 4 for example) use sampling-based methods to get statistics about the city and then plug in some simplified equations to simulate things like demand and growth. Your simulations generally behave in the way you want to, with all your assumptions and beliefs about how economics should run. The problem with this is that it fails to capture the nuance of local economic effects, which leads to your game becoming too simplistic (exemplified by the Magnasanti project which is referenced in the article) Games with microeconomic simulations (ex. Cities Skylines) treats every citizen as an independent agent, with their own jobs, families, and movement for work/shopping/travel. The problem with this is that you have less control of how the game will actually play like, and that it's incredibly hard to balance the game (Cities Skylines has a reputation for their systems being "too easy" except for transportation, but I imagine that they made it that way because any further fundamental economic tweaks that make the game harder might actually break the whole game). There's also the technical issue of simulating too many agents. NewCity, one of the more recent city-builder games on early access, is trying to achieve some balance between the two, and it's interesting to read their design decisions (https://lonepine.io/2021/01/15/macroeconomics.html https://lonepine.io/2021/01/15/macroeconomics.html). It seems like a really hard gamedev design problem though.
- steve76 6y ago> slash programs created to help the urban poor and people of color would actually, counterintuitively, help these people. Yes. Yes it will. Much better than modern day barbarity and animalism, proselytized as sincerity. Limit the violence. Don't create it. Don't make everyone happy. Don't turn yourself into a movie star. To everyone else, it's not okay to be a victim.
- comex 6y agoI was hoping they had reverse engineered SimCity and were going to actually reveal some of those formulas, or at least go into more specific examples of non-obviously perverse results. Instead there's only the one example of Magnasanti. Oh well. It's a good topic.
- 0x09 6y agoSomething of an informal reverse engineering of SimCity 3000 existed in sc3000.com's Knowledge Neighborhood. The original site is only partially available via the wayback machine now, though fortunately the articles have been preserved albeit in a slightly less convenient format here https://community.simtropolis.com/profile/157989-catty-cb/content/?type=cms_records1 https://community.simtropolis.com/profile/157989-catty-cb/co... The site contained a pretty amazingly comprehensive detailing of the game's mechanics and various algorithms scattered throughout the articles, to the point where it seemed to me like it'd be possible to implement a lot of the game's engine using it. Some good examples of the more detailed articles: The economy https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/the-economy-r452/ https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/the-ec... Land value specifics https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/land-value-specifics-r453/ https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/land-v... Traffic and transportation specifics https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/traffic-and-transportation-specifics-r447/ https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/traffi... Zone development rules https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/zone-development-rules-r468/ https://community.simtropolis.com/omnibus/other-games/zone-d...
- ChicagoDave 6y agoPretty sure if you create bus lines, you can blow up the your city. At least that’s what I recall. Subway trains were the worst.
- ChicagoDave 6y agoWhy the knocks? Is this like some big spoiler? Pretty sure everyone that played Sim City 2000 figured out the bus line thing.
- csande17 6y agoIt can be fun to try and spot the rhetorical sleight-of-hand trick that articles like this use to come to their eye-catching conclusions: > The art project Magnasanti revealed the contours of the black box when it attempted to “beat” the game that famously doesn’t have a win state [...] Artist Vincent Ocasla accomplished this feat through rigorous trial and error, eventually creating a crime-free city that maintained a stable population of 6 million sims, but only by creating a dystopian nightmare. [...] > Magnasanti reveals the contours of the black box, showing how citizen health and happiness were ultimately unimportant. What the game considers a successful city doesn’t look at all like one we would actually want to live in. SimCity presents an open-ended simulation with a wide range of things players can decide to optimize for. An artist once built a city optimizing for population density and low crime to the exclusion of all other factors, and this resulted in a dystopian nightmare where all the simulated citizens were unhealthy and miserable. But by describing what the artist did as "trying to 'beat' the game", the article pins the blame for the artist's choices on the game itself. Even though SimCity clearly does not think Magnasanti is a good city -- it's constantly flashing up warning messages and graphs showing that all the citizens are miserable and unhealthy! One could just as easily have argued that SimCity's black box is hiding a progressive ideology, one that warns us of the dangers of industrialization and over-policing! (Much like how the board game Monopoly is about the dangers of capitalism.) In essence, an artist set out to 'beat' SimCity, the artist decided what 'beating' SimCity meant, and the article tricked us into thinking that said something about SimCity.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 6y agoSimCity very much does express an ideology, though generally not because the designer wanted to. But try to zone something for mixed use. SimCity itself tells you that certain things will happen under certain conditions, and it is generally wrong about those predictions. It's not intended to be an accurate simulation; it's intended to be amusing and to conform to people's intuitions about what they want to happen when they plan their city in a certain way. But people play it and feel they're learning something about how cities actually work.
- bschne 6y agoMore on this here, goes a bit into the background of the models that inspired SimCity: https://logicmag.io/play/model-metropolis/ https://logicmag.io/play/model-metropolis/
- IAmEveryone 6y agoIt’s a rather obvious flaw, to anyone who has been to any continent but North America. Any old city of Europe, and many of South America, the Mideast and Asia, beats the generic, parking-lot dominated mid-sized American city in quality of Life. NY, SF, and a select few others illustrate the old adage about Americans always doing the right thing, after exhausting all other options. But the vast majority, operating with what planners seem to perceive as endless scrolling in all all directions, are dystopian. Sim City replicates that scenario. Neither its tools, nor depth of simulation, allow for any emergent behaviour that doesn't fit the predefined mould (pun not intended, but appreciated). It’s the grid, the strict zoning, and the coal or nuclear plant built as close to the neighboring city as possible. If your map starts with any hilly terrain, you’ll better bulldoze it now, or you’ll regret it later. If there’s any river, it better fit the grid. Good science is when you get out more than you put into you model. The same is true of simulations, and SimCity never did.
- thaumasiotes 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16561387 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16561387 > I recall something about city planners using Sim City back in the day as part of their education, which horrified Will Wright since in his words (paraphrasing) “sim city is just cellular automata with some differential equations sprinkled on top.” It was never intended to model the development of actual cities.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoPerhaps not, but cities are so very complex, with many, many moving parts (so to speak) and one of the cool things about city building games is that it helps you interact with something remarkably complex. You can start a city from scratch on easy mode. When I haven't played for a while, it's common for me to get tripped up by something stupid and have things go sideways. Fordlandia and other real world efforts to build a city from scratch in the middle of nowhere are generally infamous for having gone sideways. It's quite hard to create a functional city from scratch with all the right moving parts and once things go sideways, it's hard to come up with the money to fix the problems, assuming you can even identify them. You overbuild X and it has knock-on effects of Y and Z that didn't predict or forgot was likely and now you've painted yourself into a corner. Real cities tend to start as a nexus on some transit hub, such as a port at the mouth of a river where the terrain creates a natural port and you don't need much to make it a functional commercial port. Quite a few American cities can trace their origins to being a rail stop on a rail line. Towns can get born or die when new highways get built, depending on whether they are on the new highway or whether the new highway causes traffic to pass them by. Historic small towns on Route 66 were born from traffic passing through them and many of them "died" (or greatly shrank) when Route 66 was replaced was modern limited access highways. If you don't have enough water and electricity, no amount of tax breaks or pro-business government policies will grow your industrial base. Add water, electricity, trains and a port and now you have enormous demand for industry. Of course it doesn't model "actual cities." Models always have their limitations and it's helpful to understand what those are, but you have start somewhere for developing mental models for the complexity of all the moving parts of a living, breathing modern city. Our failure to wrap our minds around that seems to me to be a root cause of a lot of the small town blight and related social issues happening in America today. (This may also be a factor in problems in other countries, but I don't feel qualified to speak to that.)
- supernova87a 6y agoWell, of course, unless a video game company is staffed by macroeconomists, you know that you cannot hope that the modules governing "people and governmental institution behavior model" will be coded to some highly accurate level of realism, right? Their job is to make something feel enough like reality to be plausible, not model real world accuracy to 5%. Just like they may cheat on what warped room reflections are rendered in a mirror you see on the wall, they're going to come up with cheats and simplifications to things about how cities, governments, people act and behave to get it "real enough" to be believable. And just like you have to take with a grain of salt that you cannot jump through a portal and land on the other side of a building, or that women in virtual bars are interested in going on a crime spree, or that flying a plane in GTA IV makes you capable of being a pilot in real life, you have to do the same when a game tells you your choice of a property tax has caused your residents to rebel and lower your approval rating by 8 polling points. Maybe the problem is that some game experiences are obviously not from the real physical world, while these are just enough on the edge of believable to be dangerously convincing. Perhaps the people who want to ensure realism could try coding up an engaging game, complete with IRS forms 8960 and 8825 to get people's behavior right...
- jpttsn 6y agoMacroeconomists don’t know how to do this either.
- dwd 6y agoRaid on Bungling Bay was a fantastic game for anyone who never played it back in the 80s. Spent a lot of hours finishing it - had just the right amount of difficulty as you progressed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- BlueTemplar 6y ago> Algorithms are used to assess child welfare, evaluate teachers, and even “predict” where crime is likely to occur. When Yale researchers asked a bunch of cities to reveal the algorithms that controlled these systems, most of them either denied the request, gave the researchers everything but the actual formulas, or just didn’t respond at all. And this is why at least some countries make this kind of black boxing illegal.
- Lammy 6y agoMulti-layered SimCity ideology example: SimNuclear power plants leave a circle of radiation if they explode. Sounds fine on the surface, since they had to balance the game to actually give nuclear a downside, but it accidentally interacts with other gameplay features to imo unfairly tarnish real-world nuclear in the minds of players. Case in point: I played a lot of SC3000, and that game doesn’t automatically replace utility buildings when they “age out” of their in-game design lifespan. As soon as any plopped utility building hits year N+1 it’s immediately destroyed and replaced with a nonfunctional ruined (“Defunct”) version of the tile. That feature is annoying enough when a bunch of your water pumping stations all blow up at once and cause water service disruptions, but it means all in-game nuclear plants will explode and spread radiation like that exactly 71 years after being plopped unless you manually bulldoze and rebuild them. Doing it earlier than 70 years is a waste of money since the new plant costs the same amount regardless, so players will always be tempted to let it go as long as possible and only replace at the last minute. On top of that, any building (plopped or otherwise) that catches fire and is allowed to burn will also become destroyed/defunct. If your city’s total electrical usage exceeds any one power plant’s electrical capacity, that power plant will catch on fire. If it’s a nuclear plant and you don’t put the fire out, the plant is destroyed and spreads radiation. If you have multiple nuclear plants and accidentally let one of them get to be 71 years old, it will explode and irradiate its surroundings as mentioned. The sudden drop in total electrical capacity will almost certainly overload the other plants, then they will catch fire and may also explode and irradiate their surroundings. Maxis plz