4 ms·
My SO had fMRI done before her first brain surgery for glioma that was located near speech center and motor cortex. It wasn't a big deal, so I think they apply
by scotty79 6y ago
My SO had fMRI done before her first brain surgery for glioma that was located near speech center and motor cortex.
It wasn't a big deal, so I think they apply it routinely in some cases in their practice.
I'm not sure if they got much from it because it was really low res in comparison with standard MRI.
Although she made a full recovery after that surgery.
- ska 6y agoThat’s interesting! You are right the resolution (both spatial and temporal) and accurately coregistering (and then with surgery, brain shift) can be among the limiting factors for clinical use. Plus the difficult in getting good signal. I suspect this has more to do with where they had it done than anything else. There are neurosurgeons who champion it for sure , but not that many. Most places aren’t set up for it at all from what I’ve seen. I'm guessing her procedure wasnt' done awake, was it? This is a very common way to deal with the functional stuff especially near speech or motor. Glad to hear she had a good outcome!
- unsrsly 6y agoAwake cortical mapping has much better resolution than fMRI, and it avoids image registration issues, but it requires a great deal of planning and patient motivation. If it turns out that the language center is on the opposite side from the area of the surgery, then awake mapping might not even be necessary. This is why fMRI is often used as a planning step before awake cortical mapping during the actual surgery.
- ska 6y ago> why fMRI is often used as a planning step It really isn't - see my other comment. The other thing to consider here is unintentional media bias - when a lay publication wants information they tend to go to tier 1 research & academic institutions; exactly the sort of place that has all the latest new toys. This is often very far from typical practice. So people outside of healthcare hear about all sort of things that are a decade or more from general usage, even if they get there eventually. From the outside, it's probably difficult to understand how conservative medicine is generally. Even effective new practices often take decades to become really mainstream.
- unsrsly 6y agoI'm not on the outside of medicine. Significant practice variation exists, but complex neurosurgical conditions are usually managed at academic centers and fMRI is used for planning in neurooncology [1] and epilepsy surgery [2]. [1] https://thejns.org/focus/view/journals/neurosurg-focus/48/2/article-pE11.xml https://thejns.org/focus/view/journals/neurosurg-focus/48/2/... [2] https://n.neurology.org/content/88/4/395.long https://n.neurology.org/content/88/4/395.long
- ska 6y ago> I'm not on the outside of medicine. Fair enough, I didn't mean to suggest you were I was speaking more generally but worded that poorly. My comments come from systems supporting thousands of clinical neurooncological procedures (i.e. tumor resections) in planning and execution with very little interest or utilization of fMRI beyond a handful proponents and their sites. Quite literally barely on the radar of most of the neurosurgeons apart from occasional papers, and some of them are quite negative about it also. I could have an inaccurate picture of the breadth of clinical practice, and it's certainly a couple years out of date, but I would be very surprised to find a huge upsurge of usage outside research had happened. It is certainly the case that the articles claim of "transformation" hasn't happened in that space. If the article had instead claimed that some of the trickiest cases tend to have fMRI done (true, surgeons will take all they help they can get trying cases that otherwise might be inoperable) or that they are a feature of high profile academic sites (also mostly true) I wouldn't have objected.
- unsrsly 6y agoI respect your experience, and I'll concede that fMRI for pre-surgical planning in neurooncology is used at only some centers. If you worked mainly in neurooncology you may have missed some of the uses of fMRI for epilepsy surgery. Thanks for the discussion.
- ska 6y agoHey that's a good point - I have much less data on epilepsy (although we were interested in it) For me fMRI falls into the cool-but-has-some-issues (mainly around consistency and processing) side of tech. And yes, thanks for the discussion.
- scotty79 6y ago> Awake cortical mapping She had that too. > This is why fMRI is often used as a planning step before awake cortical mapping during the actual surgery. That must have been the case. I guess surgeons were trying to do whatever was in their power to not damage her speech center. Right after operation she had a few brief seizures when she lost ability to speak for a minute or two, but as the damage healed they quickly stopped.
- unsrsly 6y agoThat must have been scary, but I'm glad she had a good outcome.
- unsrsly 6y agoThank you for sharing your story. Although fMRI has low resolution, it can be very useful for surgical planning in certain clinical scenarios. For example, to determine hemispheric dominance: "Although the estimated percentages are of some debate, language is the purview of the left hemisphere in approximately 95% of right-handed people and 70% of left-handed people ... At MSKCC, language lateralization mapping is most often requested in right-handed patients with left hemispheric lesions, left-handed patients with left or right hemispheric lesions, or right-handed patients with right hemispheric lesions and signs or symptoms of aphasia." [1] [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4966674/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4966674/
- scotty79 6y ago> mapping is most often requested in right-handed patients with left hemispheric lesions That was the case for my SO.