3 ms·
In other words, the software is "free" only if your time has no value. Amazing how long some really smart people took to reach this really obvious conclusion.
by jqpabc123 6y ago
In other words, the software is "free" only if your time has no value. Amazing how long some really smart people took to reach this really obvious conclusion.
What's missing with Linux on the desktop is an overriding vision and guiding force to direct the overall effort toward a clear objective.
This open source army has lots of generals but it is missing a commander in chief. Lots of battles being fought and won but the war is not moving any closer to a conclusion.
- pimeys 6y agoBut what if hacking computers is my hobby? What if I actually get lots of joy digging into an operating system and how it works? Then there are no other options than the free systems... And I have been this way for almost 30 years now... And you can then find your niche from there. For me it's a nixos/sway/emacs/firefox that serves me well and gives me enormous power when I need it. I'm a programmer anyway, so loving linux comes naturally.
- pjmlp 6y agoI am programming since mid-80s, fail to see why I should naturally love Linux because of that.
- pimeys 6y agoI think what I tried to reply here is to the idea of not liking to play with the operating system. I love it. Systems programming, understanding how your OS works AND being able to go to the lowest level and fix things by yourself. It's a pretty good deal and I'm not doing this just because Apple and Microsoft force their own ideology and tracking down my throat, but because this is my passion... I hope I can stay in my niche for the rest of my life and there's no sudden movement to closed systems that will take it away from me.
- pjmlp 6y agoI do exactly the same on Windows, macOS, UNIX and whatever OS I can put my hands on. When I came into contact with Linux, I was already coding for a decade, used Xenix and DG/UX before, it was just a mean to save trips to the university computer center. After graduating, HP-UX, Solaris, Aix, NT/2000 were the OSes I cared about. Then J2ME and Symbian came into play. GNU/Linux became relevant again to me as the other UNIX vendors messed up and it is basically the only option alongside Windows for server deployments. However thanks to cloud language runtimes, the actual OS is becoming irrelevant to me. On the desktop side I rather play with macOS/iOS/Windows/Android stacks. And on embedded, bare metal runtimes for Arduino and ESP32 are where my fun is at. So programming and Linux doesn't come naturally to me, it was just a means to free beer UNIX when I couldn't afford something else. Anyway if that is your fun, enjoy.
- xtracto 6y agoI used to do that in my 20s ?got a history in /.) . Now in my early 40s I still could do it but I just dont care... theres so many times I can get joy compiling the kernel, tinkering with ALSA/Pulseaudio, winmodems, xfree86 , bluetooth and countless rough edges. The last I did was compile a kernel in mint with custom scheduler to fix some bug to play CS:GO. In this day an age... why do I need to do that? It's not Linux fault, but its Linux problem.
- pimeys 6y agoAnd I come here always to remind people in the Apple bubble, that there are big groups of us who are not thinking like that! I'm also soon in my 40s and I had my Apple years between 2004 and 2010. I came back to Linux and kind of hate the word tinkering even. The current Linux system offers something that nobody else does: your own desktop just how you like it. I have my configs in GitHub: https://github.com/pimeys/nixos https://github.com/pimeys/nixos With this config, I can take any ThinkPad (that are plentiful, great HW and cheap), boot from USB and get the same exact desktop experience I've had for almost a decade now in twenty minutes. And what kind of desktop? A minimal tiling window manager on top of Wayland. Exactly the applications I need. The same wallpaper as always. The same editor, the same browser, the same keyboard shortcuts, the same kernel params, the same internet setup. Sound? Always worked. With PipeWire, it even seems to work better than on my Windows installation (and replacing PulseAudio with PipeWire was a one line config change). Now. There will be no product manager somewhere that will dictate how I use my computer. If something changes in my workflow, that comes from my configuration. Nowhere else. No advertisement for new products, no suddenly disappearing applications. If something breaks from an update, I just boot to the version before I started them and I'm back to the previous state. When updates are leaving me to a state I'm happy about, I commit them to that GitHub repo and they will work exactly the same until I decide to update again. And I run the master branch of NixOS which is breaking sometimes, and it's still much more stable experience I ever had with OSX... Of course this is not for everybody, but please understand when celebrating the commercial offerings how there's so many of us who do not want a desktop experience dictated by product managers. Who are kind of conservative how our workflows should stay the same for years, or decades. And we are still super productive, doing our work and very happy using Linux.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- marco_craveiro 6y agoI disagree, actually. I think we already have Windows and OSX for that, and even Android and Chromebooks. I think the biggest value of Linux Desktop is that it is an experimental playground for a melting pot of ideas. I have used Linux on the desktop exclusively at home since ~1998 and, like Miguel, I went through a lot of pain. Heck, I remember the days when I couldn't even boot my machine without tampering with the kernel. And to compare that to what we now have, well its a world apart. I have been using Debian Testing for some 8 years or more and in that period I probably had one or two (at the very most) dist-upgrades that borked my system. And those have always been due to binary NVidia drivers. For me, the importance of Linux is that it offers something that no one else can offer - I could take this exact same setup back to my home country and start teaching kids and they would have exactly the same setup as me, with top tools, even though their hardware would be extremely old. I do not think its important that Linux takes over the desktop, much as we all would love it. What is important is that it remains viable without changing its fundamental characteristics. And that, I think, has already been achieved.
- aasasd 6y agoOfftopic: I'm here from the thread where you asked fractionalhare for a mirror of their article, and in which thread it's not possible to reply anymore. Well it seems the article is available in the Wayback Machine: https://web.archive.org/web/20201205202104/https://www.pseudorandom.com/implementing-exp https://web.archive.org/web/20201205202104/https://www.pseud...
- SubjectToChange 6y agoIn other words, the software is "free" only if your time has no value. Amazing how long some really smart people took to reach this really obvious conclusion. This is both asinine and patronizing. People and businesses do, in fact, understand TCO and make decisions based on it. What's missing with Linux on the desktop is an overriding vision and guiding force to direct the overall effort toward a clear objective. This is daydreaming. Of course it would be nice if some übermensch stepped in straightened things out. But that's never going to happen for multiple reasons. Personally, the Linux desktop as it is more than enough for me. It makes no difference whether it's mainstream or not.
- sergeykish 6y agoThis "guiding principle" is tirany, we've got it in Windows and macOS. By stomping alternatives übermensch just allienates users. Make successful product and it would be ported. WSL is part of the Windows by Microsoft choice.
- xtracto 6y agoThis kind of happened with Mark Shuttleworth in 2005. At that time you had Suse and Mandrake/mandriva as the top desktop distributions. Both were going out though: Suse was moving to servers/closed source and mandriva was in crisis. Mark's millions gave desktop linux a good push and it spawned a new generation of desktop linux (like Mint)