3 ms·
I dont think apple is entitled to that information on any basis, and i dont think its a legitimate threat to expose actual ill behaviour
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
I dont think apple is entitled to that information on any basis, and i dont think its a legitimate threat to expose actual ill behaviour
- young_unixer 6y agoI think they're talking about the implication that if Apple don't pay, then the vulnerability is published. I agree with you on a moral basis: what difference does it make if I get payed not to publish it vs. If I just publish it without even asking to get paid. But I'm not sure the law would agree with us.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI think, like in many legal matters, precedent and intent is key. Without ill intent there is no 'mens rea', or "guilty mind". In this case you aren't just a vigilante targetting apple, there is established practice stretching decades. There is also a duty on you as a security proffeshional, and there is a significant public interest in knowing about the vulnerability. So , most likely, it will be you doing your job.
- mdpopescu 6y agoAll blackmail involves exposing something that someone doesn't want exposed - usually because the "something" is illegal. And yet, blackmail itself is illegal. Most countries have a culture against whistleblowers, starting from childhood ("don't be a tattletale", "don't be a rat").
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoAnd that anti-whistleblower culture enables fraud like theranos to be undiscovered for years