5 ms·
So it's 100% certain that the only real, long term solution is to enable real competition. Probably most would agree with that. However, given the infrastructu
by mattmaroon 18y ago
So it's 100% certain that the only real, long term solution is to enable real competition. Probably most would agree with that.
However, given the infrastructure demands, that's very hard (but possible) and will take a long time. We should push for it clearly, but we need something in between.
Given that most people have only 2, maybe 3 available providers, we need the government to intervene in the mean time to enforce net neutrality. It's a stopgap measure to be sure, but it's a necessary one.
Government regulating natural monopolies in the interest of the consumer is pretty common and relatively effective.
- stcredzero 18y agoThe problem is that, in the US, political will often dies with the stopgap solution.
- mattmaroon 18y agoThat's true, but in that case our alternative is to have a monopolistic broandband provider in each area with the ability to discriminate against traffic/websites. The stopgap solution, even if left in place permanently with no further progress, is far better than that.
- dominik 18y agoI disagree. It's far better to address the root of the problem rather than just treating the symptoms on the surface. The symptoms on the surface are that monopolistic broandband providers discriminate against traffic or websites. The root of the problem is that there are monopolistic broandband providers rather than a competitive free market. Why are there monopolistic broandband providers? Where do we get our Internet from? Generally, either DSL or Cable. DSL comes via the children of another monopolistic (or at least oligopolistic) industry: telecom. And cable comes via yet another monopolistic (or at least oligopolistic) industry: cable television. Monopoly breeds monopoly, ever expanding into new industries to monopolize, more often with the government's blessings than not.
- mattmaroon 18y agoBut we're in a system where addressing the root problem isn't going to happen any time soon (and is way beyond the purview of the FCC) and without a stopgap measure we'll have nothing. We'll have a broadband oligarchy able to charge Google to be delivered to customers while Yahoo isn't. We should fix the root problem, but in the mean time a stopgap is necessary to ensure the web's economic viability. Without that we risk falling behind the rest of the world. It's too idealistic and impractical to wait.
- dominik 18y agoI think the stopgap might create a problem worse than the one it's trying to solve :-/
- mattmaroon 18y agoWhat problem is worse than monopolistic broadband providers being able to sell favor to anyone with a web presence? That seems like it would jeopardize the entire future of our information economy.
- dominik 18y agoAnd there's nothing that politicians like more than a captive monopoly that relies on favorable regulations to continue to prosper. In 10 years: We can't deregulate the Internet industry because then they'd stop donating to our campaigns since we wouldn't have control over them.