16 ms·
It makes sense. In my experience the primary goal for most crypto holders is to be a part of a new elite. This is why the most popular currencies have a fixed
by endisneigh 6y ago
It makes sense.
In my experience the primary goal for most crypto holders is to be a part of a new elite. This is why the most popular currencies have a fixed supply. That way, if they're popular earlier adopters get to be a part of the elite. With such a premise it makes sense to treat crypto like the lottery as the gain/loss likelihood is very similar to say, Mega Millions.
I do see value in a crypto that's pinned at a weighted average of every single currencies' worldwide weight. That way you get the advantage of crypto, but it's a perfectly stable currency. Needless to say, very few people at least on HN have bragged about owning an inflationary crypto currency. Why? Because they're not getting rich nor is there an opportunity for them to be a part of the techno-elite.
My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. Many advocates argue that governments shouldn't provide stimulus but history shows that's generally a terrible idea (the gold standard, for example, contributed in some ways to The Great Depression).
EDIT: I don't feel like responding individually, but I will say that I've read both the Bitcoin and Ethereum whitepaper and there's nothing about grievances of traditional governments usage of printing of their currencies.
I feel that the "that's a feature" is more a post-hoc rationalization that allows one to say they're in the right while simultaneously benefiting early adopters. Regardless, every government in world history that's pinned their currency to something that's relatively fixed has had a severe depression with some part of that depression being contributed to said pinning. It's just not good economics. Feel free to respond with a contrary example if you'd like.
- uncletammy 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. That's a feature. Not a bug.
- therein 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. Good, that's the intention.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIronically, the cryptocurrency world as a whole is constantly increasing the supply of cryptocurrency and crypto assets. The ultimate supply of Bitcoin and other coins might be fixed, but we’re seeing new cryptocurrencies rolled out all the time. The number of altcoins on the market is staggering and it has never been easier for someone to arbitrarily create their own coin. It’s not uncommon for popular cryptocurrencies to fork, doubling their supply overnight in absolute terms. One usually prevails, but several popular forks continue to chug along. Now we’ve even moved on to minting arbitrary NFT tokens of things to continue increasing the supply of crypto assets. If you look past singular cryptocurrencies, the entire cryptosphere has become a money printer.
- therein 6y agoBut that's a better way of doing it, isn't it? A new currency poses the question of additional value to the relevant population and the population determines its value. This new supply in the form of another cryptocurrency will go through price-discovery and it may turn out that it will fail to reach or maintain any significant market capitulation. Rather than some central authority (ab)using their position to weigh into the answer to that question that they themselves are asking. I see this equivalent to updating a contract unilaterally and arguing it is an upgrade versus letting the contract that both parties agreed on stay intact and sign additional contracts. If the government had printed SARS-COV-2-USD, we could have collectively decided it is backed by hot air and valued it differently but instead we were forced to dilute the supply of our already existent supply.
- africanboy 6y ago> instead we were forced to dilute the supply of our already existent supply the expenses to keep the system running are diluted too.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kneel 6y ago>My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. That's... that's the whole point.
- vkou 6y agoWhat makes you so eager to live in a deflationary money system?
- kneel 6y agoI'd prefer to live in a hybrid system where I can allocate what I need, where I need, when I want. There is a very good argument for fiat as well as a good argument for crypto.
- cool_dude85 6y agoYou want to be able to put some of your money in a less-liquid form, hoping to earn some return? Have I got good news for you about the past thousand years or so.
- kneel 6y agoYeah? Tell me about it
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoIt worked forever until the greedy elite decided to move from a gold backed currency so that they're able to print money at whim to further their interests, while leaving the rest of the people far behind.
- bko 6y ago> I do see value in a crypto that's pinned at a weighted average of every single currencies' worldwide weight, but it's a perfectly stable currency If every government in the world is printing money like crazy, how is this "stable". In the US, 23% of the money supply was created in the last year, with no visible inflation (excluding asset prices, home, energy, etc). God knows what it'll be 5 years from now What has been "stimulated" by the US creating 12 trillion in new asset besides re-inflating stock prices? It reminds me of a joke about a group being really hungry so deciding to slice their pizza into 10 slices as opposed to 8. Money is supposed to be a unit of account. I think you can try to play games with it but in the end you're messing with complex systems with a high probability of creating unintended consequences (e.g. credit crisis, bail out, hyperinflation etc).
- vkou 6y ago> If every government in the world is printing money like crazy, how is this "stable". It's stable because during a recession, as loans are closed out or default or just don't get issued, money gets destroyed/created slower. The government may be printing money, but fractional reserve banks aren't. This is a point on which most people who talk about printing presses are completely ignorant of.
- bko 6y agoMaybe there are fewer loans because business prospects are worse. By every measure of money supply, the amount has increased. Again, its a complicated system. Playing games is dangerous, especially when everything is politicized and no one is held accountable for their actions.
- dlp211 6y agoIf the dollars are borrowed or printed in exchange for collateral, no value has been destroyed, just dollars have been issued to account for that value. Not all newly printed dollars are the same, and this idea that M1/M2 volume is important to determine inflation is an outdated way of thinking. What the US has "stimulated" is preventing the economy from going into a recession. There are many businesses that are open today because of the money the US gov't has put into the economy. There are landlords that have been paid because of the money put into the economy. And the US economy is forecasted to have over 6% growth this year. Don't conflate the economy doesn't seem like it's booming/stimulated with the money the US gov't has pumped into the economy has done nothing. I know I can't prove a counterfactual, but if we had done nothing, the US would not IMO be fairing so well right now.
- chrisco255 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. New cryptos are being minted all the time. If a government wanted to issue more fiat as a crypto token it could do so directly.
- V-2 6y ago"I do see value in a crypto that's pinned at a weighted average of every single currencies' worldwide weight" The values of currencies are only relative (established by exchange rates). How do you calculate an average for all the existing currencies (weighted or otherwise)? What am I missing?
- DFHippie 6y agoYou use the price of some common basket of goods. Most participants in an economy are chiefly interested in the price of goods and services, after all, not other currencies. Of course, choosing the basket of goods and adjusting it over time is a little tricky...
- V-2 6y agoI feel like it's a different measure than the proposed one, though.
- MrMan 6y agoIf you hold a basket of currencies this can be traded as an instrument. There is a long standing proposal for example to speed the adoption of a multi-currency basket as kind of a forced substitution of the dollar as global reserve currency, an idea that has a lot of merit.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rawtxapp 6y ago> but I will say that I've read both the Bitcoin and Ethereum whitepaper and there's nothing about grievances of traditional governments usage of printing of their currencies From Bitcoin's genesis block: "The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks".
- eyeball 6y agoPerfect rebuttal to those saying the “store of value” is a pivot after it failed as digital cash. (And maybe it hasn’t failed yet)
- endisneigh 6y agoI’m not really sure what your point is? The block was created on the that date, that had that title. It’s a complete coincidence. Again if that was an explicit goal it would be in the white paper.
- gazzini 6y agoThis is the first time I’ve ever heard anyone suggest this was a coincidence. You might actually be correct — I personally doubt it, but it’s a funny thought... to think that we all just over-indexed on this trivial detail.
- tromp 6y agoI think you overestimate the importance of whether an emission is capped or not. I would argue [1] that the more important issue is whether the inflation rate is eventually negligible, which is where fiat is lacking. [1] https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-supply-1169a188d153 https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-su...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tshaddox 6y ago> In my experience the primary goal for most crypto holders is to be a part of a new elite. This part doesn’t sound very different from investing in startups, where everyone is hoping to get in really early on the next unicorn. Seems to me the main difference is that this kind of “investment” is generally only available to people who are already “elite” in some sense (i.e. sufficiently wealthy and/or connected).
- cool_dude85 6y agoI almost hate to say it, but compare the benefit of silicon valley startups to broader society and the benefit of bitcoin to broader society. So, either way, lucky duckies get mega rich, richer than anyone should be, but at least the SV stuff usually actually does something.
- tshaddox 6y agoSilicon Valley companies seem to vary in the sign of their value to society. I wouldn’t purport to be able to determine and sum them all.
- gher-shyu3i 6y ago> richer than anyone should be What's the upper limit on how rich a person should be in your view?
- pchristensen 6y agoI think most people wouldn't be able to provide a dollar value for the upper limit, but could confidently say that $100B is over it.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoWhy is $100B too much? Who's to say there is some inherent limit to wealth? Sounds borderline communist if you ask me (and I'm not a free market capitalist myself).
- me551ah 6y agoI don't think governments are going to just sit and watch as they lose control of their currency. Governments need to have the ability to provide a stimulus package if necessary. If something blocks them from doing it, they will just ban it.
- nknealk 6y ago> the gold standard, for example, contributed in some ways to The Great Depression Most people don’t realize this. A great book on the topic is Lords of Finance which outlines how the gold standard made the Great Depression truly great. Even during covid, I don’t think people realize just how fundamentally important Fed actions were to basic things like keeping food on grocery store shelves.
- bko 6y agoThere is plenty of blame to throw around during interventionist policies during the Great Depression. Take a look at Wickard v Filburn: > An Ohio farmer, Roscoe Filburn, was growing wheat to feed animals on his own farm. The US government had established limits on wheat production, based on the acreage owned by a farmer, to stabilize wheat prices and supplies. Filburn grew more than was permitted and so was ordered to pay a penalty. In response, he said that because his wheat was not sold, it could not be regulated as commerce, let alone "interstate" commerce (described in the Constitution as "Commerce... among the several states"). The Supreme Court disagreed: "Whether the subject of the regulation in question was 'production', 'consumption', or 'marketing' is, therefore, not material for purposes of deciding the question of federal power before us.... But even if appellee's activity be local and though it may not be regarded as commerce, it may still, whatever its nature, be reached by Congress if it exerts a substantial economic effect on interstate commerce and this irrespective of whether such effect is what might at some earlier time have been defined as 'direct' or 'indirect It was illegal for farmers to grow wheat above a certain amount... on their own land... to feed their own animals... You have people trying to tinker with complicated system. Gold is not complicated. It's a unit of account. There's a fixed amount of it with a pretty well known supply and demand. This is the way the world existed since 1971. That's the main value prop of crypto currencies, and by the price appreciation and interest, its a pretty strong feature. Its good to have a fixed unit of account available in the world when money supply can jump by 25% at any time due to the actions of a dozen or so individuals appointed by politicians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wickard_v._Filburn
- pixl97 6y ago>Gold. There's a fixed amount of it with a pretty well known supply and demand. At least until someone lands a autonomous mining craft on an asteroid full of it can crashes the market. Anything can be upset by changes in technology.
- gher-shyu3i 6y ago> Why? Because they're not getting rich nor is there an opportunity for them to be a part of the techno-elite. Or they want to get away from government controlled artificially inflated currency.
- anonporridge 6y agoEven years ago before the previous bull run, the most compelling narrative was that bitcoin would first displace gold as a store of value, and then maybe become a global currency. Some people did still cling to the 'digital cash for everyone' narrative, but it's pretty clear that doesn't scale. It's not clear if bitcoin will scale for global payments with second layers, but it seems like the most compelling approach. Now, there is a competing narrative that bitcoin doesn't even need to take over as a currency. Rock solid store of value that is impossible to debase is more than enough to still be worth at least an order of magnitude more. It's a technology to protect savers from having their wealth stolen through currency inflation. Wealthy people already protect themselves with a diversified basket of assets and treat currency like a hot potato. But the poor and middle class often don't have the knowledge, time, or access to protect their wealth. The trend of widening wealth inequality in the US seems to have taken off right around the time we abandoned the gold standard in the 70s. It used to be that everyone could just save their currency and that was a really good store of value. Now savings accounts yield ~0.5% and you have to put your money in more risky assets just to preserve your value. It could be that we end up with a world with both bitcoin as a reserve asset, where you sweep all your excess cash that you don't want to invest, and government fiat currencies, which they can continue to use for stimulus and to print their way out of debt, but without debasing savers to do it as they are now.
- bko 6y agoI read that gold actually outperformed the stock market since the end of the gold standard in the US (1971). I didn't really believe it , but it sort of did, depending on when you bought gold [0]. Not that gold is a good investment, but it does say something that its increased at ~7% a year since introduction of a completely fiat currency. I'm not smart enough to have a story to explain what that all means, but let's just say its ... weird [0] https://mleverything.substack.com/p/performance-of-gold-since-1971 https://mleverything.substack.com/p/performance-of-gold-sinc...
- webinvest 6y agoFrom Jan 1st 1971 to Dec 31st 2020, the US stock market grew by 10.91%/year CAGR if you include dividends which you should. 7.70%/year CAGR if you don’t include dividends. In that time frame, $1 has grown to $177.33. I did the math to find out what the melt value of a $10 1913 gold coin would be today in 2021. Over that more than 100 year time frame, the CAGR of gold is 5%/year. Since 10.91% is far higher than 5% or 7%, I’m inclined to believe that investing in productive companies is far better than investing in a hunk of yellow metal that just sits there.
- devmunchies 6y ago> In my experience the primary goal for most crypto holders is to be a part of a new elite. as opposed to new banks and funds, who want to be part of the established elite? > Needless to say, very few people at least on HN have bragged about owning an inflationary crypto currency. Why? Because they're not getting rich people don't brag about failed businesses either. > Regardless, every government in world history that's pinned their currency to something that's relatively fixed has had a severe depression with some part of that depression being contributed to said pinning. It's just not good economics. yeah but people could afford a home 50 years ago so theres that to consider. you're accounting for the ability to curb the impact of a depressive event, which is good, but an inflationary currency might have a bigger, deeper impact over 40 years than on the surface.
- hammock 6y ago>I do see value in a crypto that's pinned at a weighted average of every single currencies' worldwide weight. That way you get the advantage of crypto, but it's a perfectly stable currency. Digital SDRs, also known as IMFcoin. It's coming. Likely in the next two years. It won't be decentralized.
- rasengan 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. If people have consensus to fork and create more coins, then so it will be; but that decision will not be made alone by a single actor.
- endisneigh 6y agoMeaning it’ll never happen as holders of crypto are accountable to no one .
- rasengan 6y agoA simple proposal and vote by software upgrade would allow the coordination of this. It’s happened many times already in the blockchain space.
- endisneigh 6y agoSoftware upgrades are not the same as people voting for what's effectively taxation.
- lamontcg 6y ago> My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. Many advocates argue that governments shouldn't provide stimulus but history shows that's generally a terrible idea (the gold standard, for example, contributed in some ways to The Great Depression). Your concern here isn't big enough. Your implicitly assuming that it functions like Gold and/or USD in some healthy way. The biggest concern is really that it operates like a distributed wildcat banking system without any kind of FDIC or Fed backing up the currency. Once there is a panic then it will unwind with no kinds of circuit breakers in place. Everyone treats "the full faith and credit of the US government" as a joke and so think that a financial system that ignores the whole history of bank panics doesn't even need to pay lip service to those ideas and it'll be fine. Economic history shows that this will end badly for crypto -- like a law of gravity. It may also end badly for the US before too long, but everyone is due for a lesson in why those words are there for a reason. And nobody needs crypto to pay their groceries, rent, mortgage or taxes. Everyone can choose to quit crypto tomorrow and most of the population of the world won't care. It is incredibly difficult to quit the USD. Arguing about inflationary/deflationary currencies implicitly adopts the language that there's something useful there, when its just a really large distributed ponzi scheme that hasn't collapsed yet.
- DINKDINK 6y agoI find this post very confusing. >I've read both the Bitcoin and Ethereum whitepaper and there's nothing about grievances of traditional governments usage of printing of their currencies and >[The desire to be a part of a "new elite"] is why the most popular currencies have a fixed supply. That way, if they're popular earlier adopters get to be a part of the elite. Technical papers tend to focus on their contribution to knowledge. In Bitcoin's case it's a distributed systems paper that shows a globally consistent database is possible in an adversarial network with no central coordinator, if finality properties are allowed to be probibalistic in the short term. Though an cryptography author may feel passionately about Bill of Rights, 4th Amendment protections, they needn't say it in a paper they write about a cryptographic primative. and If we are to assume bitcoin is a "popular currency" and want to read the opinions of early thinkers rather than straw-man them: I also do think that there is potential value in a form of unforgeable token whose production rate is predictable and can't be influenced by corrupt parties. This would be more analogous to gold than to fiat currencies. [1] To me that doesn't read as advocating for the creation of a new "elite" (whatever that is) [1] https://www.mail-archive.com/cryptography@metzdowd.com/msg09975.html https://www.mail-archive.com/cryptography@metzdowd.com/msg09... >I do see value in a crypto that's pinned at a weighted average of every single currencies' worldwide weight. [People holding these 'weighted average' currencies a]re not getting rich How is it that these supposed weighted average monies are superior while simultaneously no one in the market place is demanding them while simultaneously the demand for bitcoin is increasing? The exchange ratio, what you're saying is price, cannot be arbitrarily decreed (Thou shall have X weighted exchange ratio with all government monies). Exchange ratios / prices are the result of many individual agents swaping, exchanging with eachother. All previous attempts at information/digital monies (see bmoney) failed because of this misunderstanding of how prices arise. >My biggest concern is a fixed-supply currency gives no government the ability to provide stimulus if necessary. How does printing/diluting money create wealth? If someone wants to work for a money that's costly for them to obtain (via work) and costless for someone else to obtain (money printing) they're free to do so -- the problem is that one will bankrupt themselves doing so relative to someone wants to work for a money that's just as costly for everyone else to obtain. Those still holding their wealth in fiat monies (euro, dollar, yuan, yen) or fiat-economy derivatives (bonds, fiat-company equities/stocks) are exposed to this bankrupcy potential -- it's the same dynamic as all currency debasements manifest. >every government in world history that's pinned their currency to something that's relatively fixed has had a severe depression with some part of that depression being contributed to said pinning. It's just not good economics. Governments aren't economies, Whether people can produce more than they consume (a functioning economy) is orthogonal to whether the same people who have the monopoly on violence also are trying to enforce a monetary monopoly as well. If a government fails because it consumes more than it produces, that reflects a failure in the management of said government -- not because someone, somewhere has a money in their posession. Typically, it's marginally harder for people to produce more than they consume when they're forced to be subject to a cartel/monopoly.
- DennisP 6y agoThe only way that would be an economic problem is if the fixed-supply currency were the only currency, i.e. the one and only legal tender. That seems very unlikely to happen. Even if government currencies were to somehow disappear, it would still be trivially easy for anyone to launch a new currency, just by deploying a short script on any smart contract chain. With multiple currencies, we're closer to the competing private currencies advocated by Hayek, who thought they'd bring about a stable economy without need for manual intervention. I'm not competent to judge whether he was right, but it's clear we're not going back to an equivalent of the gold standard.