3 ms·
While I agree that the world would be a better place if people refused giving as much information as possible, the specific fix here is to not consider social s
by mindslight 6y ago
While I agree that the world would be a better place if people refused giving as much information as possible, the specific fix here is to not consider social security numbers private information in the first place - they're clearly identifiers, not shared secrets. There is nothing about them that verifies anything - it's basically the database-friendly version of your name.
But yes, this could have all been headed off if the social security act had prohibited private organizations from requesting, using, or storing these identifiers in the first place, for anything but immediately passing them on to tax authorities. A Customer ID is good enough for all non-credit uses, and credit should require actual in-person verification to issue. But this is the general shape of totalitarianism in the US. The government mandates the barest minimum of systems, companies lobby against any restrictions that would prevent their abusing it, and we end up with a legally-mandated freedom-destroying system invading most aspects of our lives.
PS I've got to wonder about a blockchain solution for keeping a public catalog of leaked PII that gets abused for verification. Make the "exploit" plain as day and companies will have to change. Right now the carding community keep this to themselves, and out of sight is out of mind for the companies that continue to abuse it.