5 ms·
I have a Unifi LR AP I want to replace. I have a three level home and this AP really struggles to provide coverage. I think my mistake was getting a directional
by Waterluvian 6y ago
I have a Unifi LR AP I want to replace. I have a three level home and this AP really struggles to provide coverage. I think my mistake was getting a directional AP.
Are there any decent consumer alternatives if I'm done with Ubiquiti?
- sliken 6y agoI've looked, haven't found anything clearly better. Just got a Unifi Wifi-6 LR AP. Seems reasonable to just block APs from internet traffic and run the AP management software locally (also with traffic blocked from the internet). If you find something better, please post.
- ehutch79 6y agoYou really will likely need multiple APs. one of the consume mesh setups like eero or orbi or whatever will help
- pixl97 6y agoI'm going to agree with ehutch on this. Don't try to cover a multi story house with a single AP. Would you attempt to cover the house with one music radio? No, it would be way to loud near the stereo and way too quite far away. Also you spill signal into neighbour's location and blast excess noise into the spectrum. 3 APs on a lower setting would give you much better performance.
- Waterluvian 6y agoI appreciate yours and ehutch's feedback. 1 AP is a hard requirement, sadly. I have 6 locations in my house I can plug in my cable modem and for now there shall be no hole drilling and Ethernet cable running. My current setup works, but I'm surprised I cannot just centrally locate 1 Wifi AP. We did that when I was younger in a far larger house. But I guess back then wifi was far slower and more robust?
- boatsie 6y agoThe problem is 5ghz has much better bandwidth but less range than 2.4ghz. Also there is more interference these days with everyone having routers.
- mizzack 6y agoYou can still run a mesh without a wired backhaul. It's just not as fast/reliable. Also, 5.8GHz does not penetrate walls as well as the older 2.4GHz standards.
- pixl97 6y agoYou can't really compare things to the past for a lot of reasons. 1. In the past you were probably the only person with wifi in a mile. Now you have countless units attempting to talk in any given place on a very limited spectrum. 2. 5ghz is fast but walls and objects kill your speed quick. 3. Turning down your current 2.4ghz to wireless B speeds will increase your reliability in environments with few neighbours. Imagine a 10mbit network hub. Worked ok back in the day. Now try to increase its speed to 1gbit and add lots of uses. You wont get much done, everything gets corrupted and you retransmit a lot.
- EveYoung 6y agoLast year, I installed an Orbi Wifi 6 system in my parent's three-storey house. And I'm using the older RBK50 version myself with an ethernet backhaul. For consumer products, both are pretty good and offer fast and stable wifi. I'm not running a complex home network so consumer-grade hardware is good enough for me. That said, I've no idea if Netgear is better than Ubiquiti at a company level. I've noticed that many people here are usually fairly critical of Netgear.
- Waterluvian 6y agoFascinating. I always thought "Wifi mesh systems" are self-defeating, given they use wifi to mesh wifi. You found this worked well?
- EveYoung 6y agoMy knowledge about networking is fairly limited, but from a consumer perspective it works really well with seamless roaming, especially compared to old wifi repeaters. The Orbi system uses a dedicated backhaul to connect the nodes. Since by parents' old house doesn't really allow installing network cables, this seemed like a good solution. In my home, I'm using a wired backhaul, which is the prefered option if possible. My only critisism is that the Orbi Wifi 6 system is quite expensive and there probably exist cheaper options to achieve the same.
- croutonwagon 6y agoThere are some, including the orbi that have antennas set aside for Dedicated back haul. It will dramatically help performance compared to mesh that have to pause tx to talk on the back haul.
- gwittel 6y agoI'm in a multi-level home. Previously I had 1 centrally located Ruckus AP. Its signal was strong everywhere (solid RX signal strength), but devices could not transmit strongly enough back to the AP. In the end I went with 3 Unifi APs + a controller. You can use wired or wireless for backhaul. The main thing is that the APs have to be able to communicate with each other. There isn't a great way to test out the wireless backhaul without buying the equipment. I suppose you could use a scanner to test the RX signal strength with your AP in varying places. If the 2.4/5ghz signal is strong in the (AP, scanner location) pairs then you know the APs might be able to talk to each other. If you're looking for a less work setup, the Amplifi line, or Eeros might work.
- kiwijamo 6y agoAmplifi is a Ubiquiti product.