4 ms·
> The only company that is not affected is possibly Apple. This is an interesting point. Apple is pretty hard nosed on their predictions and capacity reservat
by gumby 6y ago
> The only company that is not affected is possibly Apple.
This is an interesting point. Apple is pretty hard nosed on their predictions and capacity reservations, to the point where they could be funding part of this expansion at TSMC (as they have done for Hon Hai, among others, for decades).
I continue to be astonished by Apple’s ability to manage their supply chain so tightly (which requires not just an iron fist but very very intense internal process). They seem to be the only ones who can manage to do that.
And it’s not like other big companies are lazy; the part that really amazes me is that their process hasn’t leached out to other companies, as so much else does in the Valley.
- somethingwitty1 6y agoI just saw something about this. The reason Apple hasn't been impacted is because their sales have been dropping for the past few years on iPhones and other devices. That trend hasn't changed during the pandemic. While many of the other players predicted drops during the pandemic, and initially it did, that demand dramatically increased, especially in the desktop market (AMD, Nvidia, etc). It is hard to fault companies from predicting the massive increase in a market that has been decreasing for decades(?) now. There is limited capacity at TSMC and Samsung. They leave buffer, but that was quickly consumed because almost everyone needed more capacity. It takes potentially years to increase capacity (build a new fab, etc), they have no room to allow any companies to adjust their capacity reservations. So at the end of the day, it isn't that Apple was necessarily better...their demand just didn't change and continued the downward trend in certain product areas, giving them breathing room.
- gumby 6y agoIt does look like apple's unit sales (of phones at least which are the lion's share of product) have been declining (conveniently they stopped reporting unit sales long ago) but I don't think that really applies here. Apple's share of the total semiconductor market is far from dominant. What's really interesting is how well they couple demand to shipment. One is that they appear to have low levels of unsold inventory, both on the incoming (BOM) side and output (unsold manufactured output, such as phones), reflecting some incredible discipline. They also manage to insure themselves against supply shock (because such a tight tolerance for over purchase and overproduction makes your supply chain more brittle) by making big moves in their supply chain like financing their suppliers, doing manufacturing R&D on their suppliers' technology and then supplying that tech to the suppliers, taking big positions in commodity markets (e.g. famously in DRAM a few years ago) and other such things you can do when you have so much cash on the balance sheet.
- pas 6y agoIf they have so much cash and margin, why don't they keep more inventory instead of all these supply chain black magic?
- gumby 6y agoBetter use of capital and better supplier flexibility (why consume your suppliers’ capacity on stuff you don’t need when you could switch them to the next gen thing you need?). You could think of it as avoiding bufferbloat in the physical domain.
- brianwawok 6y agoAlso refreshes are real annoying/unprofitable when you have millions of old tech sitting in warehouses. Apple has pretty good science on the sneak peak / release / fulfill of new tech. You can basically get day1 or at least week1 release of any new product.
- barkingcat 6y agoOne thing to remember is that the current CEO Tim Cook started in the supply chain management side of the company... And did that job for Steve Jobs during the growth of the iphone. It would be expected that Apple would have extended insight into supply chain and capacity, seeing as the head of the company was/is the one who did that job.
- commandar 6y agoI'm constantly surprised by how many people seem to forget that Tim Cook got to where he is on the basis of being a supply chain logistics whiz. If there's anything I expect Apple to excel at, almost without question, under his leadership, it's supply chain management.
- tommilukkarinen 6y agoThe comment reminds me of Nokia end times. Everyone said they mastered logistics.
- commandar 6y agoI wasn't commenting on Apple as a whole; I'm actually not a huge fan of the company overall under Cook's leadership. But supply chain management? They excel at that which doesn't surprise me given who the CEO is.
- gumby 6y agoIt's also a strength on the demand prediction side which is typically done by marketing not the manufacturing side of the business. Yes, I know Cook came from Compaq for his supply chain chops, but there are amazing supply chain folks elsewhere in the industry. On this dimension Apple is in a class by itself. Perhaps that fixation does come from Cook, as supply chain wizards typically don't rise that high in the corporate chain.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mooman219 6y agoApple is experiencing supply chain issues, and there is a shortage of laptop devices right now if you try to make bulk orders (>1000 units). I have no context on their phones.
- fomine3 6y agoThey tend to be out of stock when next product is becoming. I wish they think it's also a problem.