3 ms·
I think the heart of this isn't devs changing jobs. It's execs. I know plenty of devs who will be "irrational" about quality in that they build for sustainabilt
by wpietri 6y ago
I think the heart of this isn't devs changing jobs. It's execs. I know plenty of devs who will be "irrational" about quality in that they build for sustainabilty and longevity far beyond their personal economic incentives.
But when those same devs go up the chain to improve practices or clean up tech debt, they rarely end up happy. I think that's because executive turnover is also fast and the rewards for underinvestment are much larger. Executive compensation is often tied to stock price and other short-term metrics, and executive tenure is also quite short. That gives them a strong incentive to cut anything that pays off over the long term.
Which I think ties back to his professionals vs amateurs thing. One thing that distinguishes professionals is standards. Doctors won't prescribe you anything you want. Real engineers will refuse to build things that will collapse. But a lot of devs are more minions than professionals; if the boss says to build X, they'll build X. Whether that's good for the company, the customers, or society isn't relevant.
- kristianc 6y agoI've rarely seen progress get made when it's framed as "I want to clean up tech debt." To execs it seems like moving deckchairs rather than moving the number (which to be fair, it sometimes is). "In order to release feature x which customer y cares about, we need to clear up tech debt / refactor z" is a much better way of getting execs on board.
- aYsY4dDQ2NrcNzA 6y agoExcellent point, it needs to offer a concrete benefit. Simply saying “it will make it easier to write new features going forward” won’t convince anyone.
- wpietri 6y agoFor sure. That's definitely where many organizations are. "To cook breakfast this morning, I propose we clean up last night's dinner mess. Here is my 27-slide deck." But I think it's also worth orgs getting to the point of defaulting to just cleaning up after dinner, and also cleaning as they cook. Having to have a specific, urgent reason to clean up a mess is a fine argument for 13-year-olds to make as they come to understand how a household works. But it's tiresome when nominal adults refuse to accept that the future eventually arrives.
- watwut 6y agoBeing irrational about quality does not lead to easier to maintain software. You need to be rational about it and the distinction matters a lot. You can go all petty on minor idioms and force everyone to use all the sonar rules and all it will create is a lot of busywork with zero improvement on maintainability. And I have seen this dynamic to happen more then once.
- wpietri 6y agoThat's not the kind of irrational I'm talking about, which is why I put the word in quotes and then explained exactly what I meant in the same sentence.