2 ms·
While there is no Federal ID every state in the Union (to my knowledge) provides ID cards to citizens. These vary slightly from place to place but all contain
by mulmen 6y ago
While there is no Federal ID every state in the Union (to my knowledge) provides ID cards to citizens. These vary slightly from place to place but all contain verifiable identity (authentication).
This may seem strange to outsiders but makes more sense when you consider the United States is a federation of sovereign states. The system is built on the idea of limited federal power with states sharing but retaining much of their own sovereignty. This has many of the benefits of any federated system and makes for a robust democracy.
There’s very little of consequence you can do in the United States with single factor knowledge. If identity theft is more common here than elsewhere (citation needed) I would guess it has more to do with a lack of consequences (consumer protection) than a Federal ID.
- Daho0n 6y agoIt's the same as the EU but with way more federal power and way less local democracy.
- ACS_Solver 6y agoI'm familiar with the US federal system, but as far as I know, the individual state IDs still have the same problem. In particular, they're apparently difficult to obtain for poor or disadvantaged people, so there are enough people without an ID to let the insecure ad-hoc systems exist in parallel. So something like knowing the SSN, or displaying an utility bill (trivially faked) exists as a parallel ID form. European government-issued IDs don't work well just because they are accepted, they work well because no other ID is accepted, and that's only possible when 99% or more of the population has such an ID (and the rest can be handled in a somewhat more convoluted but uncommon procedure). Of course I have no good insight into how feasible it is for a US state / federal government to ensure that everyone (for sufficiently large values of everyone) in the state / country has an ID, without disadvantaging anyone.