5 ms·
One more reason to decline to provide SSN or non-disposable mailing address, email address, and phone numbers to institutions or vendors. Hopefully people stop
by sneak 6y ago
One more reason to decline to provide SSN or non-disposable mailing address, email address, and phone numbers to institutions or vendors.
Hopefully people stop finding it weird when customers don't want their PII in the vendor's database.
- walrus01 6y agoWhile I don't disagree with you on how bad things are now, good luck with the idea of not giving your SSN to your employer or university. At a certain point people will ask if your intention is to move to a wood shack in Montana and write a manifesto.
- nightowl_games 6y agoCome a few hundred clicks north to Saskatchewan where wood shacks and manifestos are something of a local past-time.
- NetOpWibby 6y agoIf they have high-speed fiber, it’s a date!
- renewiltord 6y agoSorry to disappoint.
- Sander_Marechal 6y agoThat's why StarLink is a thing!
- nightowl_games 6y agoI have high speed fiber to the home. SaskTel Infinet is great. It's a socialist organization too! Check it out! Saskatchewan has a lot of socialism in its history, mostly because of the intense agriculture history where farmers would pool all their grain together to negotiate better prices.
- swiley 6y agoIt's honestly pretty tempting but the border is closed.
- mulmen 6y agoGiving my SSN to my employer seems reasonable because that’s how I pay in to social security. SSNs are fine as IDs (with time bound assumptions), the problem is using them for authentication.
- d4mi3n 6y agoThey are in fact not great IDs and the Social Security Administration asked very nicely for the rest of the country to not use them as a form of identification: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus A few reasons why SSNs are bad as IDs: 1. There are a number of situations where people will not have a SSN. 2. SSNs are "secrets" that need to be broadly shared to participate in many parts of business and government in the US. 3. SSNs lack many security and authentication mechanisms most forms of ID have (e.g. photo ID) There are folks in the US who rally against the idea of a national ID, but I've always thought it was a silly argument considering how pervasive and problematic SSNs are as a form of identification.
- hedora 6y ago4. SSN’s are not unique, nor were they designed to be, but people think they are.
- mulmen 6y agoIf a living person has a SSN they can be identified by it [1]. That does not imply any individual can be identified by a SSN or that any SSN identifies an individual. The suitability of an SSN is situational for ID purposes. The video conflates identification and authentication to its detriment. Social Security Numbers are very good identifiers, that’s literally their purpose. Social Security Cards are poor authentication tokens because they contain no validation to prove the card holder is the person associated with the number. Or said another way, you cannot prove your identity (authenticate) with a social security card. I don’t see what built in validation of the number has to do with the security of the identifier. So again, the problem is using a Social Security Number or card for authentication. It’s fine as an identifier. [1]: Social Security Numbers can be reissued but this should only happen when the number is no longer in use.
- sneak 6y agoSet up a corporation, employ yourself, and send invoices from the corporation to the people who wish you to perform services for them. I've been doing this for over a dozen years. My customers don't need to have a single piece of my PII. To be honest, the thought of sending even a single piece of my PII to a customer or vendor gives me the heebie-jeebies, given what we know about data breaches. I don't even let my personal services people handle my data in Google Apps until and unless I've shipped them a chromebook and walked them through setting up hardware 2FA and enabling Advanced Protection. I'm waiting for a national bank chain or AmEx to get popped; thanks to the legally mandated total lack of financial privacy in the United States there's no way to insulate oneself from those vendors.
- nfin 6y agoyes. Hopefully that day comes where people understanding that keeping your PII private is for good reasons, and not for hiding anything bad... It is a pitty, that many (most) governments make the life hard (through laws/regulations/...) for companies wanting to offer services like aliases for phone numbers. Wouldn't it be great if I could give an alias phone number, and if I want I can redirect that number into the void [1] [1] or instead of redirect into the void possibly other good or less good ideas like "pay $1 to call me"... which would help some cases where I would have liked to delete an alias, but not sure if I didn't give it to someone that I want to keep in contact with
- Daho0n 6y agoThis is putting a bandaid on a rotten leg. What is needed is a way to stop businesses from calling you if you haven't given them permission. It is a huge problem in the US but it isn't like this everywhere. The underlying problems should be fixed instead: Laws that actually prevent this (enforced laws) and the opportunity to block non-local calls from places not as functional (like calls from the US). I have had the same mobile phone number for decades and I get maybe one call a year from a business that I haven't specifically allowed or requested calling me and it is always international because local laws actually work.
- nfin 6y agoYes, it is a band aid, or one solution out of many needed ones, and yes, probably not highest priority in terms of needs. But it doesn't have to be a either...or... And I wouldn't derive from your lack of need from a lack of need for others!! Independently from the country. Stealing is allowed in no country, and it still happens in every country. Laws and enforcement is great, but it won't stop 100% cases, and if I like to have a door lock on my door (or two), then let me do... I don't care if some don't feel a need for it (and stealing is just an example... the same for so many illegal things).
- closeparen 6y agoThe only one of those things that has any claim to being a secret is SSN. And that ship has sailed - at this point it would be a public service to publish all SSNs so we’re all forced to stop treating it like knowing an SSN means something. The rest belong in public directories, where they have been for decades.
- cm2187 6y agoIf you are a prospective student, are you going to risk your future by using your college application to make a point about privacy?
- sneak 6y agoThere's a strong argument to be made that one risks their future in general by taking on the substantial debt usually involved in attending a US university. There are worse things one can do with regards to their future than keeping their private data private.