3 ms·
While I will accept these results if valid. I sincerely hope that other labs are able to reproduce these results and the concept isn't dismissed out of hand. W
by kjrose 6y ago
While I will accept these results if valid. I sincerely hope that other labs are able to reproduce these results and the concept isn't dismissed out of hand.
While it's good to have multiple labs trying to reproduce results, that needs to apply in both directions to ensure that no unintended bias caused issues.
- BelenusMordred 6y agoFeel free to cheer it on, but extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. All the evidence here has never been verifiable and comes across as experimental sleights of hand. Always reminded me of Eugene Podkletnov and his gravity shielding, an interesting research avenue with physical experiments sure, but no one can ever replicate what he has said is happening. I sometimes enjoy to tin-foil that things like the emdrive and all those whacky navy patents are actually superpowers intentionally wasting the time of rivals. One space faring nation recently spent a lot research effort getting an emdrive into space to test it.
- kjrose 6y agoI'm not cheering anything on. I'm saying that there are many reputable groups that tried and got results. Including NASA themselves. It's important to disprove this solidly by having more than one group test and have a negative result. I think it's total bs. That doesn't mean the proof it is bs doesn't deserve to be repeated.