8 ms·
Translation technology may let humans speak with dolphins
- dolvlo 15y agoSomehow, this made me think of the Baby Translator from the Simpsons
- StavrosK 15y agoReally? Not SeaQuest DSV?
- pumpmylemma 15y agoI'll get down-voted -- correctly -- for saying something that adds nothing to the conversation, but YES! I think spending my childhood watching Lucas Walencheck was part of my inspiration to learn programming.
- StavrosK 15y agoLonnie Henderson was my first crush! So pretty.
- JoeAltmaier 15y ago"What do you want, Maggie?" Translator: "I want what the dogs eating!"
- hugh3 15y agoI prefer the dog translator from the Far Side cartoon. It turns out every barking dog is saying "Hey! Hey! Hey! Hey!"
- AshleysBrain 15y agoDo dolphins have anything interesting to say?
- parfe 15y agoObviously, "So long and thanks for all the fish." But more importantly communication is the first step towards mutual respect if dolphins are sentient.
- ghotli 15y agoA part of me feels like conscious, sentient beings should have equal protection under the law. Just because they don't encode knowledge in written language or make tools like we do doesn't mean that they may be any less sentient.
- dochtman 15y agoDefine conscious, sentient.
- michael_dorfman 15y agoYou can start here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentience http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentience
- pavel_lishin 15y agoSo, which part of you doesn't feel that conscious and sentient beings ought to have equal protection?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- defen 15y agoThe part that fears a warlike alien civilization.
- hvs 15y ago"May" in this case meaning "we haven't actually done any testing yet." Can't anyone wait until they have tested their theory before having an article written about it? This title could just as easily have been "Humans are going to record and play different sounds to dolphins with the hope that something happens."
- Goladus 15y agoMy guess is that this article will help the project compete for funding. The name of the project (CHAT) and its principle investigators are very prominent in the article, as well as promising descriptions of the technology already developed.
- lars 15y agoFrom a machine learning perspective this doesn't seem like such a daunting task. We have pretty good speech recognition for human language (plus acceptable speech synthesis). Assuming dolphins have a smaller vocabulary than humans, speech recognition of dolphins should strictly speaking be a simpler problem (although it would be significantly harder to record the training data).
- sebastianavina 15y agothe difference is to map the vocabulary to the meaning... even writig down the vocabulary is a challenge... iiiiaiiiiaiiiiiiiiiaiiiIjii... in dolphin that means "WTF" or "Of course"?
- pasbesoin 15y agoI think part of the problem may be context. Without swimming around with them, and having similar senses (something that these days some wearable sensors might mitigate), it may be difficult to grasp what they are talking about.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoSure, but we start off already being fluent in the human language we're trying to write software for.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoOf if dolphins have a sense of humor all bets are off. Dophin 1, "Hey I bet we can get that thing to say 'bite me' when it greets someone!" Dolphin 2, "You think? Ok, every time we meet in front of them you say 'bite me' and i'll say 'wheree?'"
- stan_rogers 15y agoOh, I'm sure there would be a few unfortunate "drop your panties, Sir William; I cannot wait until lunchtime" incidents, but with an automated Hungarian Phrasebook[1], we'll eventually learn to get by. More to the point, though, we have no reason to assume that dolphins, any more than, say, apes, have the ability to "chat" -- to communicate about things displaced from the here and now. It's worth a go, of course, but our expectations shouldn't be too high going in. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6D1YI-41ao http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6D1YI-41ao
- pasbesoin 15y agoDid anyone see the recently circulating video of the cat on the dock interacting with dolphins. Including repeated and extended nuzzling and no signs of aggression. I immediate thought that, in part, the dolphins might be attracted by, intrigued by the cat's probably purring, sensing it through their jaws. But there seems to be a patience and curiosity there that speaks to significantly more than mere "animal instinct". We already communicate with dolphins, and experiments have shown that they can understand the syntax and semantics of request/command structures (the same communication elements in different orders ('sentence structures', so to speak) have different meanings). What will they say when we finally understand them? "Took you long enough."
- loboman 15y agoThanks for all the fish
- bh42222 15y agoWhat will they say when we finally understand them? "Took you long enough." I don't believe that communication between dolphins and trainers has been strictly one way. I'm pretty sure a trainer can easily read a lot from a dolphin's actions, sounds, etc. And keep in mind, the other great apes are wicked smart, like smarter then small human children smart, way smarter then the smartest dog, but still not smart enough to say something like "Took you long enough to teach us sign language."
- sdewerwe 15y agoDear customers, thank you for your support of our company. Here, there’s good news to tell you: The company recently launched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionable and welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary, please plut: www.soozone.com dfgerwe
- yannski 15y agoSo finally David Brin could be premonitory, cf http://www.davidbrin.com/upliftbooks.htm http://www.davidbrin.com/upliftbooks.htm
- adavies42 15y agothat's one down. next up: world hunger, then the warrior robot race.
- siiily 15y agoThat's good news for dolphins, they must be willing to read news.ycombinator.com, first thing they can do is create their own version of fb.
- VladRussian 15y agomay be they went into the ocean to avoid the future of creating fb
- siiily 15y agoAs dolphins hearing or seeing system is 3D their mind is very different from ours. Before trying to communicate we should be able to imagine what kind of society we could construct with this 3D sensor system.
- Alex3917 15y agoHow can you write an article about talking with dolphins without linking to at least one John C. Lilly interview? http://www.futurehi.net/docs/Here_To_Alternity.html http://www.futurehi.net/docs/Here_To_Alternity.html http://www.erowid.org/culture/characters/lilly_john/lilly_john_interview1.shtml http://www.erowid.org/culture/characters/lilly_john/lilly_jo...
- VladRussian 15y agoevery small step toward recognizing intelligence of others is a great leap for humanity. I think before human species is able to move any further in its development, the first step it must to make is to step out of the "i'm the top of the God's creation" closet. http://www.npr.org/2011/01/20/132650631/new-language-discovered-prairiedogese http://www.npr.org/2011/01/20/132650631/new-language-discove... : --------------- So he devised a test. He had four (human) volunteers walk through a prairie dog village, and he dressed all the humans exactly the same — except for their shirts. Each volunteer walked through the community four times: once in a blue shirt, once in a yellow, once in green and once in gray. He found, to his delight, that the calls broke down into groups based on the color of the volunteer's shirt. "I was astounded," says Slobodchikoff. But what astounded him even more, was that further analysis revealed that the calls also clustered based on other characteristics, like the height of the human. "Essentially they were saying, 'Here comes the tall human in the blue,' versus, 'Here comes the short human in the yellow,' " says Slobodchikoff. Amazingly, it doesn't stop there. Slobodchikoff's next move was to see if prairie dogs could differentiate between abstract shapes. So he and his students built two wooden towers on each side of a prairie dog village. They then made cardboard cutouts of circles, squares and triangles and ran them out along a wire strung between the two towers, so the shapes sort of floated through the village about three feet from the ground. And the prairie dogs, Slobodchikoff found, were able to tell the difference between the triangle and the circle, but, alas, they made no mention of the difference between the square and the circle. --------------------- I wonder how aliens analyze our intelligence: - sent round blue flying saucer - a lot of buzz - sent stick-looking device http://abcnews.go.com/International/ufo-china-closes-airport-prompts-investigation/story?id=11159531 http://abcnews.go.com/International/ufo-china-closes-airport... - a lot of the same buzz. Conclusion: probably the humans can't distinguish the abstract shapes.
- grantismo 15y agoI would expect aliens capable of interstellar travel would have better metrics than "buzz" :]
- VladRussian 15y agoof course, they would be looking for fine structured mental field waveforms that they would expect us, like any sentient species, to naturally produce ... and i guess they are still waiting for us to generate the waveforms
- Lost_BiomedE 15y agoOne documentary on netflix had a couple training dolphins. They used signs to tell the dolphin to do different tricks. At the end of their training the dolphin had to invent a new trick. They then had two dolphins do the tricks together. At the end of the training, they asked the dolphins to do a new trick, and the dolphins would coordinate a brand new trick together on the fly and perform it simultaneously!