3 ms·
“Local founders/investors are annoyed by the gate-keeping role that YC is unintentionally playing. This role is being reinforced by market-ignorant – often fore
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
“Local founders/investors are annoyed by the gate-keeping role that YC is unintentionally playing. This role is being reinforced by market-ignorant – often foreign – investors,” was another.
Definition of Gatekeeping: the activity of controlling, and usually limiting, general access to something.
The internet tells me there isn't really an antonym for this word, which makes me feel better about failing to think up any myself. But I would imagine YC is serving to open a way for foreign money to flow in, not serving to control, limit and decide whom to let in or keep out.
If that is accurate, they really should do some research and write about that to educate people that "We absolutely aren't gatekeeping anything here. If people are using our activities as a proxy metric for what to throw money at themselves without doing a lot of research on their own, that's not us gatekeeping anything whatsoever."
I'm short of sleep and not heavily invested in creating some free PR resources for a multi-billion dollar company, but I imagine it would take a bit of research to come up with a good concept or metaphor to do this justice. However, it would likely be well worth the time spent on it in terms of making people in foreign countries feel more at ease with their activities.
I'm sure there are legitimate concerns on the ground in Africa about (things like) the potential impact of foreign money and foreign expertise flowing in without a lot of context and local knowledge to inform those choices. But this idea that YC is gatekeeping something is probably flat out wrong in a way that essentially drags their name through the mud baselessly.
- xwdv 6y agoFloodgating.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoOpening the floodgates is surprisingly good imagery for capturing the concern about an influx of large sums money and the potential downside for that. That would be a good place to start for tying to put together an image-rich metaphor and try to meaningfully address such things.
- pessimizer 6y ago> there isn't really an antonym for this word, It's too complicated to have a simple antonym that makes sense. From the perspective of the person trying to get in: "gatecrashing." Instead of trying to limit access, encouraging access: being a "barker." Instead of being selective, being complete: doing a "rollup."
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAnother one that has occurred to me: other companies that follow them in are riding their coattails in. The phrase breaking new ground may also be useful.
- barry-cotter 6y agoYC is barking all the dammed time.
- rcxdude 6y agoIf your decisions are affecting access to something, it's reasonable to call it gatekeeping, whether it's through your positive actions restricting access (and passivity allowing access) or your actions allowing access (and passivity restricting access). In this case though it's through effects which are not directly in YC's control, so it would be unreasonable to blame them for this. It can be gatekeeping without it being intentional or even something you can reasonably fix yourself.