4 ms·
Sure, considering I was a frantic proponent of universal healthcare before I observed the US Gov's handling of the COVID crisis and the responses of Americans t
by renewiltord 6y ago
Sure, considering I was a frantic proponent of universal healthcare before I observed the US Gov's handling of the COVID crisis and the responses of Americans to it, I changed my mind. Here are some of my reasons:
* I want to be able to be an informed participant in my healthcare. When the US Gov lied about mask efficacy so that there would be enough masks for healthcare professionals and when many Americans considered this acceptable, I lost faith in the government's ability to meet this need of mine. Either they were incompetent or malicious and neither trait is one I desire in someone treating me.
* My life involves a wide variety of risk taking: I use drugs, motorcycle, bicycle, jump off bridges, etc. During the COVID crisis, many Americans stated a desire to allocate healthcare according to behaviour. I would prefer to pay to offset my risk rather than alter my behaviour. I fear the puritan streak in American politics will push me to the back of the line in healthcare despite my ability to offset any risk with money.
* I am a software engineer. I am high income, relatively wealthy, and overall fairly comfortable. I am also in a profession that does not provide me a social cachet. During the COVID crisis, many Americans stated a desire to allocate healthcare according to a notion of value to society that elevates those with high social cachet. These are generally people who can be argued for: teachers ("they are taking care of our next generation"), medical professionals ("you don't think we should treat our healthcare heroes first?"), soldiers, firefighters, police, god knows what. I fear that people's dislike of my profession will push me to the back of the line.
So now, no universal healthcare, thank you. And yes, I am quite familiar with the NHS. I've paid enough into it and have many family members who work for it. The existence of other successful systems does not mean that the US can replicate them. There is a path problem, a second system effect, and differing social norms.
Well, there you have it, an actual statement of reasons from someone who actually opposes UHC.
- nohuck13 6y agoI don't agree with you but you deserve corrective upvotes; this is a perfectly cogent and constructive dissenting view.
- renewiltord 6y agoThank you. As it so happens, I am aware that when a HNer requests an answer like this they are fully aware of two things: * They can stay righteous knowing that the mob that they are the vanguard of will apply suppressive pressure on their behalf * They can disclaim responsibility of knowledge of the mob * The fellow members of the mob will post answers "on behalf of" the side they oppose which will strawman those positions Interestingly, many HNers will disingenuously ask "for feedback" or "an honest discussion" knowing full well about this phenomenon. Therefore, I'm not upset by their reaction because I was braced for it. My position is logically sound. Objections come from different moral foundations and different circumstances, not from logical failure. And I can accept that you can also have an opposing logically sound conclusion rising from different axioms since our axioms are beyond our Aumann Agreement Horizon.
- dudleypippin 6y ago> During the COVID crisis, many Americans stated a desire to allocate healthcare according to a notion of value to society that elevates those with high social cachet. All of the professions you mentioned (except, perhaps, “god knows what”) involve interacting with other people as part of their primary function. I’m sure you can see the wisdom of allocating the initial tranche of vaccines to “people who do valuable work and are at higher risk of causing community spread while doing so” over “people who do valuable work but can do that valuable work while isolated, thus reducing the risk of community spread”?
- renewiltord 6y agoThe outcome doesn't bother me. The reasoning for high social value professions vs. low social value does, since it works for non-contagious situations as well. The teachers continue to be the ones "taking care of our beloved children, the next generation"; The nurses continue to be "healthcare heroes"; the firefighters continue to be "brave and courageous"; all this continues to be true when I'm getting in line to have pancreatic cancer treated. I don't want to die because some pretty primary school teacher showed up at the last moment for that kidney transplant and society has decided that it wants her more than it wants me. And obviously I have no objection to vaccinating high-degree nodes before low-degree nodes subject to the usual arguments.
- makomk 6y agoIt really is about status, though. For example, here in the UK there was a huge amount of pressure to vaccinate policemen early but no such pressure for private security guards, even though security guards were at much higher risk of dying from Covid but the police weren't. Same with, say, teachers and bus drivers. The recurring pattern was that it was the professions with high status that got to push for priority, not the ones with high risk. Our government managed to push back against this in large part because the vaccination roll-out was going well and they managed to argue that prioritizing on things other than age would slow it down, but if it had been slower or some of the unions stronger they might have ended up having to give in.
- andrewchambers 6y agoHere in New Zealand celebrities and sports people get to the front of the line when it comes government quarantine facility placement. Not sure if this is money, or just a popularity contest, but it frustrates me more if it is popularity rather than just paying a lot.
- msrenee 6y agoWe had the same thing here where basketball teams and politicians were getting covid tests every week while the rest of us couldn't get one when we had symptoms. I don't think that's a private vs. public healthcare issue necessarily.
- xzel 6y agoI don’t know a health care system where you can’t buy secondary insurance on top of national health care.
- ars 6y agoCanada is like that, it's illegal to get private insurance.
- refurb 6y agoNot quite. There are private hospitals in Canada but very few. The reason is because physicians are banned from treating patients in the public system and private system. If they choose to treat private patients, they can't work in the public system. With such a small private system, that's not sustainable. In addition, private hospitals/clinics can't offer certain procedures. MRIs are allowed in some provinces, but the list isn't very long. Basically Canada is not interested in having any private healthcare system because then it would be "2 tier". They prefer everyone go to the same system.
- arethuza 6y agoAny idea why Canada decided to be so extreme - even the UK (which has the overtly socialist NHS) happily has a smaller parallel private healthcare system and a lot of doctors work in both.
- refurb 6y ago"But it was only with the 1984 passage of the Canada Health Act, drafted in the final months of Pierre Trudeau’s premiership, that Canada codified its de facto ban on private healthcare. The reason was a wave of “extra billing” that had swept Canadian healthcare in the 1970s. Canadian patients were increasingly being hit with user fees and copays that were gradually chipping away at the supposed universality of Canadian healthcare." Basically, private doctors wanted to be able to also bill the public system and any additional cost the patient is required to pay. That went against the idea that "healthcare should not be purchased". [1]https://www.capitaldaily.ca/news/private-two-tier-healthcare-brian-day-bc https://www.capitaldaily.ca/news/private-two-tier-healthcare...