4 ms·
Yeesh. I really don't like the way he privileges "art poetry" over other kinds of poetry. Rupi Kaur has every bit as much a claim to being a poet as Wallace St
by jfengel 6y ago
Yeesh.
I really don't like the way he privileges "art poetry" over other kinds of poetry. Rupi Kaur has every bit as much a claim to being a poet as Wallace Stevens does. (And Stevens in particular, of all the poets...)
And that drives me nuts, because a lot more people might like "art poetry" if he'd stop making people feel bad about not liking it.
While I'm not a voracious reader of poetry, I've got even less time for "John Ashbery, by general consensus the greatest American poet of the late-twentieth century", of whom I've never heard. And that sample is not making me rush out to read it.
It's a model of the "Purple prose with line breaks" form of modern poetry. It's not just that it doesn't have rhyme or meter, but that the line breaks don't add any structure at all except to make it look like poetry on the page. And of all the subjects to write about, "It's hard to write poetry" is the reason nobody wants to read your poems.
Here's how you get poetry: you read the poems you like. You listen to the poets you like to listen to, whether that's slam poets or rappers or singers or commercial jingles. When those start to seem repetitive or simplistic, you go read something else, something that is interesting to compare and contrast with the stuff you already like.
Exactly the same goes for painting, and wine, and everything else that rich people used to like and therefore must be important. Now we can all have it, and if you want to share your interests in it, stop yucking their yum.
- jfengel 6y agoOh, and as a Shakespeare actor and director, there are a lot more things to say about Hamlet than seem to be dreamt of in his philosophy. He appears to be demanding the "To BEEEE... or NOT... to beeeee" school of acting. That's not how actors work or how actors connect with audiences.
- mbg721 6y agoI had a high-school teacher who pointed out that the modern RP English accent isn't what Shakespeare would have spoken, and had us read aloud in a light (albeit butchered) Southern drawl instead. It had the desired startling effect on how I perceived the writing.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y ago> Exactly the same goes for painting the casual videos of John Berger's "Ways of Seeing" / "Art of Looking" have taught me (an ignorant pleb) more about how to "get" art than any opinions from art critics. There is so much pretentiousness and gate-keeping in this field it's insane. Just enjoy and see what it brings to the surface is all there is to it IMO. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0pDE4VX_9Kk&list=PLn6KyJ4PmZsPhigNqPlWGEoCgBHJbhib3 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0pDE4VX_9Kk&list=PLn6KyJ4PmZ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dagw 6y agoYou do realize that John Berger is an art critic, right?
- fovc 6y agoCompletely agree. I've been looking to get into poetry, so wanted a daily poem via RSS. The stuff that's available is all purple prose which I couldn't stand. Shameless plug: I wrote my own feed, currently delivering Robert Frost daily: https://github.com/felipeochoa/rsspoetry/ https://github.com/felipeochoa/rsspoetry/ (also a good ocaml learning experience with some notes about it for the curious)
- criddell 6y ago> Now we can all have it, and if you want to share your interests in it, stop yucking their yum. I don't think the author is talking to the people enjoying what he (derisively) called Instapoems. Those people like what they like and don't feel bad about it. The author, on the other hand, laid out 3500 words in a New Criterion article to reassure those who aspire to be the type of person who enjoys "real" poetry that they are on the right path. The readers of this are there for the yucking.
- jfengel 6y agoThat's a very good point, and my lens on it comes from seeing it here on HN rather than being in the target audience. I believe, unfortunately, that it's New Criterion writers who tend to write the poetry textbooks, and I think that drives away a lot of potential poetry readers. They do often include plenty of poems that the students have a chance of genuinely enjoying -- Emily Dickinson, Robert Frost, maybe Byron or Tennyson. But even so, a lot of students come away think of that as a search for "symbols" hidden in the poetry, and are then thrust into seeking the same symbols in modern poems. I was thinking of Stevens in particular. There was a popular meme going around, parodying "Forgive me for eating your plums", about the Ever Given. What is it about that poem that made it memorable, such that it could be the touchstone of a meme? Is it because it's a great poem? Or because it's the epitome of really terrible poetry that students recall because it's so short? Both? Neither? It's a question worth engaging... one more interesting that anything I learned in high school about Stevens.
- zebraflask 6y agoJust as an aside, I had to laugh a little at your comment re: Ashbery. His poetry is notoriously "difficult" even for "serious" readers of contemporary poetry, that is, until you read enough of it that you start to understand the internal logic - then it can be very impressive. I suppose it depends on your patience for book-length hyperconvoluted and hypercontextual poems. I think his best material comes from some of the later and longer works - "Flow Chart" would be a good starting place. For Rupi Kaur, it's probably best to think of that material as the equivalent of training wheels on a bicycle. At least it gets people reading a book that claims to be related to poetry in some way, right? You have to remember, her target demographic is the middle school to early 20s crowd, and most of it was intentionally designed to be easily consumed on social media more than for any attempt at literary merit.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoThe best introduction to Ashbery is his long (but still readable in one sitting) poem Self-Portrait in a Convex Mirror, which deals with a subject most of us here can relate to: being profoundly moved, stirred up, heartwrenched by a work of art – in this case Parmigianino's painting of the same title – and unable to stop coming back to it again and again. Later Ashbery is more hermetic and often downright inane, but Self-Portrait in a Convex Mirror justly won a trifecta of American literary prizes in the year it was published.
- zebraflask 6y agoThinking about it, maybe "Shadow Train" would be more accessible - those ones are all capped at 16 lines each, which gives you a healthy dose of the typical Ashberian verbal delirium without throwing you straight into the deep end.