3 ms·
Rust isn't that hard to learn. I teach it to college sophomores who only know Java, and within 2-3 months I have them writing parsers and interpreters in Rust.
by ModernMech 6y ago
Rust isn't that hard to learn. I teach it to college sophomores who only know Java, and within 2-3 months I have them writing parsers and interpreters in Rust. In fact these students are requesting our courses to be taught in Rust, and have never heard of Zig.
I think that while the language is a little complicated, this is tempered by how nice the tooling is. I consider the borrow checker to be my TA, as it actually helps the student write code that is structured better. When they go on to write C and C++ in later courses, their code is actually more memory safe due to having their habits having been shaped by Rust.
- moldavi 6y agoI'd imagine given another language (e.g. Python), they'd learn a lot faster and be a lot more prodictive throughout the course.
- zozbot234 6y agoPython is way too ad-hoc to be a good teaching language in a professional context. It's designed to teach kids and first-time coders, as an alternative to BASIC.
- dagmx 6y agoI think that wholly depends on the context. Python is a great teaching language IMHO if the goal is to teach how to get things done. It's not a good language if you're teaching how things do work under the hood. To me it's the difference between programming and computer science.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dagmx 6y agoPossibly but Python is a completely different level of programming too. I do wonder if Rust is easier or harder than other comparable languages like C / C++ when the person has no prior knowledge of programming. I would say just the ease of having a hello world and the ease of the Rust book would make it easier to get to grips with. No dealing with complex build systems and compiler flags at the start
- zozbot234 6y agoThe Rust book as currently written assumes that the user has some programming experience. That's mainly b/c there hasn't been much of any experimentation in teaching Rust as a first time programming language. Although obviously it's been done for C++ and even C, so it ought to be quite doable, if perhaps with a bit of a "learn programming the hard way" style.
- dagmx 6y agoThat's true. It doesn't introduce base concepts for example.
- ModernMech 6y ago> I do wonder if Rust is easier or harder than other comparable languages like C / C++ when the person has no prior knowledge of programming. I can answer this because I previously taught the course in C and C++. The students supposedly have some knowledge of Java but they seem to always have forgotten all of it when they reach me. Students learning C use all of the footguns you can imagine. The biggest problem for them is writing code that segfaults, and their code always segfaults. It's not so much a problem that it does, but that there is 0 useful feedback as to why the segfault occurred and where they could potentially look to fix the problem. The bigger issue for them is memory management. They frequently walk into the use after free, double free, and memory leak walls. They also have significant trouble with N-dimensional pointer arrays. They have trouble allocating the appropriate memory for these arrays and can't seem to visualize the layout of memory. C++ is a little better because they have experience with Java, but they are frequently mystified by constructors/destructors and how to manage memory manually (they only have experience with a GC), and template programming is always an issue. But they still run into the same issue with segfaults. Rust makes all of this go away. They don't have to manage their memory manually, and they don't encounter a single segfault. Ever. We are able to just sweep all of those problems under the rug, and move on to actual content. With C/C++ we focused a lot on the language with the hope we could use it as a tool eventually, with Rust we use the language as a tool and focus on the wider world of applications for which that tool is useful.
- ModernMech 6y agoIt's a systems course, so we use a language targeted at writing systems. It used to be C/C++, now it's Rust.
- johnnycerberus 6y agoThat's nice, at UPB in Bucharest we use for the OS course C and for the distributed systems one Go/Java, though the DS one involves heavy theory/math and less coding but implementations in Go/Java are a big bonus. I don't know where do you teach, but our students would probably be confused by Rust and their time will be spent elsewhere instead of being focused on the actual course content.
- the8472 6y ago> this is tempered by how nice the tooling is. It's fairly mixed. Compiler warnings and errors are great. IDE integration is improving. CPU profiling with perf/hotspot is fine, albeit memory-hungry. Debugging and memory profiling is still bad compared to java.
- sundarurfriend 6y agoHeh, figures that the only person with actual experience systematically teaching the language, is downvoted here.