5 ms·
> When the male traveled 22 years to mate with a female, her life was cut short on average by 12%. Am I misunderstanding something? Wouldn't she be better posi
by ars 15y ago
> When the male traveled 22 years to mate with a female, her life was cut short on average by 12%.
Am I misunderstanding something? Wouldn't she be better positioned to resist the effects of the male? She has had 22 years worth of advances, and is dealing with a "primitive" male.
- jerf 15y agoEvolution does not advance. The entire concept of "advancement" is totally inapplicable and will produce wrong results. Anthropomorphizing for rhetorical convenience, evolution will happily "regress" if it increases reproduction.
- yread 15y agoSince the article is about travelling from the future, I would assume that that it's the males who have 22 years of advances.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoThe article proposes that "attacks" and "defences" may evolve cyclically, rather than "upwards" - as an (unrealistically) extreme example, it's better to be a clockwise-turning female duck when most males are counterclockwise-turning and vice versa.
- doyoulikeworms 15y agoThis makes sense. There are two scenarios that could explain this. One, the fact that a particular trait is present in a current generation only tells us that it is superior relative to just one iteration prior, and not necessarily any more. There is no rhyme or reason to evolution. In fact, it is almost an evolutionary disadvantage to incorporate traits that were once fit, but no longer are, as it likely costs more energy, diminishing efforts against current threats. A non-biological example of this would be US foreign policy. We are very well positioned to battle the Soviet Union in a Cold War turned hot. That threat is no longer with us, but we're left with strategies and equipment that are useful in that sort of situation. Today, our problems in the Middle East are not helped by the fact that we have thousands of costly nukes and tanks (not suited for urban warfare and occupation in Iraq and Afhanistan!). I'm no military buff, but I think that this illustrates the point. Another scenario could be that the relationship between clingy males vs. females is much like that of a predator vs. prey[1]. Very clingy males result, successfully, in clingy progeny, resulting in more dying females, resulting in fewer clingy progeny, resulting in more females, resulting in clinginess being more successful, and so on... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka%E2%80%93Volterra_equation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka%E2%80%93Volterra_equation
- gaius 15y agoThat's not quite true. The reason Gulf War 1, post-Cold War, was so lopsided was that the Iraqis had Soviet equipment and training, and the desert is open terrain just like the Steppe, and NATO had spent 40 years preparing to go head-head-to-head with the Red Army using maneuver warfare. There are other nations in the world that saw that and know that NATO will dominate them in any conflict even now 20 years later. Also remember that the Russians haven't gotten rid of their nukes yet...
- doyoulikeworms 15y agoI was under the impression that the US "easily" dominated Iraq's institutional armed forces, toppling their government and "winning" (Mission Accomplished). What we're doing very poorly, though, is occupying and policing the region, now that we've taken care of the previous government. In the case of war with the Soviet Union, I'm guessing that there was heavy emphasis on dealing with nuclear war or full-scale land combat in Europe, with the primary objective of beheading and toppling the Soviet control structure. By contrast, in Iraq, our goal is (apparently) to occupy and subdue the entire region, which is a different, difficult problem.
- dy 15y agoWhen it comes to sex, you have to separate out human seduction versus animal seduction because of culture. Ideas pass down human generations through culture rather than through instinct. Future generations of humans will still be able to read books like "The Art of Seduction" unlike brine sea shrimp. Now it can be easily argued that culture itself is also cyclical (fashion, promiscuity, cultural rules all rotate), but it's definitely divorced from the pure animal kingdom.