3 ms·
I'm not an IP lawyer, but I have a handful of patents. As a patent lawyer explained to me, the list of inventors on a patent should be strictly based on whether
by analog31 6y ago
I'm not an IP lawyer, but I have a handful of patents. As a patent lawyer explained to me, the list of inventors on a patent should be strictly based on whether somebody actually invented something or not. It's not like an academic paper, where everybody on the team gets to be an "author."
In my view the same thing should apply to songwriting. The current standard is, you wrote a song if you wrote the melody or the words. Sometimes those are two different people.
If you added value in other ways, add your name to some other contract specifying distribution of proceeds.
The songwriting is extremely valuable, otherwise just write your own damn songs.
As an aside, "inherent value" is a mushy concept that seems to defy any meaningful description.
- blfr 6y agoOP is primarily about money, not credit. The songwriting is extremely valuable, otherwise just write your own damn songs. If it's so valuable, how can these companies find "hit" writers for £100 a piece? While it is entirely possible for something of immense artistic or technical value to not be priced commensurately on the market, I've heard these songs, this is not the case here.
- exactlysolved 6y agoBecause the hit writers who are working for $100 a piece, are expecting that if their song gets picked up, they will share in its success through their publishing royalties.
- pumaontheprowl 6y agoIf you do that, then performers will just exert their power in other ways (by reducing royalties for song-writers). Fundamentally, this is happening because the quality of the song-writing isn't really all that important to the success of a pop star. Marketing, production quality, and sex appeal are more important. It's really not that hard to write a 4-chord song about breaking up with your boyfriend. If song-writers think they should be getting rich off these popular songs, there is nothing stopping them from performing the song themselves. They don't do that though because they know they'll make more money letting Taylor Swift sing it.