3 ms·
> So, you're either forced to defend Richard Stallman and accept what's going on over there, or __YOU ARE THE ENEMY OF ALL OPEN SOURCE__. Where did they say th
by lelanthran 6y ago
> So, you're either forced to defend Richard Stallman and accept what's going on over there, or __YOU ARE THE ENEMY OF ALL OPEN SOURCE__.
Where did they say that, or anything that implies that?
- bfgoodrich 6y agoYou must be functionally retarded if you can't find multiple poorly written sentences that distill down to what the GP stated.
- Scarblac 6y ago> "Our opponents wish to destroy Free Software" Surely if you're OK with that, that heavily implies you are an enemy of open source? I think it's quite a reasonable rephrasing.
- vitno 6y agoFree Software is not open source and the article points that out as well. I'm not convinced they want to destroy Free Software either however.
- DetroitThrow 6y ago"Our opponents wish to destroy Free Software" in massive text without highlighting any of the legitimate, less presumptive grievances with Stallman's behavior seems to be a 1:1 drop in. Or are you concerned about their usage of open source in place of free software? They quite plainly state principles which are also shared with the open source movement are what they're defending, even not accounting for their colloquial synonyminity.
- lelanthran 6y ago> "Our opponents wish to destroy Free Software" Does not in any way imply that people not defending RMS wish to destroy Free Software. > So, you're either forced to defend Richard Stallman and accept what's going on over there, or __YOU ARE THE ENEMY OF ALL OPEN SOURCE__. This quote does, and is mischaracterising the position of the linked article.
- DetroitThrow 6y ago>Does not in any way imply that people not defending RMS wish to destroy Free Software. From the statement it is understood that you are defending free software by defending Stallman, and those attacking Stallman are attacking free software. At best this is hyperbolic, abrasive language that makes bystanders at least complacent as the destruction of free software happens by some "Orwellian" conspiracy. Their statement is perhaps even less hyperbolic than the original writer - which I question why'd you examine the commentator with such scrutiny given the hysteria in the article.
- ttt0 6y agoIt's not just RMS, they call for the removal of the entire FSF board.
- shadowgovt 6y agoAn understandable call, since that is the board which (with no explanation) has re-instated Stallman. An organization's supporters interpret bad leadership as damage and route around it.
- ttt0 6y agoSupporters like OSI, a rival organization? No one cares about Stallman beside people who are already involved in open-source movements.
- shadowgovt 6y agoSupporters like the members of the FSF who are resigning and volunteers who have stepped away from the project in light of this decision. https://www.fsf.org/blogs/executive-director/management-team-members-resigning https://www.fsf.org/blogs/executive-director/management-team...
- ttt0 6y ago
- crispyambulance 6y agoThey plainly state their irrational opinion that the resignation was the result of a smear campaign by anti-open-source entities and even list them. That's just hysterical garbage. RMS did this to himself by being an abrasive asshole and failing to curb his autistic tendencies. As a major thought leader, he ought to know better.
- yesenadam 6y ago> RMS did this to himself by being an abrasive asshole This seems the actual main issue that got the anti-RMS petition going. (Even the article most in favour of him that I saw, called him by far the most disagreeable person they'd ever met!) I don't seem to remember this was mentioned in the anti-RMS petition though. Rather, it consisted of a string of claims, which, when you looked into them, were untrue. Flinging mud instead of dealing with the actual problem. That seems unfortunate. As if because they liked the end, the means didn't matter–as if behaving ethically doesn't matter. Well, maybe the people who signed didn't look into those claims, just believed them in good faith. That faith seems unwarranted.
- iocert 6y agoThis isn't true. Many signatories of the anti-Stallman letter are known, smooth careerists who have been climbing the OSS corporate ladder for the last decade. The don't care about the actual issues at all, otherwise they'd sign anti-Clinton and anti-Gates letters. Which they won't, because their careers would suffer.
- alpaca128 6y ago> RMS did this to himself by being an abrasive asshole So what? Steve Jobs was celebrated while he shat on people left and right and even denied his own daughter's claims that he's her father for years. Elon Musk publicly called someone else a pedophile and hired specialists(which turned out to be scammers) to dig up dirt against that person. Linus Torvalds is known for being rather unfriendly to a lot of people, yet I haven't seen an open letter against him after he said "Nvidia, fuck you" in front of the camera. The world is full of assholes. If I have to choose I'll take the one who actually stood for something and gets his claims confirmed more every year rather than another corporate dude whose main skill is hiding that he's the same kind of asshole, just in a more backstabby kind of way. Don't get me wrong, I don't think RMS is a good choice in any leadership position. However I don't understand the magnitude of the current outrage and don't think it's fully rational. Furthermore, I think without his uncompromising attitude towards Free Software the FSF would not be what it is now.