5 ms·
I'm going to use the car off a cliff metaphor here because I think it's appropriate. We're still in a car that's headed off the cliff. We've only just reached
by tialaramex 6y ago
I'm going to use the car off a cliff metaphor here because I think it's appropriate.
We're still in a car that's headed off the cliff. We've only just reached the point where when people want to press the accelerator harder it reliably causes widespread yelling from those convinced that hurtling off a cliff is a bad idea.
We not only aren't steering away from the cliff edge, we haven't even checked the brakes work, maybe this car doesn't have brakes, and if we only finally try them after we go off the cliff I can assure you they won't help then.
But yes, these days most calls to accelerate faster are getting shouted down, if you think that's enough I hope we both live long enough for you to find out how wrong that was.
- adrianN 6y agoYep exactly, so far we haven't even gotten the second derivative of what we're trying to stabilize to go in the right direction. Global carbon emissions are still rising!
- ben_w 6y agoSecond derivative has been negative 22 years out of the 44 I can calculate it for with this data set: https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-by-year/ https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-by... More importantly, exponential growth of the solution is much faster than the sub-exponential growth of the problem. Indeed, faster than almost everything else in the technological world — so far as I am aware, only Moore’s law and the cost of gene reading/writing have been improving faster for any length of time.
- adrianN 6y agoI only count 9 years with a negative change in emissions (6 of which are probably due to the oil crisis?). The number that matters for warming is the total CO2 concentration. Emissions are the first derivative, change in emissions is the second derivative.
- ben_w 6y agoAh, gotcha. I was doing second derivative of emissions. Still sub-exponential, which is why I’m still optimistic.
- pmiller2 6y ago> Still sub-exponential, which is why I’m still optimistic. If you said that about an algorithm you were considering introducing into production code, I'd say you had a lot of optimization to go. Or, maybe you need to improve your proof. :P
- ben_w 6y ago“Sub-exponential” is a statement of the problem space, the solution is log(n) :P
- ben_w 6y agoPhotovoltaics in particular have been growing close to exponentially since 1992 [0]. Extrapolate that to the end of 2030 and all power — industrial and domestic; heating, transport and electrical — would be solar by that point. The only reason I’m even pessimistic enough to say “at least half” by then is that the last half often has surprises that turn an exponential into a sigmoidal. Calls to go faster may well be getting shouted down, but it’s also the cheapest form of new energy — at current prices, PV beats coal and gasoline for electricity and transport respectively even after adding the cost of batteries — so people are deploying it as fast as they can anyway for selfish reasons, and output is limited more by the rate of construction of factories rather than anything else. [0] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:PV_cume_semi_log_chart_2014_estimate.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:PV_cume_semi_log_cha...
- ryandrake 6y agoProblem with this metaphor is people keep saying "The car's almost at the edge of the cliff! Three more years and then there's nothing we can do!" Then after 3 years pass, it's the same thing: "The point of no return is nearly here... definitely one year left!" Then a year goes by... At some point I wish we could just go off the cliff, then we can stop hearing all of these dire warnings constantly about how the edge of the cliff is this close.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIf you want to use the stupid cliff metaphor, we've already driven off the cliff. "No consequences" is no longer an option. Now we just have to decide where we want to land on the scale between "minor consequences" and "apocalypse".