3 ms·
> While you try to find some bad example of unions and show us how they ruined some companies I think your perspective does not match the reality of the last 5
by robomartin 6y ago
> While you try to find some bad example of unions and show us how they ruined some companies
I think your perspective does not match the reality of the last 50 years or so. We are not in the 1800's or early 1900's, when unions were super important in shaping our labor laws and actually helping workers. Nobody can deny that.
Since then?
To reuse a phrase: The huge sucking sound you've been hearing are jobs --union and otherwise-- going to China by the millions. Unions, and their aggressive anti-business stance in the US, have been a part of this exodus. I know people who forcefully retired from a number of union jobs as their unions decimated their respective industries and their jobs went to China.
Sure, of course, reality isn't a single variable problem and we can't just blame unions for the erosion of our industrial base. There are many factors that led to this, including our incompetent politicians and their never ending quest for party power rather than what's good for the nation.
Unions in the US have become distinctly different from their European counterparts. Our unions use the threat of destroying a business as a way to get what they want. European unions have somehow reached a balance where they understand protecting the business is just as important as protecting workers. It's a far more symbiotic relationship rather than a brutally adversarial one.
No love lost of Amazon here. I just think it is important to understand history so we don't repeat our painfully-learned mistakes. The US and Europe are out of time. We can't make more mistakes. We have been helping China achieve the rank of second economy in the world for fifty years. How much more self-harm is enough?
I desperately want to go back to having manufacturing in the US as an option. Today, that option does not exist but within very specific boundaries. Anything "union" is dead, whether they know it or not. Save this message and read it again in 10, 15 or 20 years.
- simion314 6y agoYou remind me of indoctrinated religious people. A guy gets a rare birth defect and one day a doctor cures him, he thanks God for saving him but not blames God for giving him the birth defect from the beginning. Same in your case you blame the union concept for all the evil (ignore all the other possible causes why China economy is rising) but never credit unions with any good thing. Let's assume that the US people are special, they can't ever have a society like the rest of the world. How do you solve the issue where workers have to work in unsafe conditions, pee in bottles and other degrading stuff? Do you pass laws to forbid peeing in bottles? The anti-government guys will not let you pass such laws... do you make each worker negotiate how many minutes a year he can spend in toilet ? Do you solve it with Twitter and cancel culture or with God?
- dang 6y agoYou broke the site guidelines badly with this comment. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here.