4 ms·
> so many writing systems where "cap height" is meaningless Can you name any writing system that doesn't have a logical equivalent? If you pull up all your exa
by crazygringo 6y ago
> so many writing systems where "cap height" is meaningless
Can you name any writing system that doesn't have a logical equivalent? If you pull up all your examples, a quick eyeballing of them reveals there is a clear upper and lower (or left and right in the case of vertical scripts) "line" that is the obvious equivalent to cap height, even if ascenders or descenders sometimes go over it.
If you don't want to call it "cap height" in favor of a more inclusive term then you're welcome to suggest one, but the idea is generally applicable. It's not ignoring other scripts.
> Specify it in pixels?
This is a solved problem, the author presumably meant logical pixels (e.g. as used in CSS), not display pixels. Logical pixels map to display pixels either 1:1, 2:1, 3:1, etc. or by a non-integer ratio when other browser or OS zoom settings are used.
- jfk13 6y agoDo you really see a clear cap-height (and baseline, to measure it from) here? https://software.sil.org/awami/design/ https://software.sil.org/awami/design/ Or look at Thai: https://omniglot.com/writing/thai.htm https://omniglot.com/writing/thai.htm. Yes, there's a pretty clear upper and lower "line", but it's much more like an equivalent to ex-height in Latin than to cap-height. Giving it a different name doesn't help: if you put Latin text with 16px cap-height alongside Thai text with the "body" of the letters sized to 16px, they'll look awful (the Thai will be much too big). (As someone else has already said, ex-height is usually a more useful measure for Latin script, and that would be closer to matching how something like Thai might be measured -- though it'd be a bit on the small side. And it wouldn't interoperate well with Chinese, for example.)
- crazygringo 6y ago> Do you really see a clear cap-height (and baseline, to measure it from) here? I absolutely do. Do you... not? You can do a quick web search for "Arabic type anatomy" that will make it crystal clear for you. I mean it obviously has nothing to do with "capital" letters (so a more inclusive term would be better, probably), but there are clear upper and lower "bounds" beyond which ascenders/descenders poke out. The relative sizing of fonts (and line heights) across languages is a separate issue, and is complex. But it's a disaster in interfaces today, where e.g. traditional Chinese characters sized to cap height become virtually illegible they're so small.
- taejo 6y ago> I absolutely do. Do you... not? You can do a quick web search for "Arabic type anatomy" that will make it crystal clear for you. I also do not. When I search for that, I find articles like https://www.type-together.com/arabic-type-anatomy https://www.type-together.com/arabic-type-anatomy which say things like "Do not use ‘x-height’ and ‘cap height’ simply because there are no ‘x’ or capitals in Arabic." So since you do see such a thing, maybe you could show us? You could give a specific link or make a drawing.
- crazygringo 6y agoThe article you linked clearly shows lines labeled "baseline", "descender", "Latin x-height" and "ascender". And yes, it says do not use the term "cap height" but I already stated that a more inclusive term would be better. It's still obvious what's being referred to. In current practice (e.g. put roman and Arabic fonts next to each other on the same line in your browser), the Latin "baseline" and "cap height" lines clearly are conceptually equivalent to the Arabic "descender" and "ascender" lines. Do you see it now? I don't understand how anyone's trying to argue that there are languages that don't have obvious logical top/bottom boundaries (or right/left for vertical scripts) for basing font metrics on.
- taejo 6y ago> I don't understand how anyone's trying to argue that there are languages that don't have obvious logical top/bottom boundaries (or right/left for vertical scripts) for basing font metrics on. I don't argue that at all. I agree that Arabic has ascent and descent. I just don't see that Arabic ascent corresponds to Latin cap height (rather than, say, Latin ascent).
- int_19h 6y agoThe argument that the article is, essentially, trying to make is that some such correspondence obviously does exist visually - i.e. that you can write e.g. English and Arabic text in the same line, sized such that they look the same size.
- geraneum 6y agoFor people who are worried about Arabic script or Persian which uses the same script for a few centuries; you can define boundaries for the letters of said scripts. It is well studied and known to people who design fonts or typography for these scripts. You might need to adopt different approaches for achieving a similar outcome. My native language is Persian and by a simple search for “Anatomy of Persian Letters” in my native language, I found some easy to understand articles. For example in the following article it’s mentioned that the scale and boundaries are measured with with wrapping “dots” of a certain size around the letters. I imagine you can count those dots to define a container size equivalent to cap sizing. The link is in Persian/Farsi but you can recognize the dots and the shapes in the pictures. https://virgool.io/@typokhat/anatomy-of-perso-arabic-letters-alpqffeche1s https://virgool.io/@typokhat/anatomy-of-perso-arabic-letters... I am not a typography expert but I am interested in the article and wouldn’t shoot down the idea without hearing some expert opinions just because the scripts look different.