12 ms·
Social media addiction linked to cyberbullying
- motohagiography 6y agoSo sadism, basically. Social media, it's like the internet but without reason or accountability.
- cwkoss 6y agoI bet internet use is also highly correlated with cyberbullying
- undefined1 6y ago> The study also found that adolescent males are more likely to engage in cyberbullying than females, aligning with past studies that show aggressive behaviors tend to be more male driven. for a certain definition of aggression. but social media bullying is a Mean Girls phenomenon. it's reputation and character assassination, which is aggressive behavior. male aggression tends to be physical and they spend more time playing video games, while females spend more time on social media. as a result, girls are seeing higher rates of depression compared to boys. here's the research on this topic that Jonathan Haidt and other academics are maintaining; https://docs.google.com/document/d/1w-HOfseF2wF9YIpXwUUtP65-olnkPyWcgF5BiAtBEy0/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1w-HOfseF2wF9YIpXwUUtP65-...
- Solvitieg 6y agoBut if you remove the ability to be physically aggressive, would you expect the bullying to stop?
- abduhl 6y agoWhat is cyber bullying defined as in the study? I kill you in Counter Strike and drop a spray. Were you just cyber bullied? I kill you in COD and call you a newbie via voice. Were you just cyber bullied? I’m on your team in Dota and tell you that you’re terrible and should uninstall the game. Were you just cyber bullied? I tell our mutual friend group that you’re dating Jan the Man. Were you just cyber bullied? I tell everyone at our school that you’re bad at Fortnite. Were you just cyber bullied? I leak deep fake images of you getting fucked by a horse. Were you just cyber bullied? The answer to all these questions might be yes in this study, especially if it’s based on self reporting.
- watwut 6y ago> I tell our mutual friend group that you’re dating Jan the Man. I tell everyone at our school that you’re bad at Fortnite. This would be nice example of a male doing reputation assassination. It is also literally trying to use other people to get back at you. In any case, any of these should be judged by the exactly same standard as non-gaming situations are or situations which involve women are.
- watwut 6y agoMen do reputation and character assassination pretty routinely. They are no strangers to smear campaigns or even subtle manipulating group against one. Males use words for aggression quite a lot, actually.
- undefined1 6y agoyes, but it's not their primary mode of aggression and they're not as good at it.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoWhat I'm not seeing is what is going on in the lives of these people that fosters such negative behavior. These studies almost never ask questions like "Are you being abused by your parents?" or "Have you been molested?" There is this presumption that they engage in malicious behavior simply because they think they can get away with it, basically. It's an "idle hands are the devil's workshop" theory and generally lacks substance. Sure, people do all kinds of stupid stuff when bored and when they have time on their hands, but why are these young adolescents online all the time? Does this mean they have a terrible home life and no one is paying attention to them? I don't really like proxies like "Spends a lot of time online." I spend a lot of time online. I don't bully people. For me, the internet is a means to have a life when that wouldn't otherwise be possible. I earn income online. I have hobbies online. Etc. I really dislike the subtext that "spending time online is bad and more time spent online is worse." I would guess it is something more like "Spending time online to try to escape your shitty life in an abusive household means you take your baggage out on internet strangers because that seems safer and more do-able than resolving your thorny problems."
- skim_milk 6y agoIn this field, sending out surveys with "objective" questions to a large amount of people to collect data is the only way to get your research deemed "scientific". I think everyone would agree that the role of the scientists and writers of these pop-psych articles should be to interpret the point and help readers come to an insightful and true conclusion like yours, but really everyone in the psychology and journalism fields are forced to run a "I'm just reporting the facts like my boss wants me to" mantra to keep their job. It's kind of sad that this academic system makes it so only well-paid therapists get to do that, because of course looking at the current state of affairs in the world and coming to and reporting on and building insight on the logical conclusion that only hurt people hurt people isn't "scientific research" because the peers in your field only allow themselves and others to repeat what the numbers in the excel spreadsheet say. The psychology and objective journalism fields are great examples of dysfunctional academic systems. I like Alice Miller's hot take on her field in her book "For Your Own Good". I'm just going to straight up copy her text: Those who swear by statistical studies and gain their psychological knowledge from those sources will see my efforts to understand the children Christiane and Adolf [Hitler] as unnecessary and irrelevant. They would have to be given statistical proof that a given number of cases of child abuse later produced almost the same number of murderers. This proof cannot be provided, however, for the following reasons. Alice Miller lists off 1) child abuse takes place in secret 2) testimony of victims on their own suffered child abuse is often very flawed to protect their parents 3) experts in criminology have already noted this trend in their scientific research Even if statistical data confirm my own conclusions, I do not consider them a reliable source because they are often based on uncritical assumptions and ideas that are either meaningless (such as "a sheltered childhood"), vague, ambiguous ("received a lot of love"), or deceptive ("the father was strict but fair"), or that even contain obvious contradictions ("he was loved and spoiled"). This is why I do not care to rely on conceptual systems whose gaps are so large that the truth escapes through them, but rather prefer to make the attempt ... to take a different route. I am not searching for statistical objectivity but for the subjectivity of the victim in question, to the degree that my empathy permits.
- Jaygles 6y agoI wonder if social media had the potential to be a force of good or if it was doomed from the start. I'd like to run an AB experiment where social media companies didn't optimize for engagement. And maybe an AB experiment where they tried to optimize for healthy usage, even if it harmed engagement.
- renewiltord 6y agoSure. Instagram was that. They have limiters that will tell you to take a break, they have a marker that tells you you've caught up, and the default view is subscriptions-only. I only see my friends' stuff on Instagram and it's lovely. Though they've recently changed to stick random stuff underneath the last post from a friend which does diminish the point somewhat.
- Syonyk 6y agoI don't think social media was doomed from the start - there were many years of healthy enough communities (I'm mostly familiar with LiveJournal in the early 2000s) that didn't have all the downsides of modern social media. You saw updates in most-recent-first order, if you refreshed the page you got the same thing (perhaps with a new update at the top, but it was easy to tell when you'd caught up), and if you had too much stuff to read, you figured out how to trim some of it away ("FRIENDS CUT!"). The cost to operate the infrastructure was fairly minimal, and it accomplished most of the things we actually would like from social media without the downsides. What we haven't proved is that you can have social media run by a publicly traded, ad-revenue-funded company without all sorts of harmful effects (with the main interface being smartphones with push notifications). That's where all the nasty "engagement" effects come from - trying to drive eyeballs to ads to improve revenue. It's very much a zero-sum game - every pair of eyeballs has 24 hours in the day, so the goal is to command their attention for as many of those hours as possible. That's where the evil creeps in.
- TheJoYo 6y agoI've been using a chronological order social media for a couple of years now and I wouldn't trade it for a sorting algo. Sure, I miss some things that are likely interesting and sometimes I need to mute some that post too often. I think content tagging is what people were really asking for when they got "optimized for engagement."
- lbj 6y agoI feel like every week there's a new study that implies causation where none is proven and has no link to a root cause. "Possession of car linked to car crashes"
- ipsocannibal 6y agoNice to see research coming out of UGA showing up here on HN. Go Dawgs.
- ktkoffroth 6y agoGo Dawgs!
- ExcavateGrandMa 6y agoThe short of witnessing things... The scope from this mistake(social media's captiving attentionn not to say heritage alienation...), gonna have without preceding impact(s) to our societies... and this already materializing nowaday...
- swayvil 6y agoBeing online leads to a deep mental disturbance that just grows and grows. It's like you're hungry and you're reading through an endless stack of menus with this weird idea that the menus will sate your hunger. And you just keep on reading, about sandwiches, pizza and Chinese food. But none of the reading helps. You just keep on getting hungrier. I think that the Buddhists talk about this state, in their version of Hell. It's only natural that this would lead to "demoniacal" behavior.
- exo-pla-net 6y agoYou're being downvoted, but studies suggest your intuition is correct. People engage with social media at least in part out of social urges. However, consumption of social media leads to increased feelings of loneliness: https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/is-a-steady-diet-of-social-media-unhealthy-2018122115600 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/is-a-steady-diet-of-soci... So, social media is indeed a diet that just makes one hungrier. But does loneliness lead to more aggressive / "bullying" behavior? This hasn't been well studied, but evidence suggests this is the case: http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/comm/malamuth/pdf/85jspr2.pdf http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/comm/malamuth/pdf/85jspr2.pdf
- IndySun 6y agoHumans, their personalities and traits, have barely altered in 1000s of years. The internet is polarising the worst aspects. Humans haven't changed, but their worst behaviour is unleashed by anonymity.
- rland 6y agoWhen you interact online, you fundamentally are interacting with only yourself. It is a solipsistic endeavor. You fundamentally choose which comments to respond to; unlike the real world, where a conversation occurs between two people, you can instantly drive into a conversation whenever you see fit, and leave whenever you wish also. Therefore, the choice of which conversation, which comment, is entirely yours. And since the comments available are literally never-ending, you have the ultimate choice as to which you are responding. Therefore, every conversation you have is with a version of a person you have constructed in your head. This is what enables people to be mean and rude on the internet. It's because they are talking to a construct which is fundamentally in their own head, often times with their own nasty internal conflicts applied. This is also the fundamental mistake people make about the online world being a place where "discourse" can change anyone's internal landscape. It cannot, because it every discourse on the internet is by definition completely a subset of the ego of the single individual.
- swiley 6y agoThat's a neat idea but what about people who only see each other in real time chats (voice or text)? You can stop reading but AFK you can also walk away and it's pretty much the same.
- rland 6y agoI think texts/video calls/etc. isn't social media, it's much more like conversation. That's why people (in general) are not nearly as mean or rude on a voice call or a 1-to-1 text chat. When you hear someone's voice or actually engage with a real time conversation (like a text chat, which you can't as easily just walk away from), they develop an interiority to you that forces you to empathize with them. The physical world is the ultimate version of this: seeing a person's body and face forces you to acknowledge their internal life, because the shared physical experience forces it. That's why it's a much higher barrier to bully or be bullied in the physical world. There are exceptions to this, obviously. Tight knit forums, irc rooms, small moderated communities have an empathetic cost of interaction. But those are not really "social media", imho.
- endisneigh 6y agoI've thought about this problem a lot - I want to create a social network that has the following attributes: - $1 a year to participate - You must read posts/articles to reply. Imagine the mechanism in which this is determined to be "perfect." - No pictures - Karma is gathered by writing posts that are read a lot, as opposed to comments that have a lot of "upvotes." - Upvotes/downvoting doesn't exist. From my experience the social media addiction is heightened by 3 attributes: 1. pictures 2. how controversial something is 3. trolling The issue though is that a social network like I described would be something people wouldn't want to use, so it wouldn't really serve to be a place people could go to that's a healthier community. It's a tough nut to crack.
- kleer001 6y agoAdditionally, how would reading be measured?
- xwolfi 6y agoWhy do you want to build a platform for a community ? That s the thing. When I was a kid before facebook we had huge IRC and forum communities, with no ad, direct contact, true friends you d meet IRL sometimes. I know some who married. Facebook is the opposite of an online community: it takes your existing relationship graph, the one with true deep value you kept secret from the internet before, and milk and milk it for every drop of attention you can give your waking hours to ads. Whatever it takes.
- umvi 6y agoHowever you measure something being "read a lot" is basically the same thing as upvotes. People will try to game it to get more readers. Unless you are saying posts will not be sorted by popularity in which case discover-ability of good writing will be a problem (high noise to signal ratio).
- psychomugs 6y agoYouTube is a good example of players adapting to the game. Since view time became such an important metric, it’s been frustratingly difficult to find straight-to-the-point videos (that aren’t 10-second memes or TikTok reposts). It incentivizes repetition and meandering to stretch 1 minute of content into a 10 minute video.
- jancsika 6y agoAlright, "hackers": How the fuck do I use the adtech delivery system you generously gifted to me in order to read the body of a research article[1] from this public institution of higher learning? [1] https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/23727810.2020.1835420?journalCode=ucac20 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/23727810.2020.18...
- yesenadam 6y agoHmm the only way I can see right now is to pay US$45 (plus local tax) for the 13-page PDF. Which sounds insane.
- superkuh 6y agoThis is so trivial it's useless nonsense. This is like saying that that existing in reality is linked to bullying. Yes, sure, you have to exist in physical space to be non-cyberbullied. And you have to exist in a digital space to by cyberbullied.
- grawprog 6y agoMy opinions not so much on the study itself, but the topic of general shitty behaviour people seem to display on popular social media platforms. Personally, I think it has less to do with things like anonymity, up/downvotes and other gamey systems employed that tend to get blamed and more to do with the communities themselves. Specifically, their size. But also, the willingness of moderators to enforce a few basic rules of civility. I think they suffer from that same phenomenon that makes cities on a whole, less friendly than smaller towns and communities. I realize there's exceptions, but speaking generally this tends to be the case. To further the comparison a bit, you're also more likely to have the police respond with favourable results to personal and petty crime in smaller towns. You can see the same things in smaller internet communities. Whether they're pseudonymous or not or whatever kinds of upvoting systems they have or not, there's less people, moderators tend to respond more quickly to personal attacks and things and usually in more reasonable ways than automated algorithms. Again, generalizing, but when communities are small enough all the people participating are recognizable and when moderators are active in enforcing those basic rules of conduct, people tend to behave a little more reasonably. As a sidenote, I'll throw HN in as an exception to the size thing, because it's a pretty large community, but dang and the mods are like super human or something so manage to keep the conversation pretty civil most of the time here.
- robbyking 6y ago> I think they suffer from that same phenomenon that makes cities on a whole, less friendly than smaller towns and communities. There is data that shows the opposite is true[1]. While the pace of life is faster in urban areas -- which may be jarring to people aren't accustom to it -- living in areas with high population density teaches people to be courteous and respectful. [1] https://thepointsguy.com/news/are-new-yorkers-friendly/ https://thepointsguy.com/news/are-new-yorkers-friendly/
- grawprog 6y agoHaving lived in both types of communities, I question that data...
- hnbad 6y agoSocial media encourages dogpiling. "Engagement" measures shares, reactions and comments. Shares get more eyeballs on a post and "the algorithm" further promotes posts already garnering a lot of "engagement", creating a feedback loop. More eyeballs means more people commenting and a greater likelihood of repeating what has already been said, hence more dogpiling. Early online communities were not only much more heavily moderated than even sites like reddit or HN are today, but they also usually had explicit rules prohibiting dogpiling because it made it impossible to have a discussion or actually explain to someone why what they said may have been deemed offensive, inappropriate or wrong. If you spend more time "interacting" on social media, you probably encounter dogpiles more frequently and end up contributing to them more than someone who mostly just consumes social media and doesn't actively participate. This probably also means you face more of the resulting backlash, further polarizing your views of the "others". This seems to generally lead to one of two outcomes: Either you quit, or you embrace the angry surface level discourse and turn lashing out at people online into a hobby. You can see this happen in real time on Twitter because the character limit rewards witty one-liners and comebacks over wordy nuance (even if people try to work around this with threads, but note this doesn't work well for replies and this still requires replying several times in a row and results in notification spam).
- hnbad 6y agoTo put it differently: social media is competitive and encourages antagonistic behavior (because people are more likely to "engage" something snappy they disagree with, than something nuanced they agree with). Cyberbullying is just the extreme end of it. If we wanted to avoid this, we would need to encourage cooperation over competition. But even sites explicitly built around cooperation (like Stackoverflow) often end up promoting competitive behavior by introducing rewards and privileges for supposedly cooperative behavior. If you gamify cooperation and reward people for being "good at cooperating", you just create a competition with extra steps and this can still poison the well.