4 ms·
I would like a very simple electric car, simple motor(s), simple electronics to repair, no GPS or phone home necessary (I want to download on my time, send me a
by stjohnswarts 6y ago
I would like a very simple electric car, simple motor(s), simple electronics to repair, no GPS or phone home necessary (I want to download on my time, send me a text/email/whatever about critical downloads). I want something easy and cheap to repair, have the simplicity of electric motors, and run 20 years with very little maintenance. I don't 30 computers running on my computer. I just want to get from A to B and it not cost me 80-100k for a decent electric vehicle. Tesla and others are overengineered for what they do and that complexity adds to failure rate and cost of ownership.
- Afton 6y agoAren't you describing a Nissan Leaf? I can't really speak to the repairability, because even though I've had it 2 years, I haven't had to do anything but charge it. Oh, once I had to put more air in the tires. Great little car, with about a 70 mile range on my 2017 model.
- waiseristy 6y agoYou're not going to get around the 5-10 computers required for basic 21st century automotive safety. But, the rest of what you are describing is the status-quo for quite a few Chinese 'budget' brands. I'm betting once EVs start making their way into fleets, you'll find your 300k mile, low maintenance, minimal electronics American/German brand.
- elihu 6y agoOne way to get what you're asking for is to do a conversion (or pay someone else to do it, or buy one that someone is selling). I'm in the middle of converting a Mazda RX-8. Just got the motor/clutch/transmission assembly (mostly) in place last weekend. It's kind of fun, but it's also a lot of work. It seems like a tremendously inefficient way to get the car I want: electric, no phone-home or over-the-air update capability, ability to control how everything works, easy to fix, manual transmission, modern safety features. I thought about buying a Model 3, but decided it was a lot of money for something that wasn't quite what I want. 200+ mile range would have been nice though; it's hard to get that in a conversion without making it unreasonably heavy.
- astrange 6y agoWhy do you want an electric car with a transmission? It doesn't have an engine in the first place.
- elihu 6y agoPartly because shifting gears is fun. Partly because you can get more usable power out of the motor with a transmission. It's a bit of a trade-off. To use Tesla as an example, they take the approach of just putting a massively overpowered motor in each car so that they can overcome the lack of a low gear. That works fine, but the kind of parts you need in that sort of system are expensive. Not just the motor, but the motor controller and the batteries have to handle that much power. A different approach is to just have a normally-sized motor and an ability to shift gears. It should make for a lighter, more efficient car. (Though you also lose some efficiency in the gearbox.) The conversion I'm doing has a 120 horsepower motor, and it's going into a car that's about 3,000 pounds. I won't win any 0-60 races with a Model S, but it'll probably handle corners better and generally be more fun to drive, not to mention be about 1500 to 2000 pounds lighter. I'm willing to concede that wanting an EV with a stickshift may be an unpopular opinion, but it's hard to know if there's a market for that kind of thing until someone starts manufacturing it. (And I don't mean the Taycan, I mean something that some ordinary middle-class person might buy.) It seems kind of a shame that we have all these legacy car companies that know how to build transmissions, but none of them seem interested in using that as an advantage they have over Tesla for that part of the market that want an electric car but would rather drive a manual transmission.
- natch 6y agoI suppose back in the day there were those who missed the buggy whip.
- natch 6y ago>it'll probably handle corners better and generally be more fun to drive Sounds like a very educational project. I wouldn't be so quick to just brush off Tesla engineering as having bad tradeoffs, or make assumptions about the fun of cornering, but I'm sure the project will be an eye opener and maybe will lead you to test drive an M3P sometime. Definitely it's hard to beat an RX8 with cornering but that's before you load it down with batteries. Edit: I had some doubts about your weight claims but I wasn't thinking about the fact that you are losing the engine weight, which puts you pretty far ahead! Sounds like a cool project.