3 ms·
I ask because following that incident I will no longer be presenting dissenting views here, irrespective of perceived value. Presenting a dissenting opinion is
by Mz 15y ago
I ask because following that incident I will no longer be presenting dissenting views here, irrespective of perceived value.
Presenting a dissenting opinion is an art form. It takes practice. I do a lot of it. I never really fit in anywhere I go. An awful lot of my views do not fit into whatever the 'typical' assumptions are on a topic and this means that no matter what I say, both sides often wind up kicking the crap out of me.
Some tips, should you decide you would like to try again:
Don't be argumentative about it. Present your views as a standing-on-your-own-two-feet position, not a shooting-down-the-opposition thing.
Show some respect -- agree to disagree, make no attempt to "win people over", much less "win".
Stick to the issues. When you dissent, inevitably there will be enormous social pressure swirling around your lack of going along to get along. Anyone who speaks to you will likely try to put all kinds of crap on you about what they think you are saying. Politely clarify, as many times as it takes.
Judge the timing and context carefully. There is a time and place to offer an alternate point of view. There are other times and places where it's so not worth it.
Word your dissent very carefully. If your goal is to get people to really think and not just punch buttons, like it or not, the burden is on the minority voice to make an effort to communicate effectively. If you are going along with the majority opinion, you can express yourself sloppily and people won't care. But when stating a minority opinion, you must be extra careful to work at communicating effectively and intentionally avoid punching people's buttons so as to have some hope of actually being heard.