3 ms·
> yet Wikipedia continues to use the term “Dark Ages” as the article title. The article is about the history of the term "Dark Ages", why shouldn't that be the
by jcranmer 6y ago
> yet Wikipedia continues to use the term “Dark Ages” as the article title.
The article is about the history of the term "Dark Ages", why shouldn't that be the the title? If you go by link counts, there are 741 links to the Dark Ages page but 2582 to the Early Middle Ages instead.
> Why don’t they use the term and what term is preferred instead?
"Dark Ages" is itself somewhat ambiguous. In its original incarnation, it referred to the entirety of the time between the "Fall of Rome" (itself hard to specify) and the Renaissance, as its early users saw Rome as the pinnacle of human civilization and looked down on everything following the end of Rome as unimportant, at least until they themselves were bringing back the splendor of Roman civilization. Later scholars were instead nostalgic for the High or Late Medieval civilization, so instead they narrowed the term to exclude their favored era, resulting in it referring to only the Early Middle Ages (to ~1000). Some people go further still and exclude the Carolingian Renaissance from the Dark Ages, pushing its end date further still to 800--there's no neat alternative term for this range, but Age of Migrations covers much of the themes.
In any case, periodization of that time period of European history is immensely challenging. The decline of the Roman Empire brings with it a decline in the written record and our knowledge of events in the period diminishes drastically, only recovering with the Carolingian Renaissance. Furthermore, the Roman Empire doesn't fall in an easy cataclysmic moment (there's no Battle of Hastings here), but instead disintegrates at different rates in different parts of Europe, with the final vestige only falling in 1475 (Principality of Theorodo). Meanwhile, there are several overlapping themes going on: the rise of Post-Roman kingdoms (such as the Franks and the Lombards), a mass migration of peoples (including the Anglo-Saxons and various Slavic groups), the Viking Age, the birth of Islam, the Great Schism between Eastern and Western Christianity (and other schisms within those sects!). For the boundary between the Middle Ages and the Early Modern, you can point to "about 1500" and note that several major changes happen about the same time (including total conversion to gunpowder weapons, Protestant Reformation, discovery of the New World, and the Fall of Constantinople)--that doesn't exist between Antiquity and the Middle Ages.
- michaelpb 6y ago"The Roman Empire never fell, DEBATE ME" Though seriously, thanks for writing this up. This is a great explanation of how periodization says more about the "periodizer" than it represents some sort of objective truth about history, magically divorced from the political reality of successive historical writers. Debunking bad history is important... in this field (CS) I've definitely met my share of so-called "STEMacists" whose mental model of history sometimes seems to be derived from Deus Vult memes... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- BrandoElFollito 6y ago> including total conversion to gunpowder weapons Could you please comment in a few words on that? You gave a very, very interesting overview of the period, thanks!
- jcranmer 6y agoThe key gunpowder weapon I'm talking about here is the arquebus, which simultaneously incorporated three critically important innovations: the long barrel, the matchlock trigger [1], and the shoulder stock. The first weapons having all of these simultaneously starts to crop up around 1480-ish in Iberia. Effectively, these weapons are the earliest weapons that operate rather similarly to the modern military rifle. Prior to gunpowder weapons, the primary infantry weapons are going to be some variant of pike or a warbow or crossbow (if you're an archer). Earlier hand-held gunpowder weapons than the arquebus exist, but they are more unwieldy weapons and as a result don't supplant the dominant infantry weapons. But when arquebuses show up, armies change fast. By about 1520, every European army is using them. I don't have firm stats on the rest of the world, but by the early 1600s, pretty much every conflict--including indigenous peoples attempting to resist European colonizers--involves both sides using gunpowder weapons. Pikes weren't rendered obsolete until the development of the bayonet in the 17th century, but the infantry units needed to mix pikemen and arquebusiers to be competitive, basically modern combined-arms doctrine but happening 500 years ago. [1] In this case, a "match" is a burning piece of rope that is used to ignite the primer. The key innovation here is that a mechanism is used to hold the match so that it can be inserted into the primer by moving a trigger.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoThank you very much. My vision of medieval armies was similar to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_warfare#/media/File:Battle_of_crecy_froissart.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medieval_warfare#/media/File:B... (this is just an example) - where the battle was done with pikes and swords.
- acjohnson55 6y agoDon't forget the printing press!