19 ms·
> False equivalency; no one is arguing that. Really? Can someone clarify what my earlier quoted passage was referencing then? I wasn't trying to straw-man the
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> False equivalency; no one is arguing that.
Really? Can someone clarify what my earlier quoted passage was referencing then? I wasn't trying to straw-man the OP.
> However, a multi-polar world is appealing. The US is certainly not always a good actor here either: the US has 50+ years of foreign interventions to point to that span the globe, particularly the middle east, latin america, and southeast asia.
The Cold War (and most/all of those foreign-interventions that you object to) were products of a multi-polar world. I don't know that this is a good thing. I understand and empathize with the "competition is good" impulse, but I don't think it bears out in history.
> It would be in Europe (and other regions') interest to be able to defend their own interests on equal footing with the US. Currently, they cannot do that (military and economic dependence). Having China offers leverage. I.e., the US will be incentivized to behave better if other countries can say "well if you push us too far, we'll work with China."
I understand and empathize with this as well, as noted above.
- fatjokes 6y ago>> False equivalency; no one is arguing that. >Really? Can someone clarify what my earlier quoted passage was referencing then? I wasn't trying to straw-man the OP. IIUC, OP's quote just means that a lot of existing books do try to make that argument, i.e., that the only outcome of the US losing its position is for China to take it, as opposed to a multi-polar world (and thus, it would be in the reader's best interest to support US hegemony).