3 ms·
I totally feel that. But it's OK. It's only HN. There's plenty of places to feel hopeful about the future and optimistic. Research departments are one place. Yo
by graderjs 6y ago
I totally feel that. But it's OK. It's only HN. There's plenty of places to feel hopeful about the future and optimistic. Research departments are one place. Your own head could be another. Maybe some of reddit. Some blogs. And like minded people in atomspace.
HN values "intellectualism" so it has to be very cautious to throw its unbridled enthusiasm behind something new that it doesn't understand, unless it turns out wrong. The memory of being wrong, and having to face that stupidity or ignorance I think is too much for the intellectual HN superego to bear, so instead it hedges toward caution and skepticism. These are the default and "sensible" positions if you value not being wrong, and seeming right, and if the cost of "looking stupid" is too perceptually high.
I'm not being too bearish on HN. The flipside is you can have great informed discussions, with less noise and fluff than elsewhere. But you can't find people so readily welcoming of brave new worlds here. They are here, it's just that the community sentiment / mass consciousness / superego of the place shames and punishes any such enthusiasm that isn't backed by hard facts and Wikipedia pages and common knowledge, etc. And even then it's not on the whole welcomed as much as scrutinized, pushed-back against, cross-examined and interrogated. So that's a reaction limiter on those voices speaking up here enthusiastically. Hey, they still do tho. Me included.
I disliked it at first, and extreme examples I still dislike. But I get it's just someone else's way of engaging or seeing the world. That's a valid perspective, just as much as mine. Even if I don't share it. It doesn't matter. Different perspectives are normal.
And I find the awareness I now have of how the HN organism might react to some post a useful different perspective. I don't temper my enthusiasm for new stuff with it, but before posting here, maybe I'll consider how people might react. Maybe they won't be able to appreciate it.
But at the same time. HN is not homogenous. It's amorphous and ever changing. The superego sentiment shifts, and there can be many examples of HN embracing the new.
Given all that, it's good to see voices actually seeking to engage more enthusiastically and openly with newness emerge from the codified skeptical pit that is HN. I think this picture that I paint above misses alot of the details and it probably only 61-62% accurate but it's a fair enough take on HN that I think might clarify some things for people, and certainly does for me.
Tho honestly in the case of this article I would love to see more technical analysis and less skepticism (or meta posts like mine). I know I'm contributing to that, I'm just not skilled enough in this area right now to analyze it, but would love to read discussion of the technical details.
- stocknoob 6y agoExcellent description of the HN mentality. Many are so afraid of false positives they'll do a middlebrow dismissal of everything. "Actually, XYZ isn't that great because..." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24613148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24613148
- graderjs 6y agoAnd that's a great concise way to say it! I suppose if I were smarter or a better writer those are the exact words I would come up with. Many are so scared of false positives they do a middlebrow dismissal of everything. exactly, Hahaha! Thanks :)