6 ms·
A whole new world: Ars reviews the Galaxy Tab 10.1
- dr_ 15y ago"This makes it extremely difficult to evaluate products shipped in such incomplete form. " No it doesn't. If that's what they give you, that's what you review. If x is missing, you say the product lacks x. If the manufacturer is not happy with that, then maybe they shouldn't release the product until it's fully functional.
- spiralganglion 15y agoIf anyone is hoping for Samsung to value perfection at launch over being one of the first-to-market in every Android form factor, they're holding out for a Galaxy far, far away. But it seems to be working well (enough) for Samsung. I agree, though, that reviews should always be based on what the reviewer has in-hand. Every review I've read for non-Apple tablets has offered some "benefit of the doubt" that the iPad never got... or needed.
- NaOH 15y agoI'd be curious to know the longer-term traffic data for sites which do these types of reviews. Folks like us are quick to read these reviews, but I wonder how many regular users are reading them, say, four months down the road. I know when I'm researching a purchase about which my knowledge is nothing noteworthy, the immediate reviews (like this one from Ars) are beneficial to me when compared to later reviews because it enables me to see how the product has developed over time.
- benologist 15y agoI think long term traffic is a major focus for them all - the products become released, they probably have great success sending people straight from reviews to vendors through advertisements - if they can secure good positions in search engines. Content farms like Engadget (Ars are much higher quality) try pretty hard to corner Google rankings for products, manufacturers and everything else. Here's an Engadget review of the same product: http://www.engadget.com/2011/06/08/samsung-galaxy-tab-10-1-review/ http://www.engadget.com/2011/06/08/samsung-galaxy-tab-10-1-r... - 18 internal links to their own garbage articles and tag pages which only exist for search engines - 20 tags that cover everything they could think of that you might put into Google: android 3.1, android tablet, Android3.1, AndroidTablet, galaxy tab, Galaxy Tab 10.1, GalaxyTab, GalaxyTab10.1, google, honeycomb, review, Samsung, Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1, SamsungGalaxyTab10.1, slate, tab, tablet, tablet pc, TabletPc, video - no external links that might accidentally boost someone else's SERPs
- dkarl 15y agoOn the other hand... We currently have no way of knowing how Samsung's software customizations will impact the Tab 10.1's performance, reliability, or battery life when TouchWiz eventually gets rolled out to consumers. ...don't ignore the possibility that things might get worse when the manufacturer's "enhancements" and "features" are added, and readers who go by a review of the product in its current state might be disappointed with the product they get next month.
- emehrkay 15y agoGruber keeps spazzing about the slant given to "incomplete" products and he does have a point.
- richcollins 15y agoHe spazzed in the other direction when it came to the iPhone (copy/paste et al)
- thaumaturgy 15y ago> ...then maybe they shouldn't release the product until it's fully functional. But ... but ... but what about all the advice we keep hearing about MVPs and "ship ship ship" and "iterate" and...?
- drivebyacct2 15y ago"ship ship ship" is hard when it comes to hardware. As for the software side of things, I'd say "QA", but I find the dev/release cycles at these major phone/tablet manufacturers to be unbelievably slow. As in, I really don't understand what they're doing a lot of the time. 5 volunteers working on CM can fix and implement features in the time it takes Motorola's team to do a `git merge` on Android and push it out to their phones (yes, even non-Blur phones).
- thaumaturgy 15y agoI wonder if a lot of what we read about software development methodology is to blame for this? I would expect that individual and freelance developers, and developers at small companies, are more likely to practice "cowboy programming" -- use frameworks, glue them together, write code, handle (most) edge cases, exercise the most basic of best practices -- while larger companies, like Motorola, are more likely to practice something that a manager read about in a book or a consultant sold them on -- "waterfall development", "test-driven development", etc. (Not that I have anything against those methods, but they would tend to slow down development in a corporate environment.)
- drivebyacct2 15y agoI'm not sure it's so cut and dry. If you look at how CM releases are managed... they're very well done. Nightly build servers, good communication on their GitHub and Gerrit, very stable builds considering their nightly builds, all the dozens of phones exist as the larger CM project. I know you were speaking more generally, but I don't know that one or the other is always better, whether it's speed or style or development workflow.
- 15y ago
- martincmartin 15y agoIf that's what they give you, that's what you review. If x is missing, you say the product lacks x. While that would be satisfying for the writer, the reader wants to know what it will be like to own one. They may buy one several months from now, and keep using it for years. The author is saying they can't evaluate the dominant experience of actual users.
- sorbus 15y agoWait, are you saying that it is impossible to write a review that is useful for the reader unless it is a review of a product which is not going to change in the future?
- wowamit 15y agoChange is fine if it is aimed at making the overall experience better. From what we have seen in the past, any UI layer an OEM adds above stock Android just makes the overall experience worse, performance wise mainly. The reviews would never be able to foresee that.
- floppydisk 15y agoSamsung looks like they are just trying to be the first and grab market share with the first Honeycomb tablet. Looking at this and the iPad, my question still is: what do I use this for? On the go my smartphone handles all my computing tasks and at home I have several boxes for at home computation. Where is this supposed to fit in?
- drivebyacct2 15y agoI'm with you. The only thing I'd imagine is the ASUS Transformer if it had a full copy of Chrome. Then it would just be a nice netbook with all of Android and an even more compact form factor for when it might make sense.
- nissimk 15y agoI think it's fair to say that will be available soon. I think dual boot to ubuntu on the ee-pad transformer is coming within the next couple of weeks and chromium os shouldn't be far behind.
- avstraliitski 15y agoTablets are good for restaurants, stock taking and other specialised uses. Though they will soon fight the connected TV in the lounge room, right now they are a good option to have about the house if you just want to read or browse and remain mobile. Depending upon how their price and applications develop (very much in flux right now, it seems) against other platforms (PC, mobile, connected TV) I expect we'll see a leveling out in tablet growth. One thing's apparently for sure: they've killed the underpowered 'netbook' concept (finally).
- kenjackson 15y agoIMO the top use of the iPad is for little kids (think 10 and younger). It's the modern Gameboy. The other big reason is as an eReader. I just don't find the web, virtual keyboard, and other apps to be interesting enough to grab me if there is a desktop/laptop alternative. And their too large for me to take everywhere I take my phone. With that said, I have little doubt that touch-based computers will come to dominate, although I think convertibles will actually turn out to be quite popular. Unlike cellphones, an actual keyboard on a tablet is HUGE win.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- martincmartin 15y agoBottom line (according to TFA): The Tab 10.1 is a much more credible product than the Xoom, but it's not quite competitive with the iPad. If Google wants to compete, it still needs to build a vibrant third-party application ecosystem in order to make Android tablets a good option for regular users.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoHm, I'm curious... what do people want to see Google do in order to convince them? People are developing for Android in droves on mobile phones because they finally (and I do mean finally, the writing on the walls was clear before any major Android app explosion)... do they not assume that a similar effect will happen for Android tablets?
- ugh 15y agoIt hasn't happened yet and reviewers don't have a time machine. What should they write? "Well, the app ecosystem sucks but might well improve in the future, maybe"?
- drivebyacct2 15y agoUh, I was asking what will motivate developers. I agree with the consensus here. If it's not shipping with apps, and it's shipping with features missing... it should be reviewed that way. And besides, saying "Oh, 3g sucks but you can mail it off for a week to get LTE" is 100% completely different than saying "We expect the Android tablet ecosystem to grow". Do you think I bought my D1 thinking that I'd be stuck with a trash Facebook app and basically no other apps to speak of? Again, I don't expect or even have a desire for reviewers to go out of their way to make such excuses... my entire post was just questioning WHY the ecosystem is so dry, even though the Honeycomb SDK has been available (albeit in a flawed state initialy) for so long.
- zmmmmm 15y agoIt's off to a pretty slow start. Android on phones was coming from nothing. On tablets it's different - I expected a much faster takeup with at very least a huge number of developers doing minimal tweaks and updating graphics just so they could be in the small pool of tablet apps and get more exposure by calling themselves "HD" or "Honycomb compatible". But if I understand right (and I'm not able to test this directly) there is still only a very small number of apps specialised for tablets. I think part of the problem was the very anemic Xoom launch which simply didn't get many devices into developers hands, especially outside the US, and the quite unusable Honeycomb emulator which also turned off many devs from even trying to support Honeycomb. Google tried to fix that at Google IO but they should do much more. It's worth noting another part of this is confusion about how Android works - there is no reason to create a "honeycomb specific app" on Android. The whole point of Android's layout and fragment infrastructure is to let you easily make an app that seamlessly caters to any number of form factors. So the idea of looking for and counting apps that are dedicated to Honeycomb is silly - it's not surprising there aren't many of those, and those that do have specific support for Honeycomb aren't necessarily labeled that way in the market like they are in iTunes (which is a problem with the market).
- benologist 15y agoI got a Galaxy Tab (the old one) over the weekend, overall I find the experience pretty disappointing: - I never knew how much I loved hating iTunes, until suddenly everything had to be done manually - it really sucks to buy a game, fire it up and discover it's a shitty mobile version stretched to fit your screen. I'm especially disappointed in PopCap for doing that w/ PvZ!
- hugh3 15y agoExcuse my ignorant question: if I buy one of these is there any (vaguely legal) way I can use it to watch movies on long flights? edit: Never mind, I found out for myself. Rip from DVD to some wacky format, obtain app to play it. Perhaps I'll consider it, now I find myself flying (bleh) United with its severe lack of video.
- richcollins 15y agoYes! http://dekorte.com/projects/shareware/MovieDownloader/ http://dekorte.com/projects/shareware/MovieDownloader/